After completing his undergraduate degree, Evans lived in Dallas where he was a paid tenor at
Temple Emanu-El and the assistant director of music at
Highland Park Presbyterian Church. He began his career as a tenor soloist working in a mixture of amateur and professional events that extended from the concert repertoire into opera. He appeared as the tenor soloist again, this time in a complete presentation of the
oratorio, with a community chorus in Grapevine, Texas, the following March 1966. He performed as the tenor soloist in numerous amateur to semi-professional presentations of the
Messiah in Texas and Louisiana in the succeeding years, including at
Northwestern State University. He performed in several musical theatre productions at the CMT, among them the role of Sir Sagramore in
Lerner and Loewe's
Camelot (1971) with
Jamie Ross as King Arthur and soprano Catherine Christensen as Guenevere; one of the disciples in
Godspell (1974) in which he sang the song "All Good Gifts"; and the partial
drag role of Joe/"Josephine" in
Sugar (1974), a musical adaptation of
Some Like It Hot. The latter production also starred Arlington dancer Persis Forster and Broadway musical performer
Scott Jarvis. In the autumn of 1966 Evans won a vocal competition sponsored by the
Fort Worth Opera which resulted in his being cast as the Chimney Sweep in the world premiere of
Julia Smith's
The Shepherdess and the Chimney Sweep with his co-stars being bass-baritone and well-known voice teacher
Edward Baird as Mandarin and soprano
Elaine Cormany as the Shepherdess. The Fort Worth Opera production premiered on December 28, 1966. He later returned to the FWO in 1973 to perform the roles of Lord Arturo and Normanno in
Gaetano Donizetti's
Lucia di Lammermoor with
Patricia Wise in the title role. He portrayed Beppe in the FWO's 1974 production of
Pagliacci with
William Lewis as Canio,
Louis Quilico as Tonio, and
Heather Thomson as Nedda. That FWO season he also performed the part of Gastone in
La traviata. While a graduate student, Evans sang the role of David in the United States' premiere of Handel's
Saul at
St. Michael and All Angels Episcopal Church in Dallas in March 1968 which was presented in partnership with the
Dallas Ballet Theater. In the mid 1960s he performed with the
Dallas Symphony Orchestra (DSO) in concerts of
Zoltán Kodály's
Psalmus Hungaricus and
Darius Milhaud's
Miracles of Faith. In May 1968 he was the tenor soloist in the world premiere of
Samuel Adler's oratorio
The Binding which was made in honor of the composer's father,
Hugo Chaim Adler. Hugo Adler's 1937 oratorio
Akedah was written on the subject, but its score was lost after being confiscated and destroyed by the Nazis just prior to its scheduled premiere in Stuttgart. Samuel Adler conducted the premiere of
The Binding with the orchestra being made up of member of the DSO. Both during and after completing graduate school, Evans worked as a music teacher. While a graduate student he worked as the director of choral music at the
Hockaday School in Dallas. After completing his master's degree, he was a public school music teacher in Houston while simultaneously performing in the chorus and in small parts with the
Houston Grand Opera (HGO). When conductor
Sarah Caldwell was a guest conductor with the HGO she heard Evans sing and strongly encouraged him to pursue a career as a leading operatic tenor, something he had previously not imagined as possible. ==Opera Company of Boston==