MarketChinese Civil War
Company Profile

Chinese Civil War

The Chinese Civil War was fought between the Kuomintang-led government of the Republic of China and the forces of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). Armed conflict continued intermittently from 1 August 1927 until Communist victory resulted in their near-complete control over mainland China on 10 December 1949.

Background
Following the collapse of the Qing dynasty and the 1911 Revolution, Sun Yat-sen assumed the presidency of the newly formed Republic of China, and was shortly thereafter succeeded by Yuan Shikai. Yuan failed in a short-lived attempt to declare himself emperor, and China fell into power struggle after his death in 1916. The Kuomintang (KMT), led by Sun Yat-sen, created a new government in Guangzhou to rival the warlords who ruled over large swathes of China and prevented the formation of a solid central government. After Sun's efforts to obtain aid from Western countries were ignored, he turned to the Soviet Union. In 1923, Sun and Soviet representative Adolph Joffe in Shanghai pledged Soviet assistance to China's unification in the Sun–Joffe Manifesto, a declaration of cooperation among the Comintern, KMT, and the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). In 1923, Sun sent Chiang Kai-shek, one of his lieutenants, for several months of military and political study in Moscow. Chiang then became the head of the Whampoa Military Academy that trained the next generation of military leaders. The Soviets provided the academy with teaching material, organization, and equipment, including munitions. Communist members were allowed to join the KMT on an individual basis. As of 1923, the KMT had 50,000 members. On 7 April, Chiang and several other KMT leaders held a meeting, during which they proposed that Communist activities were socially and economically disruptive and had to be undone for the Nationalist revolution to proceed. On 12 April, many communists within the KMT were purged in Shanghai through hundreds of arrests and executions on the orders of General Bai Chongxi. The CCP referred to this as the 12 April Incident, the Shanghai massacre, and the beginning of the White Terror. This incident widened the rift between Chiang and Wang Jingwei, the leader of the left wing faction of the KMT. The left wing of the KMT also expelled CCP members from the Wuhan Government, which in turn was toppled by Chiang Kai-shek. The KMT resumed its campaign against the warlords and captured Beijing in June 1928. Soon, most of eastern China was under the control of the Nanjing central government, which received prompt international recognition as the sole legitimate government of China. The KMT government announced, in conformity with Sun Yat-sen, the formula for the three stages of revolution: military unification, political tutelage, and constitutional democracy. == Communist insurgency (1927–1937) ==
Communist insurgency (1927–1937)
}} On 1 August 1927, the CCP launched an uprising in Nanchang against the Nationalist government in Wuhan. This conflict led to the creation of the Red Army. On 4 August, the main forces of the Red Army left Nanchang and headed southwards for an assault on Guangdong. Nationalist forces quickly reoccupied Nanchang while the remaining members of the CCP in Nanchang went into hiding. Borodin then returned to the Soviet Union in October via Mongolia. In November, Chiang Kai-shek went to Shanghai and invited Wang to join him. On 11 December, the CCP started the Guangzhou Uprising, establishing a soviet there the next day, but lost the city by 13 December to a counter-attack under the orders of General Zhang Fakui. On 16 December, Wang Jingwei fled to France. There were now three capitals in China: the internationally recognized republic capital in Beijing, the CCP and left-wing KMT at Wuhan and the right-wing KMT regime at Nanjing, which would remain the KMT capital for the next decade. This marked the beginning of a ten-year armed struggle, known in mainland China as the "Ten-Year Civil War" (十年内战) which ended with the Xi'an Incident, when Chiang Kai-shek was forced to form the Second United Front against invading forces from the Empire of Japan. In 1930, the Central Plains War broke out as an internal conflict of the KMT; launched by Feng Yuxiang, Yan Xishan, and Wang Jingwei. The attention was turned to root out remaining pockets of CCP activity in a series of five encirclement campaigns. The first and second campaigns failed, and the third was aborted due to the Mukden Incident. The fourth campaign (1932–1933) achieved some early successes, but Chiang's armies were badly mauled when they tried to penetrate into the heart of Mao's Soviet Chinese Republic. During these campaigns, KMT columns struck swiftly into CCP areas, but were easily engulfed by the vast countryside and were not able to consolidate their foothold. Finally, in late 1934, Chiang launched a fifth campaign that involved the systematic encirclement of the Jiangxi Soviet region with fortified blockhouses. The blockhouse strategy was devised and implemented in part by newly hired Nazi advisors. Unlike previous campaigns in which they penetrated deeply in a single strike, this time the KMT troops patiently built blockhouses, each separated by about , to surround the Communist areas and cut off their supplies and food sources. This military retreat was undertaken by the Chinese Communist Party, led by Mao Zedong, to evade the pursuit or attack of the Kuomintang army. It consisted of a series of marches, during which numerous Communist armies in the south escaped to the north and west. Over the course of the march from Jiangxi the First Front Army, led by an inexperienced military commission, was on the brink of annihilation by Chiang Kai-Shek's troops as their stronghold was in Jiangxi. The Communists, under the command of Mao Zedong and Zhou Enlai, "escaped in a circling retreat to the west and north, which reportedly traversed over over 370 days." The route passed through some of the most difficult terrain of western China by traveling west, and then northwards towards Shaanxi. "In November 1935, shortly after settling in northern Shaanxi, Mao officially took over Zhou Enlai's leading position in the Red Army. Following a major reshuffling of official roles, Mao became the chairman of the Military Commission, with Zhou and Deng Xiaoping as vice-chairmen." This marked Mao's position as the preeminent leader of the CCP, with Zhou in second position to him. The march ended when the CCP reached the interior of Shaanxi. Zhang Guotao's army (Red 4th Front Army), which took a different route through northwest China, was largely destroyed by the forces of Chiang Kai-shek and his Chinese Muslim allies, the Ma clique. Along the way, the Communist army confiscated property and weapons from local warlords and landlords, while recruiting peasants and the poor, solidifying its appeal to the masses. Of the 90,000–100,000 people who began the Long March from the Soviet Chinese Republic, only around 7,000–8,000 made it to Shaanxi. The remnants of Zhang's forces eventually joined Mao in Shaanxi, but with his army destroyed, Zhang, even as a founding member of the CCP, was never able to challenge Mao's authority. Essentially, the great retreat made Mao the undisputed leader of the Chinese Communist Party. The Kuomintang used Khampa troopswho were former banditsto battle the Communist Red Army as it advanced and to undermine local warlords who often