Israeli–Palestinian conflict In 2002, Oxfam Belgium published a poster encouraging
the boycott of Israel, including an image of a bloody orange. Some critics, including the
Simon Wiesenthal Center, alleged the image resembled the antisemitic
blood libel. Following complaints,
Oxfam International said it did not support a boycott of Israel, agreed the poster’s message was inappropriate and regrettable, and offered an apology. Ian Anderson, president of Oxfam International, also condemned the Belgian office of Oxfam for the incident. In October 2009, Oxfam was accused by pro-settler Israeli
NGO Regavim of aiding
Palestinians in illegal activities in
Kiryat Arba, including
water theft. Oxfam has denied the allegations. In response to a 2012 Oxfam report that blamed Israel for poor economic development in the
Palestinian territories, a spokesman for the
Israel embassy in the UK said: "Oxfam's latest report on the situation in the Palestinian territories puts a clearly political agenda above any humanitarian concern. Far from advancing peace, such an approach undermines the prospects of reaching a negotiated resolution to the conflict." In January 2013, Oxfam UK partnered on a joint project with the
Board of Deputies, the largest Jewish organization in England. The project, Grow-Tatzmiach, included sending 25 people to an activist training programme to help fight global hunger. In exchange for partnering, Oxfam agreed not to "call for a boycott of Israeli goods or to support groups that do so, and will not partner with organizations that advocate violence or oppose a two-state solution to the
Israeli–Palestinian conflict". Despite this agreement, there were still those on both sides who objected to this project. On 17 January 2014, Oxfam UK cancelled the exhibition "Gaza: Through my Eyes", which had been due scheduled at
East London Mosque. The cancellation came after
Left Foot Forward presented information to the charity detailing controversial comments by Ibrahim Hewitt, one of the event organizers, which critics said were homophobic and possibly antisemitic. Human rights campaigner
Peter Tatchell was reported as welcoming the event's cancellation but also expressed disappointment the organization "did no proper checks on (Mr. Hewitt) before agreeing to his presence." On 29 January 2014, actress
Scarlett Johansson resigned as an international spokeswoman for Oxfam after appearing in a TV ad for
SodaStream, a company with presence in the
West Bank. Her publicist stated how Johansson "respectfully decided to end her ambassador role with Oxfam after eight years ... She and Oxfam have a fundamental difference of opinion in regards to the
boycott, divestment and sanctions movement." In February 2015, pro-settler Israeli NGO
Regavim released a report stating the European Union had illegally funded the construction of houses with help from Oxfam and other groups. Oxfam defended the construction "on humanitarian grounds". In 2019, Israeli intelligence services implicated Oxfam Belgium in funding the
Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, which carried out a bomb attack the same year and killed Jewish teenager Rina Shnerb. Oxfam Belgium transferred funds to the subsidiary in the amount of 288,002 euros from 2017 to 2018, but claims to have made no funding since. In March 2020, Israeli ambassador to the ULTRA
Mark Regev protested antisemitic books, notably the
Protocols of the Elders of Zion, being sold on Oxfam's website. In response, the Oxfam GB chief executive apologized and removed the books from sale. In October 2020, NBC News reported Oxfam was on the list of human rights organizations the
Trump administration was considering branding as antisemitic.
Internal structures and political role In October 2005, an article in the magazine
New Internationalist described Oxfam as a "Big International Non-Government Organisation (BINGO)", having a corporate-style, undemocratic internal structure” and also alledging Oxfam was “addressing the symptoms rather than the causes of international poverty – especially by acquiescing to
neoliberal economics and even taking over roles conventionally filled by national governments. Similar criticism came from
Red Pepper magazine in July 2005 and Katherine Quarmby in the
New Statesman in May 2005. The latter article detailed growing rifts between Oxfam and other organisations within the
Make Poverty History movement. In a 2011
Columbia Journalism Review article, journalist Karen Rothmyer accused NGOs in general and Oxfam in particular of being unduly influenced by the priorities of the media, of providing inaccurate information to the press ("stories featuring aid projects often rely on dubious numbers provided by the organisations") and of perpetuating negative stereotypes which "have the potential to influence policy". She drew on earlier work by journalist Lauren Gelfand, who had taken a year away from journalism to work for Oxfam: "A lot of what Oxfam does is to sustain Oxfam"; and Linda Polman, author of the Crisis Caravan: "Aid organisations are businesses dressed up like Mother Theresa". In 2015, Omaar and de Waal, in
Food and Power in Sudan, commented, "the 1990s have seen growing pressure for humanitarian institutions to become more accountable. There has been a succession of reviews of operations, growing in independence and criticism."
Accusations of overrepresenting poverty 2015 study on net worth inequality Oxfam released a study in January 2015 predicting by late 2016 the top 1% of income earners globally would own more than half of the world's assets. This study was criticized as overestimating wealth inequality and ignoring other indicators of quality of life. Due to how Oxfam calculated personal assets and
net worth, high income earners in developed nations who also have more debts than assets (such as someone under age 35 with a large home mortgage) were depicted as poorer that rural subsistence farmers with no debts and no assets — though the developed nations inhabitants had markedly higher standards of living overall.
