As
Rocketman was not meant to be a chronologically precise
documentary film, creative license was taken with the timing or specifics of the real people or historical events depicted in the film.
Events The timeline of John and Taupin's friendship and career is altered to an extent, as the first song they wrote together after they met in 1967 was "Scarecrow", while "Border Song" was not written until 1969. John and Taupin also spent two years working as staff songwriters for
Dick James, beginning in 1968, and created tracks for artists such as
Roger Cook and
Lulu, with the first album of the pair's music being 1969's
Empty Sky. Regarding the claim that John and Taupin never had an argument, the liner notes for the 1975 album
Captain Fantastic and the Brown Dirt Cowboy features a 12 January 1969 diary entry written by John that reads, "Had row with Bernie." While John did take his first name after
Bluesology bandmate
Elton Dean, his surname was actually adopted from his early mentor and friend,
Long John Baldry, who had hired Bluesology as his backup band in 1966, and not
John Lennon. John admired Baldry as one of the few people in the music scene who were both openly gay and highly esteemed. John is shown to have dated a landlady named Arabella, but he actually dated a secretary named Linda Hannon (née Woodrow) for two years, and was engaged to her in 1969. John ended up sinking into a suicidal depression due to stress faced with the prospect of living a domestic life in the suburbs, and attempted suicide before being found by Bernie Taupin. Less than a month before the wedding, John suddenly broke off their engagement on the advice of Baldry. The experience inspired Taupin to write the lyrics for the song "
Someone Saved My Life Tonight". John's 1970 performance at the
Troubadour was actually well over a year after
Neil Young's last show at the venue (Young has not done another concert there since), and John's show, on 25 August 1970, was actually on a Tuesday (as opposed to the Monday in the film). John is shown playing "Crocodile Rock" at the Troubadour, but the song was not written until two years later; and is also seen meeting his backing band on the night of the show, but he had been touring with bassist
Dee Murray and drummer
Nigel Olsson all over England since April 1970, four months before they went to Los Angeles. The guitarist at the Troubadour concert is fictional: John did not have a guitarist until
Davey Johnstone in 1972. John's concert at the
Dodger Stadium was in 1975, one year before the recording of "
Don't Go Breaking My Heart". They officially announced their divorce on 18 November 1988. John did cancel a concert at the
Madison Square Garden in New York, although this was in 1984 due to illness. John actually checked into rehab in 1990 at the
Advocate Lutheran General Hospital in Chicago a few months after a young friend,
Ryan White, had died from
AIDS, and after a visit to his boyfriend at the time, Hugh Williams, in a rehab facility in Prescott, Arizona. "I'm Still Standing" was not written while John was in rehab; the song was recorded in 1982, and the song and the video were released a year later. In a previous 2010 interview, Geoff recalled, "When I was growing up, Elton was always there and we had a lot of fun on family holidays and things like that". The depiction of Dick James was disputed by musician
Caleb Quaye, who was a member of John's former band Bluesology. Quaye described James as "a gentleman," and criticised him being shown in the film as a boorish, foul-mouthed
cockney. "He wasn't cockney. He was an old-school music man but was smartly dressed, you never heard a cuss word out of him. He was like a father, he gave us an opportunity to learn our craft. I don't understand the fantasy of depicting him like that because he was nothing like it." James' son, Stephen James (who helped discover Elton and encouraged Dick to sign him up to his music label
DJM Records), also criticised the film's portrayal of his father, calling John "basically a coward" and claiming that he wanted to destroy "everybody who was helpful or good" during the early days of his career, adding, "I don't understand why he seems to feel the need to try to destroy everybody who helped him. We only ever tried to do the best for him and to promote his career. I really am very upset that he has turned on people in this way. They basically depict my father in the film completely opposite to the way he was in real life." Beatles historian
Mark Lewisohn also criticised the depiction of James in the film, calling it "utterly outrageous and really disgusting." The portrayal of John Reid, who is depicted as being emotionally abusive towards John, was attacked by Wombles creator Mike Batt as a "weapons-grade character assassination". ==See also==