refused to fight Communist forces to conserve their own strength. The KMT enlisted 300 "Khampa bandits" into its Consolatory Commission military in Sichuan, where they were part of the effort of the central government to penetrate and destabilize local Han warlords such as Liu Wenhui. The government was seeking to exert full control over frontier areas against the warlords. Liu had refused to battle the Communists in order to conserve his army. The Consolatory Commission forces were used to battle the Red Army, but they were defeated when their religious leader was captured by the Communists. File:Nationalist China 1929 - 1937.PNG|The situation in China in 1929: After the Northern Expedition, the KMT had direct control over east and central China, while the rest of China proper as well as Manchuria was under the control of warlords loyal to the Nationalist government. File:China Soviet Zones.png|Map showing the communist-controlled Soviet Zones of China during and after the encirclement campaigns File:The Long March 1934 - 1935.PNG|Route(s) taken by Communist forces during the Long March File:Long-march.jpg|A Communist leader addressing survivors of the Long March File:Chiang1926.jpg|Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek, Commander-in-Chief of the National Revolutionary Army, emerged from the Northern Expedition as the leader of the Republic of China File:National Revolutionary Army troops.png|NRA soldiers marching File:National Revolutionary Army artillery.png|NRA troops firing artillery at Communist forces Japanese expansionism and united front negotiations In 1931, the Empire of Japan invaded Manchuria. Although the Japanese expansionism in China posed a clear threat to both sides of the civil war, at first it did not lead to a cessation of hostilities. Rather, Chiang believed that "The Japanese are a disease of the skin. The Communists are a disease of the heart." He ordered his general in Manchuria not to resist the Japanese advance and instead focused on continuing the encirclement campaigns in the south. He called this policy "first internal pacification, then external resistance." The CCP in turn reacted with disdain to Chiang's policy of nonresistance, viewing him as a pawn of the Japanese. They saw fighting the Nationalist government as an essential part of resistance to Japan and called for "Resisting Japan and Opposing Chiang". Nonetheless, prosecuting the civil war while also resisting Japan became increasingly impractical for the CCP in particular. Already by late 1932, Communist guerilla groups in Manchuria had begun to cooperate with Nationalist guerillas against the Japanese occupiers. The CCP also began to come under pressure from the Soviet Union to negotiate an end to the civil war. The USSR was concerned with events in Europe—especially Hitler's rise to power—and wanted Communist parties to form united fronts with moderates to resist fascist aggression. This policy was formally adopted by the 7th World Congress of the Comintern in the summer of 1935. The CCP delegation at the Congress, headed by Wang Ming, published the "August 1 Declaration" describing how a united front could be created in China. They recommended a government of national defense including all parties in China that wanted to resist Japanese imperialism. Importantly, because they still considered Chiang to be a "running dog" of the Japanese, they did not extend this offer to the Nationalist government. The CCP itself was in the middle of the Long March during the Comintern Congress and was cut off from radio communication with Moscow. Its leaders learned of the Congress's decisions in November 1935. The following month, they held a conference at Wayaobu to discuss the implications of this new Comintern policy. The Wayaobu Manifesto that they published was a significant retreat from the hardline positions they had held during the early civil war. It called for "the most broad national united front" to resist Japan, and announced that the CCP was willing to suspend class conflict in the interests of cross-class collaboration. However, they did not intend for the Chinese Red Army to surrender or submit to the Nationalists. On the contrary, their plan to resist the Japanese centered on expanding the Red Army to 1 million men and dramatically increasing the land area covered by the Chinese Soviet Republic. In late 1935 relations between Nanjing and Tokyo took a sharp downturn as Japan stepped up its expansionist policies in north China. Chiang Kai-shek feared that a full-scale invasion of China was imminent, and wanted to secure the material and diplomatic support of the Soviet Union. He also faced growing public pressure to actively resist Japan; on 9 December 1935, for example, a major student protest broke out in Beiping. In January, Chiang Kai-shek sent emissaries to Moscow to negotiate a military mutual assistance treaty. However, as a precondition for a treaty, Chiang wanted the Soviet Union to order the CCP to submit to the Nationalist Government. The Soviet ambassador told Chiang that while the USSR hoped the CCP would agree to a unified command under the Nationalists, Chiang would have to negotiate directly with the CCP. This upset Chiang, who worried that if the USSR was unwilling to order the CCP to stop, they might be willing to support further revolutionary actions by the CCP if a ceasefire broke down. Progress halted, and after news leaked to the press that Chiang was contemplating a treaty with the USSR, he called off negotiations. : Meanwhile, the CCP opened up separate negotiations with the Nationalist forces besieging them in northwest China. They managed to sign secret ceasefire agreements with Zhang Xueliang, leader of the Northeastern Army, and Yang Hucheng, leader of the Northwestern Army. These generals were frustrated that Chiang' was prioritizing civil war over resistance to Japan. Yan Xishan, another neighboring warlord, also signed a secret agreement with the Communists, although he was not as closely aligned with them as Zhang or Yang. The members of this northwestern alliance were united by their desire to resist Japan, but they differed over the details of how this could best be accomplished. The Communists supported a plan to use Soviet support to take over Shaanxi, Gansu, Ningxia, Qinghai, and Xinjiang and turn northwest China into a base under Zhang's command to resist Japan and oppose Chiang. Zhang, Yang, and Yan were still committed to convincing Chiang to lead the anti-Japanese resistance. As they continued to negotiate, they kept their alliance secret and even staged fake military battles to allay the suspicions of the Nanjing government. Negotiations between Chiang and the CCP began in earnest in late 1936. Chiang continued to try to resolve the civil war militarily; he continued to consider a negotiated settlement with the CCP to be a last resort. He was encouraged by the results of the Ningxia campaign in mid-to-late October. In that campaign, the Second and Fourth Corps of the Red Army marched north to pick up supplies dropped in Mongolia by the Soviet Union, but found themselves trapped on the wrong side of the Yellow River. They were cut to pieces by the Hui cavalry allied with the Nationalists. Chiang began making preparations for a sixth encirclement campaign, and instructed Zhang and Yang to participate. In early November, Chen Lifu presented Pan Hannian with a set of extremely harsh conditions for a deal. Pan balked, calling them "conditions for surrender". In