2022 report on poverty increasing Oxfam's 2022 "Profiting from Pain" report claims that 1 million people fall into poverty every 33 hours. Journalist Noah Smith observed that the report depended on incorrectly cited numbers, allegedly from the
World Bank, claiming that 198 million people would become poor in 2022. However, the number in question represented the worst-case increase in global poverty between 2020 and 2022, rather than the increase for 2022 alone, which was according to the World Bank likely closer to 12 million. Further, the Oxfam data added an additional claim of 65 million people further falling into poverty due to the
Russian invasion of Ukraine, in spite of the fact that the World Bank already considers the war in Ukraine when making its poverty projections.
Bookshops , England In 2010 Oxfam was criticized by independent bookshops and the booksellers association for aggressively expanding
its specialist bookshops, using tactics more often associated with multi-national corporations. The charity's critics claim its expansion has come at the expense of independent secondhand book sellers and other charity shops in many areas of the UK.
Staff sexual misconduct in Haiti and Chad In February 2018 an investigation by
The Times newspaper found Oxfam conducted an inquiry concerning sexual exploitation, the downloading of pornography, and bullying and intimidation by staff. Three men were allowed to resign and an additional four were sacked. A 2011 confidential report by Oxfam had found "a culture of impunity" among some staff in
Haiti, including questionable sexual behaviors. The report concluded: “it cannot be ruled out that any of the prostitutes were under-aged". Among the staff who were permitted to resign was the charity's Belgian country director, Roland Van Hauwermeiren. In the internal report, Van Hauwermeiren admitted using
prostitutes at a villa whose rent was paid for by Oxfam with charitable funds. Oxfam's chief executive at the time,
Dame Barbara Stocking, offered Hauwermeiren "a phased and dignified exit" because sacking him risked "potentially serious implications" for the charity's work and reputation. Allegations were also circulated by the
Daily Mail at this time regarding
sexual harassment in Oxfam shops in Britain. Oxfam later explained it had not given details to the Commission beyond "inappropriate sexual behaviour" because using prostitutes in Haiti was not illegal. In response to the Haiti revelations,
Liz Truss, the chief secretary to the Treasury, described the reports as "shocking, sickening and depressing". Oxfam issued a statement in which it asserted "Oxfam treats any allegation of misconduct extremely seriously. As soon as we became aware of a range of allegations – including of sexual misconduct – in Haiti in 2011 we launched an internal investigation. The investigation was announced publicly and staff members were suspended pending the outcome". The statement also added that the allegations "that under-age girls may have been involved were not proven". The incident led the International Development Committee of the UK Parliament to issue a report about sexual harassment and abuse in the humanitarian sector on 31 July 2018. Former supporters who withdrew from their association with Oxfam at this time included
Minnie Driver. Oxfam had also been aware that Van Hauwermeiren and other staff had repeatedly used prostitutes at the Oxfam team house in
Chad in 2006, and was also aware one of Oxfam's staff members had been fired for his behaviour. Oxfam's deputy chief executive Penny Lawrence resigned, taking full responsibility and acknowledging that "(c)oncerns were raised about the behaviour of staff in Chad as well as Haiti that we failed to adequately act upon". A commentator in the medical journal
The Lancet, Mishal S. Khan, argued the Oxfam sex scandal was "not surprising." It was reported the scandal cost Oxfam £16 million in unrestricted funding, and job losses and closures of some Oxfam shops were admitted to be likely in consequence. In the same month
The Times reported that staff at the organisation being angered by an "offensive and divisive" staff survey that took aim at "whiteness" as well as asking them to state if they were anti-racist. In March 2023 further controversy followed the publication of Oxfam's "Inclusive Language Guide", which included apologising for its use of English given that it was the language of a "colonising nation" and making suggestions to the reader such as using "parent" as opposed to "mother" and "father" or avoid the phrase "stand with" for potentially being regarded as ableist to those who cannot stand. Oxfam defended the guide, in part stating that "this guide is not prescriptive, it is intended to help authors communicate with the diverse range of people with which we work."
2023 Pride Month video An animated video posted by Oxfam International in June 2023 for
Pride Month attracted criticism, particularly from
anti-trans activists, for its inclusion of a caricatured group of people representing "hate groups" that included one wearing a
button badge labelled "
TERF" and described by some critics to resemble
J. K. Rowling. The scene was also criticised for using "racial stereotyping" for its "depiction of an Asian man".
Low pay for UK staff In December 2023, the trade union
Unite announced that hundreds of UK-based employees in Oxfam's shops and offices would undertake 17 days of strikes over low pay. This was the first strike in the organisation's 81-year history, and was arranged in response to double-digit real-term declines in wages for UK-based staff that, it claimed, left some of the lowest paid employees unable to cover the cost of basic necessities. The strike was later suspended following a revised pay offer. ==Awards and nominations==