Precursors and early history In May 1919, during the Russian Revolution, the
White military forces under General
Anton Denikin were achieving the apex of their military success. In the Russian city of
Stavropol, then controlled by the White Army, a group of Russian bishops organized an ecclesiastical administration body, the
Temporary Higher Church Administration in Southeastern Russia (). On 7 November (20 November) 1920,
Tikhon,
Patriarch of Moscow, his Synod, and the Supreme Church Council in Moscow issued a joint resolution, No. 362, instructing all Russian Orthodox Christian bishops, should they be unable to maintain liaison with the Supreme Church Administration in
Moscow, to seek protection and guidance by organizing among themselves. The resolution was interpreted as effectively legitimizing the Temporary Higher Church Administration, and served as the legal basis for the eventual establishment of a completely independent church body. In November 1920, after the final defeat of the
Russian Army in
South Russia, a number of Russian bishops evacuated from Crimea to
Constantinople, then
occupied by
British,
French, and
Italian forces. After learning that General
Pyotr Wrangel intended to keep his army, they likewise decided to keep the Russian ecclesiastical organization as a separate entity abroad. The Temporary Church Authority met on 19 November 1920 aboard the ship
Grand Duke Alexander Mikhailovich (), presided over by Metropolitan
Antony (Khrapovitsky). Metropolitan Antony and Bishop
Benjamin (Fedchenkov) were appointed to examine the canonicity of the organization. On 2 December 1920, they received permission from Metropolitan Dorotheos of
Prousa, Locum Tenens of the
Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople, to establish "for the purpose of the service of the population [...] and to oversee the ecclesiastic life of Russian colonies in Orthodox countries a temporary committee (epitropia) under the authority of the Ecumenical Patriarchate"; the committee was called the Temporary Higher Church Administration Abroad (THCAA).
In Karlovci On 14 February 1921, Metropolitan
Antony (Khrapovitsky) settled in the town of
Sremski Karlovci,
Serbia (then within the Kingdom of Yugoslavia), where he was given the
palace of former Patriarchs of Karlovci (the
Patriarchate of Karlovci had been abolished in 1920). In the next months, at the invitation of Patriarch
Dimitrije of Serbia, the other eight bishops of the THCAA, including
Anastasius (Gribanovsky) and
Benjamin (Fedchenkov), as well as numerous priests and monks, relocated to Serbia. On 31 August 1921, the Council of Bishops of the
Serbian Church passed a resolution, effective from 3 October, recognizing the THCAA as an administratively independent jurisdiction for exiled Russian clergy outside the
Kingdom of Yugoslavia (SHS), as well as for those Russian clergy in the Kingdom who were not in parish or state educational service. The THCAA jurisdiction was subsequently extended to hearing divorce cases of exiled Russians. The appeal to the Genoa Conference, which was published in 1922, called on the world powers to intervene and "help banish Bolshevism" from Russia. The majority of the Council members secretly decided to request that Grand Duke
Nicholas Nikolaevich head up the Russian monarchist movement in exile. (But, pursuant to the laws of the Russian Empire, the seniormost surviving male member of the Romanovs was
Kirill Vladimirovich, and in August 1924 he proclaimed himself as the
Russian Emperor in exile.) Patriarch Tikhon addressed a decree of 5 May 1922 to Metropolitan
Eulogius Georgiyevsky, abolishing the SEAA and declaring the political decisions of the Karlovci Council to be against the position of the Russian Church. Tikhon appointed Metropolitan Eulogius as administrator for the "Russian orthodox churches abroad". Meeting in Sremski Karlovci on 2 September 1922, pursuant to Tikhon's decree, the Council of Bishops abolished the SEAA, in its place forming the Temporary Holy Synod of Bishops of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia, with Metropolitan Anthony as its head by virtue of seniority. This Synod exercised direct authority over Russian parishes in the Balkans, the Middle East, and the Far East. In North America, however, a conflict developed among bishops who did not recognize the authority of the Synod, led by Metropolitan
