The underlying mechanism was first described by the German physiologist
Felix Hoppe-Seyler in 1871, and acute porphyrias were described by the Dutch physician
Barend Stokvis in 1889. The links between porphyrias and mental illness have been noted for decades. In the early 1950s, patients with porphyrias (occasionally referred to as "porphyric hemophilia") and severe symptoms of depression or catatonia were treated with
electroshock therapy.
Vampires and werewolves Porphyria has been suggested as an explanation for the origin of
vampire and
werewolf legends, based upon certain perceived similarities between the condition and the
folklore. In January 1964, L. Illis's 1963 paper 'On Porphyria and the
Aetiology of Werewolves' was published in
Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine. Later,
Nancy Garden argued for a connection between porphyria and the vampire belief in her 1973 book
Vampires. In 1985, biochemist
David Dolphin's paper for the
American Association for the Advancement of Science, 'Porphyria, Vampires, and Werewolves: The Aetiology of European Metamorphosis Legends', gained widespread media coverage, popularizing the idea. The theory has been rejected by a few folklorists and researchers as not accurately describing the characteristics of the original werewolf and vampire legends nor the disease and as potentially stigmatizing people with porphyria. A 1995 article from the
Postgraduate Medical Journal (via
NIH) explains: As it was believed that the folkloric vampire could move about freely in daylight hours, as opposed to the 20th century variant, congenital erythropoietic porphyria cannot readily explain the folkloric vampire but may be an explanation of the vampire as we know it in the 20th century. In addition, the folkloric vampire, when unearthed, was always described as looking quite healthy ("as they were in life"), whereas owing to disfiguring aspects of the disease sufferers would not have passed the exhumation test. Individuals with congenital erythropoietic porphyria do not crave blood. The enzyme (hematin) necessary to alleviate symptoms is not absorbed intact on oral ingestion, and drinking blood would have no beneficial effect on the sufferer. Finally, and most important, the fact that vampire reports were rampant in the 18th century, and that congenital erythropoietic porphyria is an extremely rare manifestation of a rare disease, makes it an unlikely explanation of the folkloric vampire.
Notable cases • The mental illness exhibited by King
George III of the United Kingdom in the
regency crisis of 1788 has inspired several attempts at
retrospective diagnosis. The first, written in 1855, thirty-five years after his death, concluded that he had acute
mania. M. Guttmacher, in 1941, suggested
manic-depressive psychosis as a more likely diagnosis. The first suggestion that a physical illness was the cause of King George's mental derangement came in 1966 in a paper by psychiatrists
Ida Macalpine and
Richard A. Hunter called "The Insanity of King George III: A Classic Case of Porphyria", with a follow-up in 1968, "Porphyria in the Royal Houses of Stuart, Hanover and Prussia". Many of their colleagues disagreed with the diagnosis, suggesting bipolar disorder as far more probable. The theory is treated in
Purple Secret, which documents the ultimately unsuccessful search for genetic evidence of porphyria in the remains of royals suspected to have had it. In 2005, it was suggested that
arsenic (which is known to be porphyrogenic) given to George III with
antimony may have caused his porphyria. This study found high levels of arsenic in King George's hair. In 2010, one analysis of historical records argued that the porphyria claim was based on spurious and selective interpretation of contemporary medical and historical sources. The mental illness of George III is the basis of the plot in
The Madness of King George, a 1994 British film based upon the 1991
Alan Bennett play,
The Madness of George III. The closing credits of the film include the comment that the King's symptoms suggest that he had porphyria, and note that the disease is "periodic, unpredictable, and hereditary". The traditional argument that George III did not have porphyria, but rather bipolar disorder, is defended by
Andrew Roberts in his biography
The Last King of America. • Among other descendants of George III theorized by the authors of
Purple Secret to have had porphyria (based on analysis of their extensive and detailed medical correspondence) were his great-great-granddaughter
Princess Charlotte of Prussia (
Emperor William II's eldest sister) and her daughter
Princess Feodora of Saxe-Meiningen. They uncovered better evidence that George III's great-great-great-grandson
Prince William of Gloucester was reliably diagnosed with variegate porphyria. • It is believed that
Mary, Queen of Scots, King George III's ancestor, also had acute intermittent porphyria, although this is subject to much debate. It is assumed she inherited the disorder, if indeed she had it, from her father, King
James V of Scotland. Both father and daughter endured well-documented attacks that could fall within the constellation of symptoms of porphyria. • Queen
Maria I of Portugal, known as Maria the Pious or Maria the Mad because of both her religious fervor and her acute mental illness, which made her incapable of handling state affairs after 1792—is also thought to have had porphyria.
Francis Willis, the physician who treated George III, was even summoned by the Portuguese court but returned to England after the court limited the treatments he could oversee. Contemporary sources, such as Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs
Luís Pinto de Sousa Coutinho, noted that the queen had ever-worsening stomach pains and abdominal spasms: hallmarks of porphyria. • Commentators have suggested that
Vincent van Gogh may have had acute intermittent porphyria. • The description of King
Nebuchadnezzar II of Babylon in
Daniel 4 suggests to some that he had porphyria. • Physician
Archie Cochrane was born with porphyria, which caused health problems throughout his life. •
Paula Frías Allende, the daughter of the Chilean novelist
Isabel Allende, fell into a porphyria-induced coma in 1991, which inspired Isabel to write the memoir
Paula, dedicated to her. •
Tommy Steele, London-born entertainer, frequently hospitalized as a child due to the condition.
Uses in literature Stated or implied references to porphyria are included in some literature, particularly gothic literature. These include the following: • The condition is the name of the title character in the gothic poem "
Porphyria's Lover", by
Robert Browning. • The condition is heavily implied to be the cause of the symptoms suffered by the narrator in the gothic short story "
Lusus Naturae", by
Margaret Atwood. Some of the narrator's symptoms resemble those of porphyria, and one passage of the story states that the name of the narrator's disease "had some Ps and Rs in it." ==References==