late November, Chiang ordered the Northeastern Army and forces from the central Nationalist Army, Hu Zongnan's Right Route Army, to attack towards the Communist capital at Bao'an. At the resulting Battle of Shanchengbao, the Northeastern Army withheld most of its forces from the attack. This allowed the Red Army to ambush and nearly wipe out Hu's 78th regiment. This reversed the diplomatic situation: Chen Lifu moderated his conditions, but the CCP recalled Pan Hannian from Nanjing on December 10. In late 1936, Zhang Xueliang decided that his repeated attempts to persuade Chiang to create a united front with the Communists were not going to be enough. To Zhang, Chiang appeared dead-set on continuing the civil war even as the threat of Japanese invasion loomed ever larger. Following Yang Hucheng's advice, he decided to resort to drastic measures. On 12 December 1936, the disgruntled Zhang and Yang conspired to kidnap Chiang and force him into a truce with the CCP. The incident became known as the Xi'an Incident. Both parties suspended fighting to form a Second United Front to focus their energies and fight the Japanese. == Second Sino-Japanese War (1937–1945) ==
Second Sino-Japanese War (1937–1945)
In 1937, Japan launched its full-scale invasion of China and its well-equipped troops overran KMT defenders in northern and coastal China. After the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor in December 1941, the Sino-Japanese War became part of World War II. The alliance of CCP and KMT was in name only. Unlike the KMT forces, CCP troops shunned conventional warfare and instead waged guerrilla warfare against the Japanese. The level of actual cooperation and coordination between the CCP and KMT during World War II was minimal. It also ended the Second United Front, formed earlier to fight the Japanese. In July 1944, the Chinese theater of the Second Sino-Japanese War was undergoing significant strain as Japanese forces launched Operation Ichi-Go, resulting in major territorial losses for the Nationalist government. During the same period, relations between the Nationalist government and the United States became increasingly strained over questions of military command and wartime coordination. The United States, which by then provided the majority of China's external military assistance, pressed for extensive reorganization of Chinese forces and sought greater operational authority through General Joseph Stilwell, the U.S. commander in the China-Burma-India Theater. These demands coincided with internal debates within the Nationalist government over sovereignty and control of military operations. At the same time, U.S. officials initiated exploratory contacts with the Chinese Communist Party through the Dixie Mission, reflecting a broader reassessment of American policy toward China. These developments unfolded alongside worsening battlefield conditions and mounting economic pressures within Nationalist-controlled areas.The course of the War of Resistance has now come under such pressure from the United States as I could never have imagined even in my worst expectations. That American imperialism should play such ruthless moves, to such an extreme degree, is something still more beyond all anticipation.—Chiang Kai-shek, 16 July 1944 In general, developments in the Second Sino-Japanese War were to the advantage of the CCP, as its guerrilla war tactics had won them popular support within the Japanese-occupied areas. In occupied areas, the Communists established military and political bases from which it carried out guerilla warfare. The Communists built popular support in these areas, returning land to poor peasants, reducing peasant's rent, and arming the people. The CCP also suffered fewer losses through its guerrilla tactics. == Immediate post-war clashes (1945–1946) ==
Immediate post-war clashes (1945–1946)
invaded Manchuria in August 1945. In the closing period of the war, both Communist radio broadcast from Yan'an and Nationalist radio broadcasts from Chongqing issued competing instructions for Japanese forces to surrender to them. A rush by the Communists and the Nationalists to secure control over the formerly Japanese-occupied areas of China resulted. In Manchuria, however, where the KMT had no forces, the Japanese surrendered to the Soviet Union. Chiang Kai-shek reminded Japanese troops to remain at their posts to receive the KMT, but Communist forces soon began taking surrenders from the Japanese and fighting those who resisted. The first post-war peace negotiation, attended by both Chiang Kai-shek and Mao Zedong, was in Chongqing from 28 August to 10 October 1945. Chiang entered the meeting at an advantage because he had recently signed a friendly treaty with the Soviet Union while the Communists were still forcing the Japanese to surrender in some places. Mao was accompanied by American ambassador Patrick J. Hurley, who was devoted to Chiang but also wanted to ensure Mao's safety in light of the past history between the two Chinese leaders. It concluded with the signing of the Double Tenth Agreement. Both sides stressed the importance of a peaceful reconstruction, but the conference did not produce any concrete results. This operation destroyed the Kwantung Army in just three weeks and left the USSR occupying all of Manchuria by the end of the war in a total power vacuum of local Chinese forces. Consequently, the 700,000 Japanese troops stationed in the region surrendered. Later in the year Chiang Kai-shek realized that he lacked the resources to prevent a CCP takeover of Manchuria following the scheduled Soviet departure. He therefore made a deal with the Soviets to delay their withdrawal until he had moved enough of his best-trained men and modern materiel into the region. However, the Soviets refused permission for the Nationalist troops to traverse its territory and spent the extra time systematically dismantling the extensive Manchurian industrial base (worth up to $2 billion) and shipping it back to their war-ravaged country. At the same time, however, the return of the KMT also brought widespread graft and corruption, with an OSS officer remarking that the only winners were the Communists. In the winter of 1945–1946, Joseph Stalin commanded Marshal Rodion Malinovsky to give Mao Zedong most of the Imperial Japanese Army weapons that were captured. Chiang Kai-shek's forces pushed as far as Jinzhou by 26 November 1945, meeting with little resistance. This was followed by a Communist offensive on the Shandong Peninsula that was largely successful, as all of the peninsula, except what was controlled by the US, fell to the Communists. File:Chinese Communist troops marched north(1945) 03.jpg|Chinese Communist soldiers march north to occupy rural Manchuria, 1945. File:Shangtang.jpg|Shangdang Campaign, September–October 1945 == Nationwide civil war (1946–1949) ==
Nationwide civil war (1946–1949)
