Early circuits (1880s and 1890s) The birth of semi-professional football can be traced back to the 1880s, when most
sports clubs in America had a team playing football, and ostensibly played without paid players. In reality, most teams often found ways around that, and acquired the best players with the promise of jobs and trophies or watches to play against top regional clubs and colleges. While the practice of professional and semi-pro teams playing college and amateur teams was common in the 1880s and 1890s, most notably with the establishment of a coalition of teams that operated from 1886 to 1895 in the New York metropolitan area called the
American Football Union, in the 20th century college and professional football began to diverge, and college-professional interplay effectively ended after the NCAA formed in 1906. During this time, the most prominent circuit was the
Western Pennsylvania Professional Football Circuit.
Leagues form (1900s-1920s) The first attempt to form a pro league was the
National Football League of 1902, which, despite its name, was a Pennsylvania regional league, with two teams based in
Philadelphia and the third from
Pittsburgh. The next step came when promoter
Tom O'Rourke established the
World Series of Football, also in 1902. The series played indoors at
New York City's Madison Square Garden and consisted of five teams: three from the state of
New York, one from
New Jersey, and another team called New York comprising two Philadelphia teams, the
Athletics and Phillies. The 1903 series also featured the
Franklin Athletic Club from Pennsylvania. In 1934, the
American Football League (AFL) was the first true attempt to establish pro football in the American South and Southwest regions. The league was formed by the strongest independent teams in the region, including the
Memphis Tigers, who claimed the
national pro championship in 1929, after beating the NFL champion
Green Bay Packers. The AFL had only one season of competition and folded after only the Memphis Tigers and Charlotte Bantams completed their seasons. Another strong southern league was the
Dixie League, which represented
Mid Atlantic teams. The league was one of the most successful minor leagues in history, playing eight seasons in eleven years, while claiming to be the highest level minor football league of the era. Unlike most pro-football minor leagues, the Dixie League had a relative stable membership until the
Pearl Harbor attack forced the league into hiatus. The league returned in 1946, but folded in 1947 after playing only one week. The Dixie League's biggest counterpart was the
American Association (AA) football league. The AA was formed by the nucleus of independent teams that played in the New York and New Jersey circuits, and was led by president
Joe Rosentover. The league teams sought relationships with the NFL, and several teams, including the Newark Bears, Brooklyn Eagles, and Jersey City Giants, functioned as a farm system for the major NFL teams. The league allowed black players to participate, including the last African-American in the NFL in 1933,
Joe Lillard. Most teams scheduled games against the independent
Fritz Pollard's
Harlem Brown Bombers. The league closed operations during World War II, and after a four-year hiatus, the AA was renamed the American Football League and expanded to include teams in Ohio and Pennsylvania. The league's demise was caused by the NFL severing ties with all minor league teams in 1948. The last of the "Big Three Leagues" was the
Pacific Coast Professional Football League, which started in 1940. The roots of pro football in the west are attributable to the
Red Grange barnstorming tour with the
Chicago Bears in 1926, as some short-lived leagues, including the 1926
Pacific Coast Professional Football League (PCPFL) and 1934–1935
American Legion League, were formed. The PCPFL was formed thanks to the financial backbone of the sport in
California, the
Los Angeles Bulldogs, billed as the "best football team in existence outside the NFL", and the only prominent minor football league to operate during the war years. The league became home to the top African American football talents in the country, including
Kenny Washington,
Woody Strode,
Ozzie Simmons,
Mel Reid, and briefly
Jackie Robinson during the NFL enforced color barrier. The league played its last season in 1948, two years after the NFL moved the
Los Angeles Rams to Los Angeles. The Big Three reached an agreement with the NFL, and in 1946 formed the
Association of Professional Football Leagues as a formal farm system with the league. The agreement lasted less than two years, after the NFL cancelled it altogether in 1948.
