Critical reception Cowboy Bebop received unanimous acclaim upon its debut. In 1998, Japanese critic Keith Rhee highlighted the series as a standout in an otherwise "run-of-the-mill" season, praising its overall production values, and singling out Kanno's soundtrack as "a much-welcome change from all the sugary
J-pop tunes of most anime features". Rhee also highlighted the show's Japanese "all-star cast", In 1999, Australian magazine
Hyper reviewed the anime and rated it 9.5 out of 10.
Paste and
IGN named it as the best and second best anime of all time, respectively.
Anime News Networks Mike Crandol gave the series an 'A+' rating for the dubbed version, and an 'A' rating for the subbed version. He characterized the series as "one of the most popular and respected anime titles in history", before adding that it was "a unique television show which skillfully transcends all kinds of genres". Crandol praised its characters as "some of the most endearing characters to ever grace an anime", and commended the voice acting, especially the "flawless English cast". He also complimented the series' "movie-quality" animation, "sophisticated" writing, and its "incredible" musical score. Crandol hailed
Cowboy Bebop as a "landmark" anime "that will be remembered long after many others have been forgotten", and went on to call it "one of the greatest anime titles ever". Additionally, Michael Toole of
Anime News Network named
Cowboy Bebop as one of the most important anime of the 1990s. T.H.E.M. Anime Reviews gave the entire series a perfect score of 5 out of 5 stars, with reviewer Christina Carpenter believing
Cowboy Bebop as "one of the best [anime]" and touting it as a masterpiece that "puts most anime...and
Hollywood, to shame". She described it as a "very stylish, beautifully crafted series that deserves much more attention than it gets". Carpenter praised the animation as "a rarity and a marvel to behold" and that it was "beyond superb", and the plot and characterization as having "a sophistication and subtlety that is practically one-of-a-kind". She also praised the soundtrack, and hailed the opening theme as one of the best intro pieces she had ever heard. Carpenter went to say that
Bebop was a "must-have for any serious collector of Japanese animation". In his article "Asteroid Blues: The Lasting Legacy of
Cowboy Bebop",
The Atlantic writer Alex Suskind states, "On paper,
Cowboy Bebop, the legendary cult anime series from Shinichirō Watanabe, reads like something
John Wayne,
Elmore Leonard, and
Philip K. Dick came up with during a wild, all-night whiskey bender." He goes on to write, "The response from critics and fans may have sounded hyperbolic—the word 'masterpiece' was thrown around a great deal—but the praise was justified. First-time solo director Watanabe had created a gorgeous tale of morality, romance, and violence–a dark look at the lives of outlaws that's shot like an independent film." In January 2015, television writer Kyle Mills of
DVD Talk awarded the series five stars upon review. He stated, "Regardless of the medium, be it live action television, film, or animation,
Cowboy Bebop is simply one of the finest examples of storytelling ever created." In his review, he describes the finale as "one of the best in television history", referring to it as a "widely revered" ending that "still sparks fan conversation, resonating with viewers 15 years on". He closes by writing, "
Cowboy Bebop ends with a bang." In his 2018 review of the series,
Paste critic John Maher wrote, "It feels like a
magnum opus produced at the pinnacle of a long career despite being, almost unbelievably, Watanabe's first series as a director. It is a masterwork that should justly rank among the best works of television of all time." It was also placed at #1 on the publication's list of the "50 Best Anime Series of All Time". On
review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes, the series has an approval rating of 100% based on 23 reviews. The website's critical consensus reads, "Blending a head-spinning array of genres and references,
Cowboy Bebop is an anime television classic that must be experienced." In an April 2019 interview with Diego Molano, creator of
Victor & Valentino, he said that Cowboy Bebop was the first anime he "obsessed over", as he spent time tracking down VHS tapes of the show in high school. He also argued that this series showed him "how cinematic and emotional animation can be".
Accolades At the 1999
Anime Grand Prix awards for the anime of 1998,
Cowboy Bebop won two first place awards: Spike Spiegel was awarded the best male character; and Megumi Hayashibara was awarded the best voice actor for her role as Faye Valentine.
