After a year of training and auditioning, Brody landed the role of
Barry Williams in the television film
Growing Up Brady (2000) and appeared in the Canadian comedy series
The Sausage Factory. In 2001, he had a minor role in
American Pie 2. Brody's first major television role came in 2002, when he was cast in a recurring role on the third season of the comedy-drama series
Gilmore Girls as
Dave Rygalski, Lane's bandmate and love interest. In 2003, Brody appeared in the movie
Grind and the music video for "Too Bad About Your Girl" by
the Donnas. That year, he was cast in his breakout role as
Seth Cohen on the teen drama series
The O.C., where he reportedly improvised some of the character's comedic dialogue. In 2005, Brody had a supporting role in the film
Mr. & Mrs. Smith, and played a Hollywood studio assistant in the film adaptation of
Thank You for Smoking (2006). which was released in April 2011. In 2011, he voiced Woodie in the MTV animated series
Good Vibes, and appeared in
The Oranges. In January 2012, it was announced that Brody had joined the cast of
Lovelace, a biopic about late 1970s porn star
Linda Lovelace, directed by
Rob Epstein and
Jeffrey Friedman. Brody portrayed
Harry Reems. He starred in
Some Girl(s), which premiered at the 2013
SXSW Festival. He appeared in
Life Partners (2014). In 2015, he appeared in
Sleeping with Other People and starred as Billy Jones in
Direct TV's sitcom
Billy and Billie. In 2016, Brody starred in
Sony Crackle's drama series
StartUp. He played the older version of
Jack Dylan Grazer's character in the superhero film
Shazam! and starred in the thriller
Ready or Not, directed by
Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and
Tyler Gillett for
Fox Searchlight. The films were released in April and August 2019, respectively, both to positive reviews. Brody has also appeared as Max Larssen in the eight-part drama
Curfew, beginning in February 2019. In 2024, he co-starred in the first season of
Netflix's
Nobody Wants This as
Rabbi Noah Roklov who starts dating
Kristen Bell's character, Joanne, a
shiksa. His performance earned him a nomination for the
Golden Globe Award for Best Actor – Television Series Musical or Comedy and
Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series. ==Other works==