Critical response The film received generally negative reviews from critics.
Rotten Tomatoes gave the film a score of 23%, based on 30 reviews, with the site's critical consensus stating, "Dull, poorly directed, and badly miscast,
Red Sonja is an uninspired conclusion to Schwarzenegger's barbarian trilogy." On
Metacritic, the film has a score of 35% based on reviews from 6 critics, indicating "generally unfavorable reviews". Audiences polled by
CinemaScore gave the film an average grade of "D+" on an A+ to F scale. Schwarzenegger commented, "It's the worst film I have ever made." He joked, "Now I tell my kids that, if they get out of line, they'll be forced to watch
Red Sonja ten times in a row. It must be working, because I've never had much trouble with any of them."
John Grant, who authored the film's entry in
The Encyclopedia of Fantasy (1997), gave
Red Sonja a negative review, commenting "Morally dubious (Gedren's
lesbianism is depicted as one of her evil attributes) and worse-acted than words can explain,
Red Sonja is a great embarrassment." Film historian
Leonard Maltin gave the movie 1.5 out of a possible 4 stars. He went on to cite the picture as: "Spectacularly silly...While it might amuse juvenile viewers, most of the fun for adults is in deciding who gives the worse performance -- Brigitte Nielsen or Sandahl Bergman." Joe Kane, the "
Phantom of the Movies", gave the film 1 out of 4 stars. According to him, "While
Conan the Barbarian was
sword-and-sorcery, this is grunt-and-groan: the actors grunt, while the audience groans...Amid wooden thespianism, redundant comedy relief, and clunky storytelling, Arnold Schwarzenegger's most impressive feat is managing to stay offscreen for more than half the running time despite being top-billed."
Siskel and Ebert also gave the film negative reviews though both considered the film unintentionally funny. Both
Gene Siskel and
Roger Ebert agreed that the film was poorly made, yet it contained enough campy humor that it might have been intended as a spoof; Ebert noted the "dialogue which sounds like the actors have already read the
Mad magazine parody of this film". Both critics laughed during their reviews, notably when Siskel noted the awkward position of the Buddha statue. Andrea Wright, writing for the
Journal of Gender Studies, has argued that the film represents a problematic representation of women, because the character of Red Sonja is sexualized and relies on a male counterpart.
Accolades The film was nominated for three
Golden Raspberry Awards:
Worst Actress (Brigitte Nielsen),
Worst New Star (Nielsen) and
Worst Supporting Actress (Sandahl Bergman). Nielsen won in the Worst New Star category, shared for her performance in
Rocky IV, at the
6th Golden Raspberry Awards. ==Comic books==