A group of 25
Scotch Presbyterian families became the first European settlers in what would become
Orange County when they settled at the mouth of the Moodna in 1685. The creek served as an important transportation route for soldiers during the
American Revolutionary War. During
colonial times, and for a short time after
independence, the creek formed part of the boundary between Orange and
Ulster counties. In 1935, a Newburgh waitress named Dorothy Sherwood admitted to drowning her two-year-old son, Jimmy, in the Moodna. She was initially sentenced to death but, on appeal, was allowed to plead guilty to
manslaughter and was sentenced to between six and fifteen years in prison. The case received national press attention. By 1965, the Moodna was so heavily polluted that, according to
Lee Mailler, he had seen the water run "green, pink, cream and blue" but that it usually looked "like curdled milk." A
Mountainville resident told the
Daily News that the smell from the Moodna was "so bad, so strong that it [could] awaken you from sleep." Joseph Martin and Douglas Sefton wrote in the
News that the Moodna's pollution problem was emblematic of a
nationwide pollution crisis. Although state officials acknowledged that a paper mill on the creek was largely responsible for the pollution, state and federal officials proved ineffective at remedying the situation for years due to bureaucratic entanglements. In 1970, the state gave the Town of New Windsor a $333,037 grant ($ in ) to build wastewater treatment facilities on the creek. Heavy rains during the
April 2007 Nor'easter caused the creek to flood extensively in its upper course in and around Washingtonville. Route 94 was blocked in both directions, and Route 208 from the south, leaving only northern access to the village available. Almost a hundred residents had to leave their homes for temporary shelter at a local elementary school.
Hurricane Irene caused the creek to swell, coming nearly to the platform of the 9W bridge, and washing out an area at the Forge Hill Road bridge. This caused the closing of part of Butternut Drive, and all of Forge Hill Road, except the easternmost , from Route 9W to Staples Lane. The portion east of Staples Lane remains open to local traffic, until the east end of the bridge, which is unstable. One house on Butternut Lane has been condemned, and the property fenced off, due to the dangerous dropoff on the property. The road was not rebuilt and reopened until the late 2010s. ==Recreation==