Platon (Rozhdestvensky); this group formed the
American Metropolia, the predecessor to the
OCA. In Western Europe, Metropolitan
Eulogius (Georgievsky), based in
Paris from late 1922, did likewise, stating that the Synod was merely "a moral authority." Metropolitan Eulogius later broke off from the ROC, and in February 1931 joined the
Ecumenical Patriarchate. This seminal act formed the
Patriarchal Exarchate for Orthodox Parishes of Russian Tradition in Western Europe. On 5 September 1927, the Council of Bishops in Sremski Karlovci, presided over by Metropolitan Anthony, decreed a formal break of liaison with the "Moscow church authority." They rejected a demand by Metropolitan
Sergius (Stragorodsky) of Nizhny Novgorod, who was acting on behalf of Locum Tenens (Metropolitan
Peter of Krutitsy, imprisoned then in the Soviet
Gulag, where he later died), to declare political loyalty to the Soviet authorities. The Council of Bishops said that the church administration in Moscow, headed by Metropolitan Sergius (Stragorodsky), was "enslaved by the godless Soviet power that has deprived it of freedom in its expression of will and canonical governance of the Church." While rejecting both the
Bolsheviks and the de facto head of the Russian Orthodox Church, Metropolitan Sergius (who in 1943 would be elected as
Patriarch), the ROCOR continued to nominally recognize the authority of the imprisoned Metropolitan
Peter of Krutitsy. On September 9, the Council stated: "The part of the Russian Church that finds itself abroad considers itself an inseparable, spiritually united branch of the great Russian Church. It doesn't separate itself from its Mother Church and doesn't consider itself
autocephalous." Meanwhile, inside the USSR, Metropolitan Sergius' Declaration caused a
schism among the flock of the Patriarch's Church. Many dissenting believers broke ties with Metropolitan Sergius. On 22 June 1934, Metropolitan Sergius and his Synod in Moscow passed judgment on Metropolitan Anthony and his Synod, declaring them to be suspended. Metropolitan Anthony refused to recognize this decision, claiming that it was made under political pressure from Soviet authorities and that Metropolitan Sergius had illegally usurped the position of Locum Tenens. He was supported in this by the Patriarch
Varnava of Serbia, who continued to maintain communion with the ROCOR Synod. However, Patriarch Varnava also attempted to mediate between the Karlovci Synod and Metropolitan Sergius in Moscow, and to find a canonically legitimate way to settle the dispute. In early 1934, he had sent a letter to Sergius proposing that the Karlovci bishops be transferred to the jurisdiction of the
Serbian Church; the proposal was rejected by Sergius. Sergius continued to demand that all Russian clergy outside the USSR pledge loyalty to the Soviet authorities. Patriarch Varnava's attempts in the mid-1930s to reconcile the rival exile Russian jurisdictions were likewise unsuccessful. Metropolitan Anthony (Khrapovitsky) died in 1936. He was succeeded by
Anastasius (Gribanovsky). After the deaths of Metropolitan Anthony in August 1936 and Metropolitan
Peter of Krutitsy in October 1937 (albeit falsely reported a year prior), the Russian bishops in exile held the Second All-Diaspora Council, first in
Belgrade, then in Sremski Karlovci, in August 1938. The council was presided over by Metropolitan
Anastasius (Gribanovsky), and was attended by 12 other exiled Russian bishops (at least double the number of Orthodox (Patriarchal) bishops who were allowed to serve within the USSR), 26 priests, and 58 laypersons. The Council confirmed the leading role of the Church and its bishops in Russian émigré organizations, and adopted two missives: to Russians in the USSR () and to the Russian flock in diaspora (). From February 1938,
Germany's authorities demanded that all the Russian clergy in the territories controlled by Germany be under the Karlovci jurisdiction (as opposed to that of
Paris-based Eulogius). They insisted that an ethnic
German,
Seraphim Lade, be put in charge of the Orthodox diocese of
Berlin.
