On September 3, 1831,
William Lloyd Garrison published an article, "The Insurrection", in the
abolitionist newspaper
The Liberator. On September 10, 1831,
The Liberator published excerpts from a letter to the editor saying that many people in the South believed the newspaper had a link to the revolt and that if Garrison were to go to the South, he "would not be permitted to live long... he would be taken away, and no one is the wiser for it... if Mr. Garrison were to go to the South, he would be dispatched immediately... [an] opinion expressed by persons at the South, repeatedly." In November 1831, Thomas R. Gray published
The Confessions of Nat Turner, based on research he conducted while Turner was in hiding and from conversations with Turner before the trial. The pamphlet sold 40,000 to 50,000 copies, making it a noted source about the rebellion at the time. But a November 25, 1831, review of the publication by
The Richmond Enquirer said: The pamphlet has one defect—we mean its style. The confession of the culprit is given, as it were, from his lips—(and when read to him, he admitted its statements to be correct)—but the language is far superior to what Nat Turner could have employed—Portions of it are even eloquently and classically expressed.—This is calculated to cast some shade of doubt over the authenticity of the narrative, and to give the Bandit a character for intelligence which he does not deserve, and ought not to have received.—In all other respects, the confession appears to be faithful and true. Gray's work is the primary historical document about Turner but some modern historians, specifically David F. Allmendinger Jr., have also questioned the validity of his portrayal of Turner. In the aftermath of the revolt, Whites did not try to interpret Turner's motives and ideas. Northern and Southern states shared many of the same fears; a proposal to create a college for African Americans in
New Haven, Connecticut was overwhelmingly rejected in the
New Haven Excitement. The fear Turner's rebellion caused and the concerns raised in the emancipation debates that followed resulted in politicians and writers defining "
slavery as a positive good"; Thomas Dew was among those writers. Other Southern writers began to promote a paternalistic ideal of improved Christian treatment of slaves, in part to avoid such rebellions. Dew and others believed they were civilizing Black people, who were then still mostly American-born through slavery. The writings were collected in
The Pro-Slavery Argument, As Maintained by the Most Distinguished Writers of the Southern States (1853). Some Virginians wanted to remove all Black people from the state Tidewater and Piedmont regions or deport all from the state. In 1852, the Virginia branch of the
American Colonization Society sent 243 Black Virginians to
Liberia. == Other perspectives ==