The second wave (1960-1970s) The minor leagues experienced a renaissance in the 1960s and 1970s; their growing relevance occurred alongside the
AFL and NFL rivalry. In April 1964, the two leagues, along with the
Central States Football League, the
Midwest Football League, and the
Southern Football League, formed the
Association of Minor Football Leagues. The association also included the non-paying semi-pro
New England Football Conference, and appointed UFL commissioner
George T. Gareff as the
CEO. The association represented teams in fifty cities spanning twenty-one U.S. states plus Quebec, and scheduled exhibition games between leagues, but disbanded after two years without making any strides. When the UFL folded and the
Newark Bears of the ACFL unsuccessfully applied to join the AFL, two new national leagues formed. The first was the
North American Football League (NAFL), which lasted from 1965 to 1967 and played in the Midwest, essentially replacing the UFL, the
North Pacific Football League (NPFL), and the
Texas Football League (TFL), which operated in the southern United States. Those leagues would later merge with the CoFL, as several teams from the NPFL joined the league in 1966, and the PFLA followed in 1968, resulting in the dissolution of both leagues. In 1969, the CoFL announced the all eight teams from TFL were being added to its ranks as a separate division, and were scheduled to play mostly against each other, along with a few inter-league contests. The two bigger leagues, the CoFL and ACFL, had different strategies: the CoFL aimed to remain independent, while the ACFL functioned as a developmental league and, like previous Rosentover leagues, allowed its teams to become farm teams for the AFL and NFL. The ACFL also produced some significant talent, such as
Pro Bowler
Marvin Hubbard, first female professional football player
Patricia Palinkas, who was placeholder for her husband Stephen, and cult figure
King Corcoran. It also lasted longer. The league operated continuously through 1971, with a return season in 1973, which was played mostly by promoted teams from the lower-level
Seaboard Football League (SFL), which in turn, brought up semi-pro teams to replace them. However, the attempted major
World Football League (WFL) sapped both leagues of most of their talent, forcing them to fold by 1974. The league's first collapse in 1972, along with the demise of the
Midwest Professional Football League, ended the era of NFL teams having individual farm teams. During its existence, the SFL hovered between a minor league and semi-pro, as some of its players, most notably
Joe Klecko, were never paid, and others received only fifty dollars per game. Despite that, the league had some notable alumni, including
Vince Papale,
Jack Dolbin, and Klecko. Additionally, the league was the last minor league to play an inter-league exhibition match against an NFL team, when the
New York Jets rookies defeated
Long Island Chiefs 29–3. The AFA followed the model set by the TAFL, and played its from May to August. The formation of the first
United States Football League (USFL) in 1982 led to a decline in AFA talent, a move to semi-pro status, and a cancellation of the league entirely after the 1983 season. The USFL dominated minor league football from 1983 to 1985, but folded after a failed lawsuit against the NFL led by team owner
Donald Trump. Near the end of the era, there was one last attempt to organize non-NFL pro teams under one umbrella, with the establishment of the
Minor Professional Football Association, which represented more than 200 teams and about 10,000 players. From 1980 through 1985, the association sponsored an annual post-season championship tournament for minor league teams, with an attempt to establish a minor-league system. In 1981 the association reached an agreement with the NFL to hold a special national all-star game for minor leaguers, the day before the
Super Bowl, with scouts in attendance. The NFL had the right to sign any player from the association for a $1,500 payment to the team that held his contract. But the agreement did not continue, and in 1986 the association reformed into the
American Football Association (AFA) and focused on providing services to semi-pro and amateur teams around the US. The development of
arena football and the birth of the
Arena Football League (AFL) in 1987 effectively ended the era, reducing most outdoor leagues to amateur or semi-pro status.
WLAF and NFL Europe (1990s) After the turmoil in the 1980s, the NFL decided to form its own league in 1991, the
World League of American Football, as a spring developmental league. For the first time, an American sport league had a European division as part of its ten-team league, while the other teams were located in continental US and Canada. The league was used to test rule changes and technical innovations and planned as a farm system for NFL teams. However, the first two seasons produced low TV ratings, and the league was put on hiatus until 1995. When it came back, the league was based entirely in Europe, reduced to six teams, and re-branded in 1998 as NFL Europe. The league kept the same format until 2007, when the NFL terminated it. Ultimately, the league was one of the longest tenured high-level minor leagues in history, lasting fifteen years in total and producing players like Hall of Famer
Kurt Warner and Super Bowl quarterbacks
Brad Johnson and
Jake Delhomme. Other notable players include
Dante Hall,
David Akers,
James Harrison,
Adam Vinatieri, and
William Perry.