World War II and post-war period The relationship between members of the ROCOR and the Nazis in the run-up to and during World War II has been an issue addressed by both the Church and its critics. Metropolitan Anastassy wrote a letter to
Adolf Hitler in 1938, thanking him for his aid to the Russian Diaspora in allowing them to build a Russian Orthodox Cathedral in Berlin and praising his
patriotism. This has been defended as an act that occurred when the Metropolitan and others in the church knew "little …of the inner workings of the
Third Reich." At the ROCOR Second Church History Conference in 2002, a paper said that "the attempt of the Nazi leadership to divide the Church into separate and even inimical church formations was met with internal church opposition." Meanwhile, the USSR leadership's policies towards religion in general, as well as policy towards the Moscow Patriarchate's jurisdiction in the USSR, changed significantly. In early September 1943,
Joseph Stalin met at the Kremlin with a group of three surviving ROC metropolitans headed by
Sergius (Stragorodsky). He allowed the Moscow Patriarchate to convene a council and elect a Patriarch, open theological schools, and reopen a few previously closed major monasteries and some churches (said institutions had been reopened in territory
occupied by Germany). The Soviet government decisively sided with the Moscow Patriarchate, while the so-called
Obnovlentsi ("Renovationists," i.e. the modernist, pro-Soviet current in the ROC), previously favored by the authorities, were sidelined; their proponents were disappeared shortly after. These developments did not change the mutual rejection between the Moscow Patriarchate and the ROCOR leaderships. Days after the election in September 1943 of Sergius (Stragorodsky) as Patriarch in Moscow, Metropolitan
Anastasius (Gribanovsky) made a statement against recognizing his election. Thus, the German authorities allowed the ROCOR Synod to hold a convention in
Vienna, which took place on 21—26 October 1943. The Synod adopted a resolution declaring the election of Patriarch in Moscow to be uncanonical and hence invalid, and called on all Russian Orthodox faithful to fight against Communism. On 8 September 1944, days before
Belgrade was taken by the
Red Army, on the attack from the East, Metropolitan Anastasius (Gribanovsky), along with his office and the other bishops, left Serbia for Vienna. A few months later, they moved to
Munich; finally, in November 1950, they immigrated to the
United States, together with numerous other Russian Orthodox refugees in the
postwar period. After the end of World War II, the Moscow Patriarchate was the globally dominant branch of Russian Orthodox Christianity. Countries whose Orthodox bishops had been part of the ROCOR in the
interwar period, such as Yugoslavia,
China,
Bulgaria, and
East Germany, were now within the USSR-led bloc, which rendered any activity by the ROCOR politically impossible. A number of ROCOR parishes and clergy, notably
Eulogius (Georgiyevsky) (in a
jurisdiction under the
Ecumenical See since 1931), joined the Moscow Patriarchate, and some repatriated to the USSR. Until well after World War II, most of the Orthodox Church properties in
Palestine were controlled by leaders opposed to both the Soviet rule and the Moscow Patriarchate, i.e. mainly within the ROCOR. When
Israel became a state in 1948, it transferred all of the property under the control of the ROCOR within its borders to the Soviet-dominated Russian Orthodox Church in appreciation for Moscow's support of the Jewish state (this support was short-lived). The ROCOR maintained control over churches and properties in the
Jordanian-ruled West Bank until the late 1980s. In January 1951, the Soviets reopened the
Russian Palestine Society under the direction of Communist Party agents from Moscow, and replaced Archimandrite Vladimir with Ignaty Polikarp, who had been trained by Communists. They attracted numerous Christian Arabs to the ROC who had Communist sympathies. The members of other branches of Orthodoxy refused to associate with the Soviet-led ROC in Palestine.
