On 22 August 1938, NKVD leader
Lavrenty Beria was named as Yezhov's deputy. Beria had managed to survive the Great Purge and the "Yezhovshchina" during the years 1936–1938, even though he had almost become one of its victims. Earlier in 1938, Yezhov had even ordered the arrest of Beria, who was party chief in Georgia. However, Georgian NKVD chief
Sergo Goglidze alerted Beria, who immediately flew to Moscow to see Stalin personally. Beria convinced Stalin to spare his life and reminded Stalin how efficiently he had carried out party orders in Georgia and Transcaucasia. Yezhov eventually fell in the struggle for power, and Beria became the new NKVD chief. Over the following months, Beria (with Stalin's approval) began to usurp Yezhov's governance of the Commissariat for Internal Affairs. As early as 8 September,
Mikhail Frinovsky, Yezhov's first deputy, was relocated from under his command into the Navy. Stalin's penchant for periodically executing and replacing his primary lieutenants was well known to Yezhov, as he had previously been the man most directly responsible for orchestrating such actions. Well acquainted with typical Stalinist bureaucratic precursors to eventual dismissal and arrest, Yezhov recognized Beria's increasing influence with Stalin as a sign that his downfall was imminent, and he plunged headlong into
alcoholism and despair. Already a heavy drinker, in the last weeks of his service, he reportedly was disconsolate, slovenly, and drunk nearly all of his waking hours, rarely bothering to show up to work. As anticipated, Stalin and
Vyacheslav Molotov, in a report dated 11 November, sharply criticised the work and methods of the NKVD during Yezhov's tenure as chief, thus establishing the bureaucratic pretense necessary to remove him from power. On 14 November, another of Yezhov's protégés, the Ukrainian NKVD chief
Aleksandr Uspensky, disappeared after being warned by Yezhov that he was in trouble. Stalin suspected that Yezhov was involved in the disappearance and told Beria, not Yezhov, that Uspensky must be caught (he was arrested on 14 April 1939). Yezhov had told his wife, Yevgenia, on 18 September that he wanted a divorce, and she had begun writing increasingly despairing letters to Stalin, none of which were answered. She was particularly vulnerable because of her many lovers, and for months people close to her were being arrested. On 19 November 1938, Yevgenia committed suicide by an overdose of sleeping pills. At his own request, Yezhov was officially relieved of his post as the People's Commissar for Internal Affairs on 25 November, succeeded by Beria, who had been in complete control of the NKVD since the departure of Frinovsky on 8 September. He attended his last Politburo meeting on 29 January 1939. Stalin was evidently content to ignore Yezhov for several months, finally ordering Beria to denounce him at the annual
Presidium of the Supreme Soviet. On 3 March 1939, Yezhov was relieved of all his posts in the Central Committee but retained his post as People's Commissar of Water Transportation. His last working day was 9 April, at which time the "People’s Commissariat was simply abolished by splitting it into two, the People’s Commissariats of the River Fleet and the Sea Fleet, with two new People’s Commissars,
Z. A. Shashkov and
S. S. Dukel’skii."
Arrest On 10 April, Yezhov was arrested and imprisoned at the
Sukhanovka prison; the "arrest was painstakingly concealed, not only from the general public but also from most NKVD officers ... It would not do to make a fuss about the arrest of 'the leader’s favourite,' and Stalin had no desire to arouse public interest in NKVD activity and the circumstances of the conduct of the Great Terror." A letter from Beria,
Andreyev and
Malenkov to Stalin, dated 29 January 1939, accused the NKVD of allowing "massive, unfounded arrests of completely innocent persons", and stated that the leadership of Yezhov "did not put a stop to this kind of arbitrariness and extremism ... but sometimes itself abetted it." Yezhov was interrogated by Acting Chief Military Prosecutor Nikolai Afanasiev. In his confession, Yezhov admitted to the standard litany of state crimes necessary to mark him as an "
enemy of the people" prior to execution, including "wrecking", official incompetence, theft of government funds, and treasonous collaboration with German spies and saboteurs. Apart from these political crimes, he was also accused of and confessed to a humiliating history of sexual promiscuity, including
homosexuality, rumors that were later deemed true by some post-Soviet examinations of the case.
Trial On 2 February 1940, Yezhov was tried behind closed doors by the Military Collegium, chaired by Soviet judge
Vasiliy Ulrikh. Yezhov, like his predecessor Yagoda, maintained to the end his love for Stalin. Yezhov denied being a spy, a terrorist, or a conspirator, stating that he preferred "death to telling lies". He maintained that his previous confession had been obtained under torture, admitted that he had purged 14,000 of his fellow Chekists, but said that he was surrounded by "enemies of the people". Yezhov's determination to assert his innocence was something few of the victims of the Stalinist purges shared. In his final statement at his trial, he defended his record vehemently, though it did not save his life. After the secret trial, Yezhov was allowed to return to his cell; half an hour later, he was called back and told that he had been condemned to death. On hearing the verdict, Yezhov became faint and began to collapse, but the guards caught him and removed him from the room. "Procurator Afanasiev came to his cell to point out to him that he had the right to apply to the Supreme Soviet for pardon and commutation of the death sentence." A bewildered Yezhov replied: "Yes, yes, comrade procurator, I want to appeal for pardon. Maybe comrade Stalin will do that." However, his appeal for clemency was immediately denied, and when he was informed, Yezhov became hysterical and wept. He soon had to be dragged out of the room, struggling with the guards and screaming.
Execution On 4 February 1940, Yezhov was shot in the basement of a small NKVD station on Varsonofevskii Lane (Varsonofyevskiy pereulok) in
Moscow. The basement had a wall made of logs and a sloping floor so that it could be hosed down after executions, and had been built according to Yezhov's own specifications near the
Lubyanka. The main NKVD execution chamber in the basement of the Lubyanka was deliberately avoided to ensure total secrecy. According to biographers Marc Jansen and Nikita Petrov, he "must have been executed by the NKVD Commandant",
Vasili Blokhin, with Afanasev and the Deputy Chief of the NKVD's "First Special Department", Leonid Bashtakov as witnesses. However, Russian author and former
GRU officer
Viktor Suvorov claimed in his 1984 book
Inside Soviet Military Intelligence that there were "grounds for believing that" future
KGB chairman Ivan Serov "played a personal part" in Yezhov's death, although he did not elaborate. Yezhov's body was immediately cremated, and his ashes dumped in a
common grave at Moscow's
Donskoye Cemetery. The execution remained a secret, and as late as 1948, an article in
Time magazine reported rumours that he was still alive and being held "in an insane asylum". == Personal life ==