Early career Spielman began his NFL career as a scout with Detroit in 1990 and worked with the club in college scouting for five seasons before adding pro scouting duties in 1995 and 1996. He was promoted in 2002 to senior vice president of football operations and player personnel and eventually general manager in 2004. Spielman left the Dolphins during the 2005 offseason, later working at
ESPN as an analyst. In 2002, he was promoted to senior vice president of football operations. Spielman was promoted to general manager after the 2003 season saw the team miss the playoffs for the 2nd straight year (
Ron Wolf turned down the position when asked by team owner
Wayne Huizenga). Wannstedt was fired midway through the 2004 season, which saw the team win just one of their first eight games with a roster missing running back
Ricky Williams, who abruptly retired in August. In that same month, the Dolphins elected to trade
Adewale Ogunleye (the 2003 leader in sacks for the AFC) due to him holding out and not accepting the qualifying offer as a restricted free agent; they received
Marty Booker and a third-round pick in the 2005 draft. An attempt at trading for a quarterback to win the starting job with
A.J. Feeley (the third-string player on the
Philadelphia Eagles) saw them trade a second-round pick for him only to see him start (and lose) two of the first three games of the season on the way to throwing 11 touchdowns against 15 interceptions.
Minnesota Vikings Spielman assumed the Vikings' vice president of player personnel role on May 30, 2006, replacing Fran Foley. On January 3, 2012, Spielman was promoted to general manager of the Vikings. Despite his lack of success with the Dolphins, Spielman established himself as one of the league's better general managers during his 16-year tenure with the organization. From 2010 to 2019, 12.5% of Viking draft selections made the Pro Bowl. which was fourth best in the league, and he was also NFL.com's 6th ranked GM in 2021. His most notable draftees include:
Adrian Peterson and
Sidney Rice in 2007;
John Sullivan in 2008;
Percy Harvin and
Phil Loadholt in 2009;
Christian Ponder and
Kyle Rudolph in 2011;
Matt Kalil,
Harrison Smith and
Blair Walsh in 2012;
Xavier Rhodes, and
Cordarrelle Patterson in 2013; and,
Teddy Bridgewater and
Anthony Barr in 2014;
Trae Waynes,
Eric Kendricks,
Danielle Hunter, and
Stefon Diggs in 2015;
Dalvin Cook in 2017,
Brian O'Neill and
Daniel Carlson in 2018;
Justin Jefferson in 2020; and
Christian Darrisaw in 2021. Prior to 2012 when he was promoted to general manager, Spielman shared a "triangle of authority" in drafts where he ran the personnel department with final say over the draft while working in tandem with the head coach (
Brad Childress until 2010 before he was replaced by
Leslie Frazier) for on-field operations while salary cap and contracts were negotiated by football operations vice president
Rob Brzezinski that all (as a "Triangle of Authority" in some circles) reported directly to team owner
Zygi Wilf. In 2014, Spielman was given the authority to make a head coaching change. He hired
Mike Zimmer to replace
Leslie Frazier. Mike Zimmer and new offensive coordinator
Norv Turner were involved in the draft process in 2014 and 2015. Notable 2015 draft picks on defense included
Eric Kendricks who led the Vikings in tackles,
Danielle Hunter who recorded 6 sacks in limited playing time and saw his role grow towards the end of the year. The Vikings also drafted star wide receiver
Stefon Diggs (4× Pro Bowl, first-team All-Pro (2020), second-team All-Pro (2022)). In 2012, Spielman helped the team sign fullback
Jerome Felton who made it to the
Pro Bowl that same year and who was a major contributor to
Adrian Peterson rushing for the second-highest amount of rushing yards in a season in NFL history. In 2013, Spielman traded WR
Percy Harvin for the Seattle Seahawk's 2013 1st, 7th and 2014 3rd round draft picks. The trade proved to be largely beneficial for the Vikings, as they used that pick on All-Pro Cornerback Xavier Rhodes. In 2015, the Vikings brought in
Terence Newman and traded for
Mike Wallace. The emergence of Stefon Diggs and a poor schematic fit caused the Vikings to cut Wallace, who was subsequently scooped up by the Ravens. However, Both Newman and Rhodes contributed to a record-breaking 2017 Minnesota Vikings defense that led the franchise to its first Conference Championship appearance since 2009. The 2020 offseason saw the Vikings trade Stefon Diggs and a seventh round pick to the
Buffalo Bills in exchange for a first, fourth, fifth, and sixth round pick. With the Bill's 22nd pick of the 2020 draft, the Vikings selected wide receiver
Justin Jefferson. During his last draft overseen in 2021, the Vikings elected to trade down nine spots to draft Darrisaw at offensive tackle. Although Spielman drafted well and made some great trades, he struggled to consistently land talent through free agency. In the 2012 offseason, before Kyle Rudolph was drafted, Spielman signed
Seattle Seahawks tight end John Carlson to a 5-year, $25 million contract. Carlson played only two years for the franchise before being cut, never amassing more than 400 yards receiving. During the 2013 offseason, Spielman signed veteran Green Bay wide receiver
Greg Jennings to a 5-year, $47.5 million ($18 million guaranteed) contract. Jennings failed to surpass 900 yards receiving during his brief tenure and was cut after two seasons. During the 2016 Offseason, Tackle
Mike Remmers was signed to a 5-year, $30 million deal and Guard
Alex Boone was signed to a 4-year, $26.8 million deal. Despite both being signed for multiple years, both players were cut within two years. There were some notable exceptions such as the signing of Pro Bowl nose tackle
Linval Joseph, who was a key contributor to the Vikings 2017 playoff run. In addition, Spielman successfully found key starters in undrafted free agents such as
Andrew Sendejo,
Adam Thielen and
Anthony Harris. In hopes of finally winning it all, the Vikings signed free agent QB Kirk Cousins to a fully guaranteed 3-year $84 million contract in 2018. This signing by Spielman caused tension between him and head coach Zimmer, who was reluctant to allocate such a significant portion of the salary cap to a single player. In August 2020, Spielman signed a multiyear extension with the Vikings. Despite the heavy investment at quarterback, the Vikings failed to make the playoffs in three of the first four years with Cousins at the starting position under Zimmer. Tensions rose between Speilman and Zimmer, with things coming to a head during the 2021 NFL Draft. In an interview with the Star Tribune, Zimmer stated that "...When he picked Kellen Mond|[Kellen] Mond, I walked out of the room... I left the building. I didn’t even talk to him on the phone.". Zimmer also expressed displeasure with Speilman's attempt to trade up for
Justin Fields, and his lack of involvement with the day 2 selections. Zimmer and Spielman were fired on January 10, 2022. In January 2024, Spielman worked with the
Washington Commanders as an advisor in a search that led to the hiring of general manager
Adam Peters and head coach
Dan Quinn.
New York Jets On February 6, 2025, the
New York Jets hired Spielman as a senior football adviser. ==Personal life==