Background and disposition of forces Having examined the actions of the Soviet Communist Party, the situation in Manchuria, and the broader international context, I have repeatedly reflected upon the matter and have found no viable path to a peaceful compromise. Should there be even the slightest chance of a turning point, I would not willingly hazard such grave dangers or subject the people once again to the suffering of war. Yet given the present condition of the domestic economy and the currency system, any renewed cycle of warfare would inevitably provoke social instability, which the Communist insurgents would then exploit to incite disorder.—Chiang Kai-shek, 9 November 1945 In March 1946, despite repeated requests from Chiang, the Soviet Red Army under the command of Marshal Rodion Malinovsky continued to delay pulling out of Manchuria, while Malinovsky secretly told the CCP forces to move in behind them, which led to full-scale war for the control of the Northeast. These favorable conditions also facilitated many changes inside the Communist leadership: the more radical hard-line faction who wanted a complete military take-over of China finally gained the upper hand and defeated the careful opportunists. Before giving control to Communist leaders, on 27 March, Soviet diplomats requested a joint venture of industrial development with the Nationalist Party in Manchuria. Although General Marshall stated that he knew of no evidence that the CCP was being supplied by the Soviet Union, the CCP was able to utilize a large number of weapons abandoned by the Japanese, including some tanks. When large numbers of well-trained KMT troops began to defect to the Communist forces, the CCP was finally able to achieve material superiority. The CCP's most effective political reform was its land reform policy. This drew the massive number of landless and starving peasants in the countryside into the Communist cause. This strategy enabled the CCP to access an extensive supply of manpower for both combat and logistical purposes; despite suffering heavy casualties throughout many of the war's campaigns, manpower continued to grow. For example, during the Huaihai Campaign alone the CCP was able to mobilize 5,430,000 peasants to fight against the KMT forces. After the war with the Japanese ended, Chiang Kai-shek quickly moved KMT troops to newly liberated areas to prevent Communist forces from receiving the Japanese surrender. Within less than two years after the Sino-Japanese War, the KMT had received $4.43 billion from the USmost of which was military aid. Outbreak of war File:Chaing Kai-shek's Strategy 1947.PNG|Situation in 1947 File:North China Areas of Politico-military Control, 15 August 1947 - DPLA - 1e624ff873a62c9c3c18bc0f50c38da0.jpg|North China areas of politico-military control in August 1947 File:Communist Offensives September through November 1948.PNG|Situation in the fall of 1948 File:Lost Horizon? (1948).jpg|Map of the Far East from the Time magazine showing the situation of the Chinese Civil War in late 1948 File:Communist Offensives November 1948 - January 1949.PNG|Situation in the winter of 1948 and 1949 File:Communist Offensives April - October 1949.PNG|Situation in April to October 1949 File:ROC_Retreat_to_Taiwan.svg|The Nationalists' retreat to Taipei: after the Nationalists lost Nanjing they next moved to Guangzhou, then to Chongqing, Chengdu and finally, Xichang before arriving Taipei in 1949. FT tanks As postwar negotiations between the Nationalist government and the CCP failed, the civil war between these two parties resumed. This stage of war is referred to in CCP historiography as the "War of Liberation" (). On 20 July 1946, Chiang Kai-shek launched a large-scale assault on Communist territory in North China with 113 brigades (a total of 1.6 million troops). The Communists counterattacked soon afterwards. With KMT efforts for an all-out offensive failing, the Nationalists changed strategy from broad assaults to concentrating on key targets, including Communist-controlled areas in Shandong and Shaanxi. At the same time, Communist forces also began to counterattack in Northeastern China, North China and East China. The capture of large KMT units provided the CCP with the tanks, heavy artillery and other combined-arms assets needed to execute offensive operations south of the Great Wall. By April 1948, the city of Luoyang fell, cutting the KMT army off from Xi'an. Following a fierce battle, the CCP captured Jinan and Shandong province on 24 September 1948. During this period, the Battle of Weixian took place, which was an important battle for the CCP to liberate Shandong. Through the Weixian Campaign, the CCP controlled the Jiaoji Railway and cut off the connection between Jinan and Qingdao. The Huaihai Campaign of late 1948 and early 1949 secured east-central China for the CCP. The PLA suffered heavy casualties while securing Zhangjiakou, Tianjin along with its port and garrison at Dagu and Beiping. In the final moments before the city completely fell, a group of senior Nationalist military and civilian officials carried out a mass suicide, including Liang Huazhi, the Acting Governor of Shanxi and Yan Huiqing, close cousin of the Premier Yan, who was regarded within the family as a younger sister, and the commander of Yan's Japanese troops, Imamura Hōsaku. Xu Duan, Director of the Statistics Bureau of the Shanxi Provincial Government and commander of the Special Gendarmerie, and Yin Zundang, Administrative Inspector of Shanxi's First District, led their subordinates in resistance and, after their positions were overrun, collectively took poison and burned the building, destroying their bodies. Shi Zecheng, Chief of the Taiyuan Municipal Police Bureau, fought with his forces before killing his wife and children and then taking his own life. Zhao Liankui, commander of the Special Service Battalion of the Taiyuan Pacification Headquarters, led a final defense; after exhausting all resistance, his unit destroyed its weapons and committed collective suicide with hand grenades. On the eve of Yan Huiqing's suicide by poisoning, she drafted the “Last Farewell Telegram.” After being refined by Wu Shaozhi, Secretary-General of the Shanxi Provincial Government, it was transmitted to Yan Xishan and KMT central government. The full text reads:For days the cannon fire has thundered like rolling storms, deafening to the ears; shells fly like rain, striking terror into the heart. Outside, smoke and flames spread everywhere, a vast sea of fire; inside, darkness and deathly stillness prevail, and all thoughts are extinguished. The overall situation is lost, and street fighting can no longer be sustained. Xu Duan has gone to his death; Dunhou has perished with the city. Soldiers and civilians without number bathe the streets in blood; five hundred colleagues achieve righteousness in the flames. Though I am but a woman, my resolve to die is already fixed. Having witnessed jade shatter, how could I dare remain whole like tile? Living, I have been unable to turn the nation’s disastrous course even by the slightest margin; in death, I shall obey instructions so that my remains will not fall into enemy hands. At this message’s end, words cannot fully express my feelings. This life is already finished; our parting is forever. If there is a next life, may reunion not be an empty illusion. At the moment I send this message, I am still among the living; by the time elder brother reads it, we shall already be separated by life and death. Flames rise before the buildings; collapse comes from the hills behind. Death presses upon my brow, yet my heart has turned calm. Alas—is this Heaven’s summons? Or is it the compassion of our ancestors? — Yan Huiqing, Director of the Shanxi Branch of the Wartime Child Care AssociationThe fall of Taiyuan effectively ended the last heavily fortified and fiercely defended Nationalist resistance and removed the last KMT-controlled urban center in North China. The mass suicide in Taiyuan Campaign later became known as the “Taiyuan Five Hundred Martyrs” (太原五百完人), a commemorative designation by the central government of Republic of China. 