Cowboy Bebop also received rankings in other categories: the series itself was awarded the second best anime series; Faye Valentine and Ed were ranked the fifth and ninth best female characters respectively; "Tank!" and "The Real Folk Blues" were ranked the third and fifteenth best songs respectively; and "Ballad of Fallen Angels", "Speak Like a Child", "Jamming with Edward" and "Mish-Mash Blues" were ranked the second, eighth, eighteenth and 20th best episodes respectively. At the 2000 Anime Grand Prix awards for the anime of 1999,
Cowboy Bebop won the same two first place awards again: best male character for Spike Spiegel; and best voice actor for Megumi Hayashibara. Other rankings the series received are: second best anime series; sixth best female character for Faye Valentine; seventh and twelfth best song for "Tank!" and "Blue" respectively; and third and seventeenth best episode for "The Real Folk Blues (Part 2)" and "Hard Luck Woman" respectively. In the 2000
Seiun Awards, Cowboy Bebop was awarded for Best Media of the Year. A 2004 poll in
Newtype USA, the US edition of the Japanese magazine
Newtype, asked its readers to vote the "Top 25 Anime Titles of All Time";
Cowboy Bebop ranked second on the list, after
Neon Genesis Evangelion, placing it as one of the most socially relevant and influential anime series ever created. During that same year,
Cinefantastique listed the anime as one of the "10 Essential Animations", citing the series' "gleeful mix of
noir-style, culture-hopping inclusiveness and music". In 2007, the American Anime magazine
Anime Insider listed the "50 Best Anime Ever" by compiling lists of industry regulars and magazine staff, and
Cowboy Bebop topped the list. In 2012,
Madman Entertainment compiled the votes of fans online for "The Top 20 Madman Anime Titles" and ranked
Cowboy Bebop at seventh.
Cowboy Bebop has been featured in several lists published by
IGN. In the 2009 "Top 100 Animated TV Series" list,
Cowboy Bebop, labelled as "a very original – and arguably one of the best – anime", was placed fourteenth, making it the second highest ranking anime on the list after
Evangelion, and one of the most influential series of the 1990s. In 2011,
Bebop was ranked 29th in the "Top 50 Sci-Fi TV Shows" list, once again being the second-highest ranking anime on the list after
Evangelion. In 2006,
Cowboy Bebops soundtrack was ranked first in the "Top Ten Anime Themes and Soundtracks of All-Time" list, with the series being commented as "one of the best anime ever and certainly is tops when it comes to music." Spike Spiegel was ranked fourth in the "Top 25 Anime Characters of All Time" article.
IGN Movies also placed
Cowboy Bebop in its list of "10 Cartoon Adaptations We'd Like to See".
Analysis The series has been subject to study and analysis since its debut, with the main focus being on its style and mixture of genres. Miguel Douglas, describing the series style in a review, said that "the series distinctly establishes itself outside the realm of conventional
Japanese animation and instead chooses to forge its own path. With a setting within the realm of
science fiction, the series wisely offers a world that seems entirely realistic considering our present time. Free from many of the elements that accompany science fiction in general—whether that be
space aliens, giant
robots, or
laser guns—the series delegates itself towards presenting a world that is quite similar to our own albeit showcasing some technological advances." Daryl Surat of
Otaku USA, commenting on the series' appeal, said that it was "that rare breed of science-fiction: 'accessible'. Unlike many anime titles, viewers weren't expected to have knowledge of
Japanese culture—character names, signs, and the like were primarily in English to begin with—or have seen any other anime series prior." Michelle Onley Pirkle, in her book
Science Fiction Film, Television, and Adaptation: Across the Screens, said that "
Cowboy Bebop is taking a new take on genre, not by creating unique images and sounds, but by playing 'freely' with, 'remixing', or adapting the images and sounds of other familiar genres in a dynamic way." Robert Baigent, writing for the
Graduate Journal of Asia-Pacific Studies, said that the series' appeal likely stemmed from the trend in anime to emulate Western fiction. ==Legacy==