Pinball Construction Set's sales had surpassed 250,000 copies by November 1989, and it ultimately sold over 300,000 copies in all platforms.
Pinball Construction Sets scope and flexibility on a 48K Apple II was impressive.
Steve Wozniak called it "the greatest program ever written for an 8-bit machine", and for thousands the software was their first experience with a GUI.
Computer Gaming World in 1983 considered the
software toy revolutionary, and easy to understand because of its representative icons and drag-and-drop method of constructing a table; the magazine stated that "there's something almost magical about the way this product works. You take everything it does for granted after just a few minutes". The nine-page manual was considered "overkill", since
Pinball Construction Set required no programming knowledge; an eight-year-old had no problems creating his own tables. Reviewing the Atari version in their "Arcade Alley" column,
Video magazine described
Pinball Construction Set as a "remarkably clever and easy-to-use program", and noted that a third-party company had already published a suite of pre-made pinball games for use with the construction set.
BYTE found the tool kit as "complete" and praised Budge's "marvelous sense of programming". The magazine reported that "creativity is encouraged. [Users] are gently encouraged and aided. This is valuable for children and inexperienced players and computer users".
InfoWorld compared the game's importance to that of
Scott Adams's
Adventureland, and predicted that it "is sure to have lots of children and grandchildren". ''InfoWorld's Essential Guide to Atari Computers
cited it as a notable arcade game. Ahoy! called Pinball Construction Set
as one of the best home entertainment programs of its era. The
Addison-Wesley Book of Atari Software 1984'' gave the "pinball wizard's dream" an overall A+ rating, praising the user interface as "exceptionally human engineered".
Compute! listed it in 1988 as one of "Our Favorite Games", calling the game "a programming work of art ... a classic that never seems to grow old".
Orson Scott Card said in the magazine in 1989 that the program was so flexible that his son used it as a graphics program.
Awards In 1984
Pinball Construction Set received a Certificate of Merit in the category of "1984 Most Innovative Video Game/Computer Game" at the 5th annual
Arkie Awards. One month later
Softline readers named the game the ninth most-popular Apple and Atari program of 1983.
Computer Gaming World in 1996 declared
Pinball Construction Set the 50th-best computer game ever released, and ranked it #1 in the magazine's list of the most innovative computer games.
Pinball Construction Set is an inductee in
GameSpy's Hall of Fame. In 2008,
Pinball Construction Set was honored at the 59th Annual
Technology and Engineering Emmy Awards for "User Generated Content/Game Modification". ==Legacy==