Transgender people Rowling's responses to proposed changes to Scottish gender recognition laws and her views on
sex and
gender have provoked controversy. She has been critical of self-declared
gender identity. Her statements have divided
feminists, fuelled debates on
freedom of speech and
cancel culture, and prompted
support for transgender people from the arts sector. Her statements have been deemed
transphobic by critics and she has been referred to as a
TERF (trans-exclusionary radical feminist) As her views on transgender issues came under scrutiny, Rowling stated that she has received death threats. Rowling's views on trans individuals were first noted in 2018 when she "
liked" a tweet that described trans women as "men in dresses". This was criticised by some of her fans who accused her of being transphobic. Her spokesperson told
PinkNews that Rowling had "favourited" the tweet by mistake. In December 2019 Rowling tweeted support for
Maya Forstater, who lost her job with the
Center for Global Development due to
gender-critical views, and was the subject of
Forstater v Centre for Global Development Europe. In 2020 Rowling spoke out against a
Devex article for using the phrase "people who
menstruate" instead of "women". She stated that "erasing the concept of sex" erases the experiences of women worldwide and eliminates the possibility of same-sex attraction. Responding to criticism, she stated her view that "sex is real and has lived consequences", while additionally writing: "I respect every trans person's right to live any way that feels authentic and comfortable to them." Rowling published an essay on her personal website in 2020 in which she expressed a number of concerns about what she called the "new trans activism". Rowling characterises arguments that femaleness does not reside in the sexed body, and assertions that "biological women" do not have common experiences, as being misogynistic. She finds language calling females "menstruators" to be dehumanising, and she believes that the trans activist movement seeks to erode women as a political class as well as a biological one. She also said that the attempt to redefine the legal definition of sex in terms of gender would put safe spaces for women at risk. She said she was concerned that girls were transitioning in order to escape sexism, and that she was a survivor of
domestic abuse and
sexual assault, and stated that "When you throw open the doors of bathrooms and changing rooms to any man who believes or feels he's a woman...then you open the door to any and all men who wish to come inside". Among those who disputed the claims in Rowling's essay were the LGBTQ rights charity
Stonewall and
Mermaids, a charity for gender non-conforming children, which criticised Rowling for what it saw as her conflating "trans women with male sexual predators". Women's rights groups in the United States had said in 2016 that 200 municipalities which allowed transgender people to use women's shelters reported no rise in violence. Rowling believes that "no child is 'born in the wrong body'," arguing that adults are promoting an ideology that bodies can be modified, which will prove harmful in the future. She has criticised schools for affirming trans identities without parental consent, and argues that parents may be protecting their children from a cultural assumption that anxieties about sexuality and puberty can be resolved by solutions that require lifelong dependence of pharmaceutical interventions. She has said that she "never set out to upset anyone" but was "not uncomfortable with getting off my pedestal." Neither is she concerned, she explained, about how her opposition to trans rights will affect her legacy. She claims the term
cisgender is "ideological language signifying belief in the unfalsifiable concept of gender identity." She claims that her beliefs arise out of a sincere concern for transgender people, and in particular, young transgender men, saying, "I'm concerned about the huge explosion in young women wishing to transition and also about the increasing numbers who seem to be detransitioning." Her belief is that young people are transitioning to avoid homophobia. Nevertheless, the rate of detransitioning is low, in the order of 0.5%. Rowling opposes legislation to advance gender self-recognition and enable transition without a medical diagnosis, She also voiced opposition to the
Scottish Gender Recognition Reform Bill, aimed at allowing transgender people to change their legal gender more easily and subsequently she donated £70,000 to
the legal challenge brought by
For Women Scotland against the Scottish Ministers in the
Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, which on 16 April 2025 ruled that the legal definition of a woman in the
Equality Act 2010 is based on biological sex. In response to
Edinburgh's rape crisis centre being run by a trans woman,
Mridul Wadhwa, Rowling established a sexual assault crisis centre that excludes trans women,
Beira's Place, in December 2022.
The Guardian quoted
rape crisis specialists as saying it "would provide much-needed extra provision, because existing services were being overwhelmed by new cases" and noted that "under the Equality Act, services that exclude trans women are lawful if they are proportionate and legitimate". In response to a fan praising this decision, Rowling tweeted "Merry Terfmas". Rowling has also expressed her opposition to the
Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Act 2021, and when this went into effect in April 2024, she deliberately
misgendered several transgender women to challenge the new law. Throughout the thread, Rowling sarcastically referred to all the people as female, but at the end clarified, "Obviously, the people mentioned in the above tweets aren't women at all, but men, every last one of them." Rowling said that, if her comments were illegal under the new law, she "looked forward to being arrested". Later, a spokesperson for
Police Scotland said that Rowling's statements were "not assessed to be criminal and no further action will be taken." The prime minister,
Rishi Sunak, defended Rowling, saying, "We should not be criminalising people saying common sense on biological sex".