20th century mainland Chinese historiography identifies only about 46 government officials as suicides that can be substantiated by evidence, and treats higher figures, including the claim of “five hundred,” as Nationalist (KMT) propaganda fabrications rather than historical fact. Republic of China official records, however, including draft chronicle manuscripts from the Chiang Kai-shek Presidential Papers held at the Academia Historica, report contemporaneous estimates by Shanxi provincial officials of approximately 120–130 individuals. Separately, a portion of the remaining, unverified names may refer to pseudonymous Japanese soldiers who also committed suicide. Overall, Disputes over the actual number have also been widely debated in official narratives, public discourse, and popular memory. — Mao Zedong, "Order to the Army for the Country-Wide Advance", 21 April 1949 Following with the complete military collapse of the KMT position in northern China, Stalin initially favored a coalition government in postwar China, and tried to persuade Mao to stop the CCP from crossing the Yangtze and attacking the KMT positions south of the river. Mao rejected Stalin's position and on 21 April, began the Yangtze River Crossing Campaign. On 23 April, they captured the KMT's capital, Nanjing. The Kuomintang made several last-ditch attempts to use Khampa troops against the Communists in southwest China. The Kuomintang formulated a plan in which three Khampa divisions would be assisted by the Panchen Lama to oppose the Communists. Kuomintang intelligence reported that some Tibetan tusi chiefs and the Khampa Su Yonghe controlled 80,000 troops in Sichuan, Qinghai and Tibet. They hoped to use them against the Communist army. Pushing south in mid 1950 On 1 October 1949, Mao Zedong officially proclaimed the People's Republic of China with its capital at Beiping, which was returned to the former name Beijing. Chiang Kai-shek and approximately two million Nationalist soldiers retreated from mainland China to the island of Taiwan in December after the PLA advanced into Sichuan province. Isolated Nationalist pockets of resistance remained in the area, but the majority of the resistance collapsed after the fall of Chengdu on 10 December 1949, with some resistance continuing in the far south. A PRC attempt to take the ROC-controlled island of Quemoy was thwarted in the Battle of Kuningtou, halting the PLA advance towards Taiwan. In December 1949, Chiang proclaimed Taipei the temporary capital of the Republic of China and continued to assert his government as the sole legitimate authority in China. The Communists' other amphibious operations of 1950 were more successful: they led to the Communist conquest of Hainan Island in April 1950, the Wanshan Islands off the Guangdong coast (May–August 1950), and Zhoushan Island off Zhejiang (May 1950). == Nationalist reorganization and continued resistance (1949–1965) ==
Nationalist reorganization and continued resistance (1949–1965)
The retreat to Taiwan did not mark the end of Nationalist military activity. Following the fall of Chengdu on 10 December 1949, the ROC government under Chiang undertook a systematic reconstruction of its military and political apparatus. Prior to the arrival of the official U.S. Military Assistance Advisory Group (MAAG) in May 1951, Chiang enlisted a secret Japanese military advisory group known as the White Group (白團), composed of former Imperial Japanese Army officers including General Yasuji Okamura, to help restructure ROC training and mobilization systems. The Kuomintang Reconstruction of 1950–1952 purged underperforming commanders and reorganized the party structure. A comprehensive land reform program redistributed land to tenant farmers between 1949 and 1953, addressing a structural failure widely attributed to the loss of the mainland. By the late 1950s, with extensive US military aid formalized through the Sino-American Mutual Defense Treaty (1954), the ROC Armed Forces had grown to approximately 600,000 troops, described by U.S. Ambassador Karl Rankin in 1957 as the second-largest Asian military allied to the United States. For the approximately two million mainlanders who retreated to Taiwan with the ROC government—among them soldiers, civil servants, teachers, students, and civilians—the aspiration to return to their home provinces and reunite with families left behind on the mainland remained a powerful motivating force for decades. Many had left home without warning, not knowing that departure would mean permanent separation; some were sent away by parents who hoped that following the Nationalist forces would give their children a chance to survive. Letters could not be sent, and news could not reach across the strait. Many genuinely believed in the mission of liberating the mainland from Communist rule, a sentiment that sustained popular support for Chiang's stated objective of retaking China. From 1951 to 1954, ROC irregular forces trained by the CIA conducted coastal raids on PRC territory from ROC-controlled offshore islands. On 1 April 1961, Chiang formally established Project National Glory, a classified multi-phase invasion plan centred on an amphibious assault on Xiamen, with subsidiary operations including special forces infiltration and air campaigns targeting Fujian and Guangdong. The Cultural Revolution beginning in 1966 prompted renewed ROC assessments of mainland vulnerability, and Chiang again sought U.S. support for offensive operations; the request was declined. The Guoguang Operation Office was abolished on 20 July 1972, effectively ending formal planning for a mainland counteroffensive, coinciding with Chiang's gradual withdrawal from active governance due to declining health. Nationalist resistance also persisted along China's southwestern periphery. Approximately 3,000 KMT soldiers under General Li Mi retreated into Burma rather than surrender, conducting guerrilla operations into Yunnan province through the early 1950s with covert CIA support. Following Burmese government appeals to the United Nations in 1953, the United States pressured the ROC to withdraw; approximately 6,000 soldiers were evacuated to Taiwan by end of 1954. Thousands remained, however, and the ROC continued covert resupply operations for decades, maintaining a forward military presence along the Chinese periphery until the remnants were finally airlifted to Taiwan in the 1980s. == Aftermath ==
Aftermath