Cold War period The third
First-Hierarch of the ROCOR was
Philaret (Voznesensky), who served from 1964 until his death in 1985. After the declaration of Metropolitan Sergius of 1927, there were a range of opinions regarding the Moscow Patriarchate within ROCOR. There was a general belief in ROCOR that the Soviet government was manipulating the Moscow Patriarchate to one extent or another, and that under such circumstances administrative ties were impossible. There were also official statements made that the elections of the patriarchs of Moscow which occurred after 1927 were invalid because they were not conducted freely (without the interference of the Soviets) or with the participation of the entire Russian Church. Historically, ROCOR has always affirmed that it was an inseparable part of the Russian Church, and that its autonomous status was only temporary, based upon Ukaz 362, until such time as the domination of the Soviet government over the affairs of the Church should cease: :"The Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia is an indissoluble part of the Russian Orthodox Church, and for the time until the extermination in Russia of the atheist government, is self-governing on conciliar principles in accordance with the resolution of the Patriarch, the Most Holy Synod, and the Highest Church Council [Sobor] of the Russian Church dated 7/20 November 1920, No. 362." Similarly, Metropolitan
Anastassy (Gribanovsky) wrote in his last will and testament: :"As regards the Moscow Patriarchate and its hierarchs, then, so long as they continue in close, active and benevolent cooperation with the Soviet Government, which openly professes its complete godlessness and strives to implant atheism in the entire Russian nation, then the Church Abroad, maintaining Her purity, must not have any canonical, liturgical or even simply external communion with them whatsoever, leaving each one of them at the same time to the final judgment of the Council (Sobor) of the future free Russian Church." The
Catacomb Church had been a significant part of the Russian Church prior to the relaxation of the suppression of the Church on the part of
Stalin, in 1943. Most of those in the ROCOR were
White émigrés who had left Russia well before World War II. They were unaware of the changes that had occurred immediately after World War II—most significantly that with the election of Patriarch
Alexei I in 1945, after which most of the Catacomb Church was reconciled with the Moscow Patriarchate. By the 1970s, due to this reconciliation, as well as to continued persecution by the Soviets, there was very little left of the Catacomb Church.
Alexander Solzhenitsyn made this point in a letter to the 1974 All-Diaspora Sobor of the ROCOR, in which he stated that ROCOR should not "show solidarity with a mysterious, sinless, but also bodiless catacomb." Through its publications, ROCOR expressed support for efforts to resist communism during the
Vietnam War.
Vitaly (Ustinov) served as the fourth First-Hierarch from 1985 until his retirement in 2001. After the end of the
Soviet Union in December 1991, ROCOR continued to maintain its administrative independence from the
Russian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate). In May 1990, months prior to the complete disintegration of the USSR, the ROCOR decided to establish new, in the USSR, and to consecrate bishops to oversee such parishes.
Post-Soviet period In 1997
Patriarch of Moscow Alexei II attempted to visit a
ROCOR-held monastery in
Hebron with
Yasser Arafat. "The Moscow-based church has enjoyed a close relationship with Arafat since his guerrilla fighter days." The ROCOR clergy refused to allow Arafat and the patriarch to enter the church, holding that Alexei had no legitimate authority. Two weeks later police officers of the
Palestinian Authority arrived; they evicted the ROCOR clergy and turned the property over to the ROC. Alexei made another visit in early January 2000 to meet with Arafat, asking "for help in recovering church properties" as part of a "worldwide campaign to recover properties lost to churches that split off during the Communist era". Later that month the Palestinian Authority again acted to evict ROCOR clergy, this time from the Monastery of Abraham's Oak in Hebron. Metropolitan
Vitaly (Ustinov) in 2001 was succeeded by the fifth
First-Hierarch of the ROCOR, Metropolitan
Laurus (Škurla), who oversaw the reconciliation with the Russian Orthodox Church in 2007. After the death of Laurus in 2008, he was succeeded by the sixth First-Hierarch, Metropolitan
Hilarion (Kapral). Metropolitan
Hilarion (Kapral) died in May 2022. ==Reconciliation with the Moscow Patriarchate==