Reactions Within days of the publication of Rowling's 2020 essay,
Daniel Radcliffe, who portrayed the titular character in the
Harry Potter film series, voiced his support of transgender people, and stating his own belief that trans women are women. Other actors of the
Wizarding World franchise who either criticised her views directly or spoke out in support of trans rights include
Emma Watson,
Eddie Redmayne,
Rupert Grint,
Bonnie Wright, and
Katie Leung.
Stephen Fry, who narrated the
Harry Potter audiobooks, has said Rowling may have been "radicalised by
TERFs" and "the vitriol that is thrown at her" and that, as a result, she had said "things that are inflammatory and contemptuous, mocking and add[ing] to a terribly distressing time for trans people". A public backlash to Rowling's Twitter interactions also saw calls for her "cancellation" and to ignore her opinions. Some actors in the Wizarding World franchise have come to Rowling's defence.
Helena Bonham Carter,
Robbie Coltrane and
Ralph Fiennes spoke out in support of Rowling. The actress
Noma Dumezweni initially expressed support for Rowling but rescinded this following backlash.
Evanna Lynch initially criticised Rowling's views but later condemned the intense backlash against her. Other performers and activists have supported Rowling and condemned comments against her, including
Julie Bindel,
Dave Chappelle and
Kathleen Stock. Conversely, others, including
David Tennant,
Pedro Pascal,
Charlotte Clymer and
Nicola Coughlan, have criticised Rowling over her comments on transgender people. The former prime minister
Tony Blair expressed his belief in 2021 that Labour could not win a general election if it "looked askance" at Rowling's views on transgender people, calling for open debate on the issue. The reaction of
Warner Bros. Entertainment was measured, but increasingly stressed the collaborative nature of the
Harry Potter brand. Warner Bros and
Universal Studios Parks & Resorts released statements in June 2020, emphasising their prioritisation of LGBTQ inclusion and diversity, but did not directly mention Rowling or her comments. In June 2020 the
Equality Act was blocked in the
United States Senate. The
Republican Party senator
James Lankford cited Rowling's essay as part of his reasoning for opposing the bill. Four authors resigned in protest from the Blair Partnership, Rowling's
literary agency, after the company refused to issue a public statement of support for trans rights, saying that "freedom of speech can only be upheld if the structural inequalities that hinder equal opportunities for underrepresented groups are challenged and changed." In July 2020, following the threat of legal action, the British children's news website
The Day publicly apologised to Rowling after publishing an article that suggested her comments caused harm to and attacked transgender people, made comparisons between Rowling's views and those of
Richard Wagner on race and
Pablo Picasso on women, and called for her work to be boycotted. The publication agreed to pay an undisclosed sum to a charity of Rowling's choice. Rowling returned her Robert F. Kennedy Human Rights
Ripple of Hope Award in August 2020, after the organisation's president
Kerry Kennedy called her statements "deeply troubling", "transphobic" and degrading towards transgender people. Rowling stated that she was "deeply saddened" to be returning the award, reiterating her admiration for
Robert F. Kennedy, but said that no award "means so much to me that I would forfeit the right to follow the dictates of my own conscience." The fansites
MuggleNet and
The Leaky Cauldron have expressed criticism towards Rowling. In September 2020 a letter in support of Rowling, signed by 58 entertainers and authors, including
Ian McEwan, the actress
Frances Barber, the playwright
Tom Stoppard and the actor
Griff Rhys Jones, was published in
The Sunday Times. The letter condemned the "onslaught of abuse" directed at Rowling on social media, describing such behaviour as an "insidious, authoritarian and misogynistic trend". The actor
Eddie Redmayne similarly condemned the abuse targeted at Rowling, whilst also condemning the abuse towards transgender people. The
genderfluid comedian and actor
Eddie Izzard stated that she does not consider Rowling transphobic and encouraged people to read Rowling's work about the topic. In an interview with
New Statesman, the philosopher and gender theorist
Judith Butler agreed that Rowling should not be subject to abuse, but urged people to oppose any form of abuse against transgender people.
Asexual people Rowling does not believe
asexual people are
subject to discrimination and denies that they belong in the LGBTQ community. She implied that asexuality is incompatible with romantic attraction, doubting how an asexual person can distinguish whether they are romantically gay or straight and described heteroromantic asexual people as merely being straight people who do not want to have sex. On
International Asexuality Day (IAD) 2025, Rowling posted an IAD infographic by
Switchboard accompanied by a sentence framing it as "fake oppression day". She contrasted gay people getting killed in homophobic countries with asexuals, whom she claimed merely get "ignored to death". Lola Uguen of
Elle had similar arguments. Fiona Ward and Hannah Madlener from
Glamour DE specified that asexuality does exist. Federico Boni from
Gay.it argued JKR's statements on asexuals were fuelling misinformation.
Yasmin Benoit, an asexual activist who co-created International Asexuality Day, stated that "A lot of people's introduction [to International Asexuality Day] has now been through JK Rowling hating on it" and noted she was seeing a negative conversation about asexuality in spaces where it was previously absent, stating that Rowling "hijacked the occasion" and describing her views as "acephobia". Rowling's views on asexuality have also been described as related to her views on transgender people, also members of the LGBTQ community. == Eating disorders ==