Before he became famous, British singer
Calum Scott posted a cover version to his personal
YouTube channel on 1 March 2014, and later performed the song for his audition on ''
Britain's Got Talent'' in April 2015, the original clip of which has garnered over 415 million YouTube views. "Naive about the [music] industry" and worried his "career was over" after he wasn't signed to
Simon Cowell's
Syco Entertainment when "the show was over and it went quiet", Scott thought his "opportunity was gone". Tracking the data behind the sudden rise in engagement and speed of new subscribers to Calum's channel over several months, A&R executive Conrad Withey encouraged him to release the song officially. With Conrad's endorsement, Calum signed independently with
Warner Music Group, and the song was released as his debut solo single on 15 April 2016, with a 3 June 2016 release in other territories under
Capitol Records. With this early exposure, Conrad's
Instrumental, a London-based
AI algorithm-based
A&R start-up looking to streamline "notoriously inefficient methods of talent discovery" using internet engagement to cut costs with a "data-driven" platform that would controversially prioritize "popular[ity]" over "artistry" in support of "online engagement", "internet stars" and "brand and content partnerships" rather than "musicians", reversing preconceived notions of building fanbases from scratch by capitalizing on those that already existed, went on to contract their services with the '
Big 3' and revolutionize A&R signing of artists. with critical reception being polarized, and streaming performance being very strong in the UK and Australia, followed by
sleeper hit longevity throughout Europe. Two
EDM remixes of the cover were commissioned and released by Calum's label from
Tiësto on 15 July 2016 and
Hull-based Ben Dooks on 29 October 2018. Different music videos were commissioned and released later in 2016 for Calum's cover as well as the Tiësto remix.
Critical reception Reception to Scott's cover was polarized.
Metro Weekly Sean Maunier called it a "stellar" confessional, noting its "subtle yet powerful" slight lyric changes to "reflect his own experience as a gay man" that were "casual" yet still "matter-of-fact, and all the more striking for it,"
Ones to Watch Miro Sarkissian praised it as "stunning", and
Digital Journal Markos Papadatos found it "crisp and haunting".
BBC Newsbeat Steve Holden wrote that Calum's "second lease of life" he gave the song reached "a far wider audience in the mid-2010s", and Robyn shared with Steve she was "super happy" for Calum's success that got people to "know the song a little bit more", praising his "voice" and "interpretation [...] in a way that 'made the song come alive again.'" and
Pitchfork Jayson Greene also found it "dubious" and "weepy" in comparison to Robyn's. while
We Rave You Petar Lazarevic appreciated how Tiësto "slowly envelope[d]" yet still left "plenty of room" for Calum's vocals, building "the presence of the glossy guitar riffs in the drop" which evoked "the lazy and comfortable feelings that accompany the early hours of the morning after a fantastic night". In March 2018, Scott revisited the mixed reactions to his version. He said that those complaining he had ruined Robyn's song were counterbalanced by positive responses, for instance one person that had "just written to me and said that they've come out to their family because of my interpretation". He said he "didn't change the pronouns of the song" because he wanted the interpretation to always come from a "gay man's perspective". He said the gay community have thanked him repeatedly for the song, saying "how much it means to them that they have a voice in music."
Chart performance The cover went viral on streaming services, with
Spotify tracking it reaching number one in six countries while ranking in the Top 10 in over 20, peaking at number 2 in the Global Viral 50. On
iTunes it charted in the top ten in more than 12 countries. The track had its greatest reception in the UK, where, despite little radio airplay (apart from West Hull FM), it climbed into the top 40 and slowly reached number 4 in July. It was then added to
BBC Radio 2's C List playlist and peaked at number 2 on the
UK Singles Chart on 5 August. The track remained in the top three four months after its release and later that year it was revealed it was the most bought song of the summer in the country. Scott told the Official Charts Company on its reception there that he was "absolutely over the moon" at the news. The track went on to become the best-selling UK single by a British solo artist in 2016. In the subsequent months and years, the track became a moderate
sleeper hit in Europe, including by mid-2018 reaching 550M streams and becoming certified platinum in at least four countries. Scott said in a press statement upon signing with
Capitol Records in the U.S. that "when I recorded the song in my bedroom, I never thought for a second that it would reach as far as it has and bring this level of support from literally all over the globe...I'm completely overwhelmed by it all."
Music videos in the crowd Self-produced by
Calum Scott and directed by Ryan Pallotta, the video for the original version was released on 15 June 2016. A crowd of silent people dressed in white are looking towards a light source. Among them, Scott mouths the song lyrics. A man and a woman move through the crowd to find each other. By April 2020 the video had received over 400 million
YouTube views. The official video for the
Tiësto remix was commissioned by
Capitol Records and released on 4 October 2016. Co-directed by Josh Killacky and David Moore, and edited by Alex Ditommaso, the video depicts a man pursuing a woman who is no longer his lover. With Moore shooting video while riding a
hoverboard in a stark studio space, Josh Killacky and Haley Fitzgerald perform a
modern dance routine, choreographed by Killacky.
Media The cover aired on the 20th episode, "Kill 'em All" of
The CW series
The Vampire Diaries, broadcast 29 April 2016, while Caroline makes soup for Bonnie while ranting to Alaric about Stefan, commitment and closure. It also aired on the 24th episode, "Ring of Fire" of the
ABC series ''
Grey's Anatomy, broadcast 17 May 2017, while Nathan asks Meredith details about Megan, then hugs her in celebration and drives off. Scott promoted the track throughout 2016 and 2017 most notably on Late Night with Seth Meyers, Good Morning America, Elvis Duran and the Morning Show, Good Morning Britain, The Ellen DeGeneres Show, and Dancing with the Stars. Following the 10th episode "Brainwave Jr." of the DC Universe series Stargirl in July 2020, the cover "racked up 10.5 million U.S. on-demand streams, along with 3,000 digital downloads, according to Nielsen Music/MRC Data", topping The Hollywood Reporter'''s Top TV Songs Chart. During the
2021 MLB postseason, the
Boston Red Sox adopted the Tiësto remix of the song as their postseason anthem, playing the song in their celebrations after their
Wild Card Game win over their rivals, the
New York Yankees, and their series win over the
Tampa Bay Rays. During the
2022 MLB postseason, the
Philadelphia Phillies also adopted the Tiësto remix of the song as their own postseason anthem, with the team carrying it over into the 2023 season as well.
Awards and nominations Weekly charts Year-end charts Decade-end charts Certifications == Release history ==