Most observers expected Chiang's government to eventually fall to the imminent invasion of Taiwan by the People's Liberation Army, and the US was initially reluctant in offering full support for Chiang in their final stand. US President Harry S. Truman announced on 5 January 1950 that the United States would not engage in any dispute involving the Taiwan Strait, and that he would not intervene in the event of an attack by the PRC. Truman, seeking to exploit the possibility of a Titoist-style Sino-Soviet split, announced in his United States Policy toward Formosa that the US would obey the Cairo Declaration's designation of Taiwan as Chinese territory and would not assist the Nationalists. However, the Communist leadership was not aware of this change of policy, instead becoming increasingly hostile to the US. The situation quickly changed after the sudden onset of the Korean War in June 1950. This led to changing political climate in the US, and President Truman ordered the United States Seventh Fleet to sail to the Taiwan Strait as part of the containment policy against potential Communist advance. " – a rock in Jinhu, Kinmen with Chiang Kai-shek's calligraphy signifying the retaking of one's homeland In June 1949, the ROC declared a "closure" of all mainland China ports and its navy attempted to intercept all foreign ships. The closure was from a point north of the mouth of Min River in Fujian to the mouth of the Liao River in Liaoning. Since mainland China's railroad network was underdeveloped, north–south trade depended heavily on sea lanes. ROC naval activity also caused severe hardship for mainland China fishermen. During the retreat of the Republic of China to Taiwan, KMT troops, who could not retreat to Taiwan, were left behind to fight a guerrilla war against the Communists. These KMT remnants were eliminated in what the PRC called the Campaign to Suppress Counterrevolutionaries and the Campaigns to Suppress Bandits. According to official statistics from the CCP in 1954, during the Campaign to Suppress Counterrevolutionaries, at least 2.6 million people were arrested, some 1.29 million people were imprisoned, and 712,000 people were executed. Most of those killed were former Kuomintang officials, businessmen, former employees of Western companies and intellectuals whose loyalty was suspect. Winning China proper in 1950, also after annexation of Tibet, the CCP controlled the entire mainland in late 1951 (excluding Kinmen and Matsu Islands). But a group of approximately 3,000 KMT Central soldiers retreated to Burma and continued launching guerrilla attacks into south China during the Kuomintang Islamic Insurgency in China (1950–1958) and Campaign at the China–Burma Border. Their leader, Li Mi, was paid a salary by the ROC government and given the nominal title of Governor of Yunnan. Initially, the US-supported these remnants and the Central Intelligence Agency provided them with military aid. After the Burmese government appealed to the United Nations in 1953, the US began pressuring the ROC to withdraw its loyalists. By the end of 1954 nearly 6,000 soldiers had left Burma and Li declared his army disbanded. However, thousands remained, and the ROC continued to supply and command them, even secretly supplying reinforcements at times to maintain a base close to China. Following World War II, civil conflicts erupted in Vietnam. With victory in the civil war and the establishment of the People's Republic of China in 1949, the Chinese communists supported the communist Viet Minh guerrillas against France. The PRC recognized the Democratic Republic of Vietnam (DRV) in January 1950 and began supplying military equipment in accordance with the agreement of April 1, 1950. By the end of that year, the Viet Minh had secured control over remote regions in northern Vietnam and along the Sino-Vietnamese border. This territorial control enabled the flow of supplies and weapons into Vietnam and facilitated the establishment of training camps and base areas. Chinese military aid played a key role in the Viet Minh's victory at the Battle of Dien Bien Phu in 1954. The recognition of the DRV by the PRC and other Eastern Bloc countries also prompted the United States and the Western Bloc to recognize the State of Vietnam as a counterweight to the communists. As Chinese communist troops neared complete victory in December 1949, Vietnamese nationalist revolutionary Vũ Hồng Khanh moved from China to lead a force of Vietnamese, upland minorities, and Kuomintang soldiers toward Lạng Sơn to attack the Viet Minh and the French. Defeated by both, he crossed over to the State of Vietnam. Several thousand Kuomintang soldiers were sent to Phú Quốc for temporary internment and repatriation, but by the late 1950s, a number of them were still farming pepper while directing the island militias. After the ROC complained to the United Nations against the Soviet Union for violating the Sino-Soviet Treaty of Friendship and Alliance to support the CCP, the UN General Assembly Resolution 505 was adopted on 1 February 1952, condemning the Soviet Union. In the end, the Communist military forces suffered 1.3 million combat casualties in the 1945–1949 phase of the war: 260,000 killed, 190,000 missing, and 850,000 wounded, discounting irregulars. Nationalist casualties in the same phase were recorded after the war by the PRC: 5,452,700 regulars and 2,258,800 irregulars. Basing this judgment on multiple factors, including the idea of a Chinese century of humiliation at the hands of Western powers beginning in the mid-19th century, U.S. support for the Nationalists during the Chinese Civil War, and the ideological struggles between revolutionaries and reactionaries, the PRC leadership believed that China would become a critical battleground in the U.S.'s crusade against Communism. As a countermeasure and to elevate China's standing among the worldwide Communist movements, the PRC leadership adopted a foreign policy that actively promoted Communist revolutions throughout territories on China's periphery. European communism will collapse by around 1990; the Chinese Communist regime, however, will follow somewhat later.—Chiang Kai-shek, in a conversation with former South Korean prime minister Chung Il-kwon, Taipei, 1972. On 24 January 1955, the United States Congress passed the Formosa Resolution authorizing the President to defend the ROC's offshore islands. The First Taiwan Straits crisis ended in March 1955 when the PLA ceased its bombardment. The crisis ended during the Bandung conference. The fourth crisis began in 2022. US Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi's visit to Taiwan in August 2022 triggered PRC military exercises across the Taiwan Strait. She originally intended to travel to Taiwan in April 2022, but was delayed due to the COVID-19 pandemic. She rescheduled the trip to August as part of a wider Asian trip. The White House was reported to have been initially divided over the appropriateness of the trip, but later affirmed Pelosi's right to visit Taiwan. As a result, the PLA announced four days of unprecedented military live-fire drills, which was later extended to seven days, in six zones that encircled the island on the busiest international waterways and aviation routes. In response to the announcement, ROC officials complained that the PRC's live-fire drills were an invasion of Taiwan's territorial space, and a direct challenge to free air and sea navigation. This was only the first of several large-scale military drills that China would conduct around Taiwan in subsequent years. Political fallout wreckage (pilot Chang Liyi) on display at the Museum in Beijing On 25 October 1971, the United Nations General Assembly admitted the PRC and expelled the ROC, which had been a founding member of the United Nations and was one of the five permanent members of the Security Council. Representatives of Chiang Kai-shek refused to recognise their accreditations as representatives of China and left the assembly. Recognition for the People's Republic of China soon followed from most other member nations, including the United States. By 1984, PRC and ROC began to de-escalate their hostilities through diplomatic relations with each other, and cross-straits trade and investment has been growing ever since. The state of war was officially declared over by the ROC in 1991. Despite the end of the hostilities, the two sides have never signed any agreement or treaty to officially end the war. According to Mao Zedong, there were three ways of "staving off