Following his retirement, McAfee became a football analyst and a host of
sports talk shows. After starting his own talk show,
The Pat McAfee Show, he grew to become one of the most popular figures in the sports media industry, eventually earning an eight figure deal with
ESPN.
Barstool Sports During his final season with the Colts, McAfee began to perform stand-up comic routines about his time in the NFL. Following his retirement from football at the close of the 2016 season, McAfee joined
Barstool Sports, where he developed the "Heartland" division of the company in
Indianapolis and hosted
The Pat McAfee Show on
SiriusXM channel Barstool Power 85. McAfee announced his separation from Barstool Sports on August 31, 2018, citing a lack of transparency with the business operations of the company as his reason for leaving.
Pat McAfee Inc. Upon departing from Barstool Sports in 2018, McAfee incorporated a small business, Pat McAfee Inc. (PMI), from his original office in
Indianapolis. PMI continued to operate McAfee's charity, The Pat McAfee Foundation, and began selling merchandise. At first, PMI produced four podcasts,
The Pat McAfee Show 2.0, ''That's Hockey Talk
, Heartland Radio 2.0
, and Good Bettor Bets
. The former two are still in operation as of 2021, with The Pat McAfee Show 2.0
re-running clips from his daily show on Sirius XM, while That's Hockey Talk
was originally co-hosted by former NFL center A. Q. Shipley, but Shipley was replaced by former NHL player Mike Rupp in 2021. Heartland Radio 2.0
evolved into The Pod'' after the departure of former host, Todd McComas, while PMI's gambling podcast,
Good Bettor Bets, re-branded into
Hammer Dahn with the addition of former NFL general manager
Michael Lombardi as a guest co-host. On August 7, 2019, it was reported that McAfee would begin to host a two-hour, weekday radio show,
The Pat McAfee Show, beginning September 9, 2019, syndicated by
DAZN and
Westwood One. The deal with DAZN also includes McAfee streaming his podcast on the service three times per week, and appearances in NFL-related shoulder content in regions where DAZN holds streaming rights to the league (primarily Canada and Germany). They parted ways in August 2020 due to McAfee's disdain for FCC regulations on terrestrial radio. In September 2020,
The Pat McAfee Show moved to
Sirius XM's Mad Dog Sports Radio from 12 to 3 pm on weekdays. The show is also broadcast live on YouTube. Former NFL linebacker, and consistent collaborator,
A. J. Hawk co-hosts the second and third hours of the show with McAfee. McAfee's former teammate
Darius Butler co-hosts the show on Fridays when it is broadcast from Tampa, Florida. During the NFL season, McAfee frequently hosts
Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback
Aaron Rodgers on his program. Sirius XM stopped airing the show in August 2022. In March 2021, PMI brought back
The Best Wrestling Show, formerly known as ''Wrasslin' With Sports Entertainment'', a wrestling podcast that had aired one episode in 2019. It is hosted by former WWE employee and PMI executive producer Mike Mansury, and Pittsburgh-based radio commentator & former
World Championship Wrestling commentator
Mark Madden. The podcast was short-lived, as Mansury left PMI to focus on independent work in May of the same year and the low viewership numbers caused by Madden. In 2021, McAfee announced plans to move PMI's base of operations to a former United Methodist Church in
Lawrence, Indiana. On December 9, 2021, McAfee announced a four-year, $120 million sponsorship agreement with
FanDuel to serve as the sponsor and official odds provider of
The Pat McAfee Show.
Fox Sports On November 24, 2018, McAfee made his college football broadcasting debut on Fox, calling a college football game between
Baylor and
Texas Tech. On December 30, McAfee made his NFL broadcasting debut on Fox, joining
Justin Kutcher,
Robert Smith, and sideline reporter
Sarah Kustok for the
Lions–
Packers game.
ESPN On July 29, 2019,
Adam Schefter announced via Twitter that McAfee would be joining
ESPN as the
color analyst for their
Thursday Night College Football broadcasts, alongside
Matt Hasselbeck. The news came after McAfee had auditioned for ESPN's
Monday Night Football after
Jason Witten's return to the Cowboys, though ESPN decided to retain its booth as is. In the same year, McAfee began making regular appearances on
Get Up! and
College GameDay, after appearing on the latter show as a celebrity guest picker. In September 2022, it was announced that McAfee would be returning to ESPN. He serves as a full-time analyst on
College Gameday. He will serve as an analyst for ESPN's coverage of the
Rose Bowl, the
College Football Playoff, the
Super Bowl and
Pro Bowl. On August 17, 2023, it was announced that The Pat McAfee Show would be making its debut on ESPN, ESPN+ and YouTube on September 7, 2023, the same day as the 2023 NFL season opener. Although the exact dollar amount of his deal with ESPN was not publicly disclosed, it has been reported to be over eight figures. On April 1, 2025, it was reported that his amplification of a false rumor about a student at the
University of Mississippi had sparked harassment and bullying. McAfee talked about the false rumor with guests on his show and posted a clip of the discussion on
X, captioned "What's going on at Ole Miss". McAfee has also faced criticism for allowing
Aaron Rodgers to promote
Anti-vaccine conspiracy theories on his show.
Other appearances In 2016, McAfee performed in
stand-up events around
Indiana. McAfee was a regular on the nationally syndicated morning radio program
The Bob & Tom Show, itself based in Indianapolis. He has described co-host
Bob Kevoian as one of his best friends during an interview on the
Off the Air Podcast hosted by sports commentator
Chick McGee. In 2018, McAfee made his professional baseball debut for the
Washington Wild Things as a right-fielder and guest first base coach. He made a
putout in the outfield and went 0–3 at the plate, reaching second base on a throwing error before being replaced with a
pinch runner. He was a sideline reporter for the
XFL for some of its games in 2020. McAfee is a co-host on the sports gambling podcast
Hammer Dahn, which is produced by his business, Pat McAfee Inc. He makes occasional appearances on PMI's other podcasts,
The Pod and ''That's Hockey Talk''. He took part in
The Soccer Tournament in 2024 as a player, and as a team manager in 2025. ==Professional wrestling career==