Modern era (2000-2010s) In the late 1990s and early 2000s, a wave of entrepreneurs tried forming new leagues in the ever growing football market. The first league was the self-styled "major league of spring football"
Regional Football League (RFL) that played a single season in 1999. The league was initially planned to begin in 1998, but financial difficulties delayed it by a year and changed the business plan, transforming it into a lower-budget league featuring just six teams from mid-sized cities mostly located the southern United States. The league did not prosper, as it failed to secure a television contract and was forced to play a shortened eight-week season. Although the league was unsuccessful, it pioneered the idea of assigning players teams based on the region where they played in college. Parallel to the RFL, there were two more attempts to start up new leagues. The first, the
International Football Federation, folded so rapidly it is considered the shortest football league in history, ceasing operations before completing the preliminary planning stages. The second, the
Spring Football League, was founded by several ex-NFL players:
Bo Jackson,
Drew Pearson,
Eric Dickerson, and
Tony Dorsett. It failed to attract big investors on account of the tech-market crash of 2000, and was cancelled after only two weeks. The next attempt was probably the most significant since the emergence of the AFL in 1960, as
NBC and the
WWE collaborate to form the (original)
XFL in 2001. Although 14 million viewers tuned in for the first game, the
Nielsen ratings later plummeted and triggered NBC to pulled out of its broadcast contract, and the league folded after one season. The league featured several changes in rules and broadcast style, and gave birth to the
Skycam in sports broadcasting. From the late 2000s into the early 2010s, many startup leagues had trouble attracting investors. Five high-profile attempts by the
All American Football and
United National Gridiron leagues in 2007, the
New United States Football League in 2010 and 2014, and the
A-11 Football League in 2014, never materialized. Two other leagues in the era were the low-level
New World Football League (NWFL) and the
Stars Football League (SFL), both of which survived three seasons: the NWFL from 2008 to 2010, and the SFL from 2011 to 2013. The 2009
United Football League (UFL) was the most prominent league in the era, playing 3½ seasons before folding. The UFL was fairly successful, attracting big crowds in
Omaha,
Sacramento, and
Hartford, signing prominent former NFL stars, and airing all league games on
Versus,
HDnet, and over the Internet, and had plans to expand. It functioned as a single-entity league following the
Major League Soccer model. The UFL was the first professional fall league other than the
National Football League to play in the United States since the mid-1970s. The league suffered from systemic financial shortfalls throughout its existence, which eventually led to unpaid players and coaches, and the league shutting down midway through its 2012 season. The
Fall Experimental Football League (FXFL), founded in 2014, aimed to become a professional feeder system for the NFL. The league owner, Brian Woods, wanted his franchises to be primarily based in minor league baseball stadiums, and use the infrastructure in place to attract fans. The FXFL attracted the final NFL roster cuts, for the purpose of keeping them "in football shape, physically and mentally". The league was cancelled after two abbreviated seasons, and was reformatted as the developmental
Spring League in 2016.
New resurgence (2020s) In 2018, several figures with connections to the original 2001 XFL entered the spring-football market with rival leagues. The first was the
Alliance of American Football (AAF), founded by
Charlie Ebersol and
Bill Polian, which began playing in 2019, but ceased operations eight weeks in, after a sudden funding shortfall (caused by the federal asset freeze of a key investor,
Reggie Fowler) led to a rushed midseason sale to
Thomas Dundon, who halted the season after eight weeks after unsuccessfully demanding a formal NFL affiliation and subsidy. 2020 saw a relaunched version of the
XFL, as
Vince McMahon hired
Oliver Luck as commissioner. The league first began play in winter 2020, with more success and a better reception than its first iteration, and aired on
ABC,
ESPN, and
Fox Sports. After five weeks of play, the XFL announced its season would end because of growing
COVID-19 pandemic concerns. The league was on hiatus in 2021 and 2022, after it filed for bankruptcy and put up for sale by McMahon and was later sold to
Dany Garcia,
Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson and
RedBird Capital Partners, and began its second season on February 18, 2023. Six other leagues have entered the planning stage, but have yet to launch. The first is the
Spring League of American Football, a planned high-level minor league that was first announced in September 2016, by two former
Madison Square Garden executives, but did not acquire any funding to begin play. As of 2023, the league appears defunct, with no official website and no news since 2018.
Major League Football was founded in 2014, but so far only has two cancelled seasons in
2016 and
2022. The
American Patriot League was founded in 2018 and planned to start in 2019, held two league showcase and allocated players and coaches to teams, but still hasn't launched because of the
COVID-19 pandemic. Another planned league is the
Freedom Football League, also founded in 2018, run by former NFL players
Jeff Garcia,
Ricky Williams,
Terrell Owens, and
Simeon Rice, with an initial 2020 starting season, but with no recent updates to its timeline. The last two were developmental-level leagues. The first was
Pacific Pro Football, founded in 2017 and designed for non-NFL eligible players; it was abandoned in mid-2020 after several investors backed out, and was reformatted to a scouting event called
HUB Football. The other,
Your Call Football, did start, lasted from 2018 to 2019, and featured concepts that gave the fans the power to control the outcome, which were also adopted by the indoor
Fan Controlled Football league, but was abandoned when its parent company moved on to adapting the technology in other sporting environments. From 2017 to 2021, a developmental league called
The Spring League (TSL) was aimed at professional athletes but acted as "instructional league and showcase for professional football talent" with abbreviated seasons. Its fall 2020 and spring 2021 seasons were notable for their operations inside
bubbles without spectators, allowing them to play through the pandemic. On June 3, 2021, TSL owner Brian Woods announced that he had acquired the remaining extant trademarks of the
United States Football League and launched a
USFL-branded league in 2022, with Fox Sports owning the league and reportedly committing $150 million over three years to its operations, essentially ending the five years run of TSL, and establishing the USFL as a new high-level minor league. In late 2023, the XFL and USFL merged to form a new league, taking the name
United Football League. The league comprises four former XFL teams and four former USFL teams. After the 2025 season,
Mike Repole took a controlling minority stake in the league and substantially overhauled it. ==System and structure==