imperialist intervention in the short term" during the continuation of the Chinese Communist Revolution. The first was through a rapid completion of the military takeover of the country, and through showing determination and strength against "foreign attempts at challenging the new regime along its borders". The second was by "formalising a comprehensive military alliance with the Soviet Union", which would dedicate Soviet power to directly defending China against its enemies; this aspect became extensively significant given the backdrop of the start of the Cold War. And finally, the regime had to "root out its domestic opponents: the heads of secret societies, religious sects, independent unions, or tribal and ethnic organisations". By destroying the basis of domestic reaction, Mao believed a safer world for the Chinese Communist Revolution to spread in would come into existence. In 1987, the ROC government ended its prohibition on veterans traveling to the mainland to visit relatives, allowing the first cross-strait family reunions since 1949. For many of the mainlanders who had retreated with the ROC government, the reunion came too late; significant numbers had died waiting. Under the new ROC president Lee Teng-hui, the Temporary Provisions Effective During the Period of Communist Rebellion was renounced in May 1991, thus ending the chances of the Kuomintang's quest to retake the mainland. In July 1999, Lee announced a "special diplomatic relationship". China was furious again, but the military drills were stopped by the 921 earthquakes. It was the last tense moment of this civil war. With the election in 2000 of Democratic Progressive Party candidate Chen Shui-bian, a party other than the KMT gained the presidency for the first time in Taiwan. The new president did not share the Chinese nationalist ideology of the KMT and CCP. This led to tension between the two sides, although trade and other ties such as the 2005 Pan-Blue visit continued to increase. With the election of pro-mainland President Ma Ying-jeou (KMT) in 2008, significant warming of relations resumed between Taipei and Beijing, with high-level exchanges between the semi-official diplomatic organizations of both states such as the Chen-Chiang summit series. Although the Taiwan Strait remains a potential flash point, regular direct air links were established in 2009. == Analysis ==
Analysis
The Communist victory over the Nationalists is regarded as one of the most impressive twentieth century insurgent victories. Historians and political scientists cite a number of factors, including the CCP's success at mobilizing mass support and the shortcomings of the Nationalist government. In his diary entry of January 1949, following his resignation from the presidency, he recorded that "after twenty years in power, we have done nothing for social reform or the welfare of the people" and that "we never established a new, solid organization." In his memoir Soviet Russia in China (1957), however, Chiang attributed primary causal responsibility to Soviet duplicity. He documented the Yalta agreements of February 1945, which granted the USSR Manchurian concessions without consulting the Chinese government; the systematic Soviet dismantling of Manchurian industrial infrastructure following Japan's defeat, estimated by U.S. Ambassador Edwin Pauley at approximately two billion U.S. dollars in value; and the covert transfer of captured Japanese weaponry to the CCP in violation of the 1945 Sino-Soviet Treaty, by which Stalin had formally pledged exclusive recognition of the Nationalist government. Scholars including Eastman and Parks M. Coble have assessed this account as accurate in identifying Soviet interference but self-serving in deflecting attention from Chiang's own leadership failures, particularly his personal disengagement from economic management, his tolerance of corruption among close associates including H.H. Kung and T.V. Soong, and his strategic errors in Manchuria. Andrew J. Nathan observed that Chiang's diaries follow the Neo-Confucian tradition of moral self-cultivation logbooks, in which the author functions simultaneously as penitent and merciless judge, making his self-criticism more self-delusional than hypocritical. The Nationalist military and the government's civilian employees were most impacted by hyperinflation which in turn prompted widespread corruption and pilfering. Chiang wrote in his diary in June 1948: "After the fall of Kaifeng our conditions worsened and became more serious. I now realized that the main reason our nation has collapsed, time after time throughout our history, was not because of superior power used by our external enemies, but because of disintegration and rot from within." Historian Odd Arne Westad says the Communists won the Civil War because they made fewer military mistakes than Chiang Kai-shek and also because in his search for a powerful centralized government, Chiang antagonized too many interest groups in China. Furthermore, his party was weakened in the war against the Japanese. Meanwhile, the Communists targeted different groups, such as peasants, and brought them to their side. After 1945, the economy in the ROC areas collapsed because of hyperinflation and the failure of price controls by the ROC government and financial reforms; the Gold Yuan depreciated sharply in late 1948 and resulted in the ROC government losing the support of the cities' middle classes. United States Secretary of State Dean Acheson described the Nationalists as "corrupt, reactionary, and inefficient". He believed that the Nationalists had displayed both political inadequacy as well as "the grossest incompetence ever experienced by any military command," and that the Communists "did not create this condition", but skillfully exploited the opportunity it provided. Mass mobilization and cohesion of the Communists The Communists developed their support and ability to mobilize villagers through their socioeconomic reforms.'''''' The Communists continued their land reform programs, winning the support of the population in the countryside. This was a decisive factor in the Communists' success. Millions of peasants who obtained land through the movement joined the People's Liberation Army or assisted in its logistical networks. Ultimately, the Communists obtained the greatest popular support of any insurgency in modern history. Intelligence penetration and mass defections A significant factor in the Nationalist military collapse was the systematic penetration of KMT operational planning by Communist intelligence agents at the highest levels of the command structure. Guo Rugui (郭汝瑰), who served as chief of the Operations Department of the Nationalist Ministry of National Defense, transmitted virtually all major battle plans to the CCP throughout the critical campaigns of 1947–1949, including operational details for the Huaihai Campaign and the Yangtze River defense line. Beyond passive intelligence transmission, Guo drafted combat orders designed to disadvantage Nationalist forces and issued misleading reports concealing CCP troop movements. During the Huaihai Campaign, Nationalist field commanders Du Yuming and Qiu Qingquan reportedly identified the malicious intent of Guo's operational deployments but were unable to prevent their adoption through official channels. Xiong Xianghui, recruited in 1937 at the age of seventeen by Zhou Enlai, served for over a decade as the confidential aide-de-camp to General Hu Zongnan, one of Chiang's