Mario Tennis Fever received generally favorable reviews from critics, according to the
review aggregation website
Metacritic. Fellow review aggregator
OpenCritic assessed that the game received strong approval from critics.
IGNs Logan Plant commended the game for its "exciting multiplayer moments, great controls, and a huge character roster" while viewing Adventure Mode as "more of an extended
tutorial than an actual adventure". In his review for
Nintendo Life, PJ O'Reilly referred to
Mario Tennis Fever as his "favourite game in the series thus far, by finding an addictive balance between Mario's madcap antics and real-world tennis fun", though he criticized the lack of
single-player content, as well as Adventure Mode, which he viewed as "a letdown" for being "disappointingly short and rather basic". Reviewing the game for
PCMag, Jordan Minor summarized
Mario Tennis Fever as "a must-have Switch 2 game that I recommend to anyone who fancies a bonkers spin on traditional racket competition", praising the game modes, "[c]risp, colorful" presentation, and unlockables while criticizing the linearity of Adventure Mode, as well as mild lag in online matches. Donovan Erskine of
Shacknews deemed
Mario Tennis Fever "a competent tennis game with plenty of variation and a high skill ceiling", particularly for its on-court gameplay, extensive character roster, and new Fever Racket gimmick. Steve Watts of
GameSpot felt that the Fever Rackets helped create "the best Mario sports game in years", as well as viewing Adventure Mode as "a short and sweet story with lots of variety and clever boss fights". Several critics highlighted the high price. On
Giant Bomb, Jeff Grubb felt, "the mechanics are solid, but nothing outside of the core tennis gameplay is that much fun...At $70? A game like Fever feels lazy and rote." The review from
The A.V. Club felt that despite the overall competence of the game, Nintendo was wasting the potential of the developing studio, with critic Dia Lacina openly calling for Camelot Software to make a new RPG; "Instead of hamstringing the company that gave us
Golden Sun...Stop asking the Takahashis and their studio to sleepwalk through Mario-branded sports games, and let them cook again." ==Notes==