most trusted commanders, while secretly reporting to the CCP. His most consequential contribution came in March 1947, when he forewarned the CCP leadership two weeks before Hu Zongnan's 200,000-strong offensive against Yan'an, allowing Mao Zedong, Zhou Enlai, and the party leadership to evacuate safely. Mao Zedong later assessed Xiong's contribution as equivalent to that of several army divisions. The three decisive campaigns of 1948–1949, Liaoshen, Huaihai, and Pingjin, were further characterized by mass defections reflecting the comprehensive collapse of Nationalist military morale. Across the three campaigns, Nationalist forces suffered losses totaling approximately 1.54 million troops through capture, surrender, or defection. Historian Diana Lary has argued that by late 1948 morale in much of the Nationalist military had effectively collapsed, with individual soldiers calculating the rational costs of continued resistance against forces that had achieved overwhelming operational momentum. The Manchurian campaigns as the decisive theater Historians have increasingly identified Manchuria, China's most industrialized region, transformed by Japanese colonial investment, as the theater where the outcome of the civil war was strategically determined. Harold Tanner's Where Chiang Kai-shek Lost China: The Liao-Shen Campaign, 1948 (2015) provides the most detailed reconstruction of the decisive campaign, documenting how an unresolved command conflict between Chiang Kai-shek and his field commander Wei Lihuang paralyzed the Nationalist defense. Chiang sought to withdraw forces along the Jinzhou–Huludao corridor to preserve a strategic retreat route; Wei insisted on defending Shenyang. This deadlock allowed Lin Biao to complete the transformation of the People's Liberation Army's Northeast Field Army from a guerrilla force into a conventional combined-arms formation capable of capturing fortified cities through coordinated infantry, artillery, and armored operations. The campaign resulted in over 470,000 Nationalist casualties against approximately 69,000 PLA losses, and for the first time in the war gave the PLA numerical superiority across all theaters. The Soviet role in establishing conditions for this outcome was multifaceted. Following Japan's defeat, Soviet occupation forces systematically dismantled Manchurian industrial infrastructure, U.S. Ambassador Edwin Pauley estimated the total value of removed equipment at approximately two billion dollars, while simultaneously transferring captured Japanese weaponry to CCP forces and delaying their withdrawal to allow the CCP to establish rural base areas before Nationalist forces could occupy the region. Odd Arne Westad's multi-archival research demonstrates that Stalin's China policy involved consistent material support for the CCP despite formal diplomatic recognition of the Nationalist government, reflecting Soviet geopolitical calculations about buffer states in Northeast Asia. Westad simultaneously challenges deterministic interpretations of the war's outcome: drawing on Russian, Nationalist, Communist, and American primary sources, he argues that the KMT held real military and political advantages in 1945 that were squandered through specific leadership decisions, and that the outcome remained genuinely uncertain until the Huaihai Campaign of late 1948. American policy and the withdrawal of support After the Second Sino-Japanese War ended, the United States government provided economic and military support exclusively to the Nationalists. (such as the notorious Yangtze Development Corporation controlled by H. H. Kung and T. V. Soong's family) and KMT's military setback in Northeast China. Historians such as Jay Taylor, Robert Cowley, and Anne W. Carroll argue that the Nationalists' failure was largely caused by external reasons outside of the KMT's control, most notably the refusal of the Truman administration to support Chiang with the withdrawal of aid, the US armed embargo, the failed pursuit of a détente between the Nationalists and the communists, and the USSR's consistent support of the CCP in the Chinese Civil War. The better-trained Communist army's support from the USSR helped counter the American aid that the Nationalists received. == Atrocities ==
Atrocities
During the war, both the Nationalists and Communists carried out mass atrocities, with millions of non-combatants deliberately killed by both sides. Nationalist atrocities Over several years after the 1927 Shanghai massacre, the Kuomintang killed between 300,000 and one million people, primarily peasants, in anti-communist campaigns as part of the White Terror. During the White Terror, the Nationalists specifically targeted women with short hair who had not been subjected to foot binding, on the presumption that such "non-traditional" women were radicals. Communist atrocities During the December 1930 Futian incident, the communists executed 2,000 to 3,000 members of the Futian battalion after its leaders had mutinied against Mao Zedong. Between 1931 and 1934 in the Jiangxi–Fujian Soviet, the communist authorities engaged in a widespread campaign of violence against civilians to ensure compliance with its policies and to stop defection to the advancing KMT, including mass executions, land confiscation and forced labor. According to Li Weihan, a high-ranking communist in Jiangxi at the time, in response to mass flight of civilians to KMT held areas, the local authorities would "usually to send armed squads after those attempting to flee and kill them on the spot, producing numerous mass graves throughout the CSR [Chinese Soviet Republic in Jiangxi] that would later be uncovered by the KMT and its allies." Zhang Wentian, another high-ranking communist, reported that "the policy of annihilating landlords as an exploiting class had degenerated into a massacre". During the Siege of Changchun, the People's Liberation Army implemented a military blockade on the KMT-held city of Changchun and prevented civilians from leaving the city during the blockade; to 150 thousand civilians. The PLA continued to use siege tactics throughout Northeast China. At the outbreak of the Chinese Civil War in 1946, Mao Zedong began to push for a return to radical policies to mobilize China against the landlord class, but protected the rights of middle peasants and specified that rich peasants were not landlords. The 7 July Directive of 1946 set off eighteen months of fierce conflict in which all rich peasant and landlord property of all types was to be confiscated and redistributed to poor peasants. CCP work teams went quickly from village to village and divided the population into landlords, rich, middle, poor, and landless peasants. Because the work teams did not involve villagers in the process, however, rich and middle peasants quickly returned to power. The Outline Land Law of October 1947 increased the pressure. Those condemned as landlords were buried alive, dismembered, strangled and shot. In response to the aforementioned land reform campaign, the Kuomintang helped establish the "Huanxiang Tuan" (), or Homecoming Legion, which was composed of landlords who sought the return of their redistributed land and property from peasants and CCP guerrillas, as well as forcibly conscripted peasants and communist POWs. The Homecoming legion conducted its guerrilla warfare campaign against CCP forces and purported collaborators up until the end of the civil war in 1949. == See also ==
tickerdossier.comtickerdossier.substack.com