Capitol released "She's a Woman" in the US as the
B-side to "I Feel Fine" on 23 November 1964. EMI's
Parlophone label released the same single in the UK four days later. Journalist
Neil Spencer suggests that the song would have been an album track on
Beatles for Sale were it not for the dearth of new
Lennon–McCartney compositions. In the US – where Capitol reconfigured the Beatles' albums, reducing the number of songs and using single A- and B-sides to create further LP releases – the song appeared on the North American album ''
Beatles '65, released on 15 December 1964. It has since appeared on the 1978 British compilation album Rarities, while the first true stereo mix of the song to be released in the US appeared on the 1988 compilation Past Masters, Volume One. The mono mix was subsequently included on the 2009 Mono Masters'' compilation. Among contemporaneous reviews, Derek Johnson in the
NME described "She's a Woman" as "arresting and ear-catching", and highlighted the track's "pounding beat" and blues-inflected vocal.
Billboard predicted an immediate chart hit for both sides of the single and recognised the record as a "gift to Capitol on the group's first anniversary with the label". The UK single release sold 800,000 units within five days and over a million by 9 December. In the US, where five albums and sixteen singles had been released in the first seven months of 1964, the ensuing lull of new Beatles material led to fans highly anticipating the next single's release. The US release sold more than a million copies in its first week. "She's a Woman" became a hit in its own right, mostly on the strength of
point of sale requests, peaking at number four on the
Billboard Hot 100 and remaining on the chart for nine weeks. In a retrospective review for
AllMusic,
Stephen Thomas Erlewine says the song demonstrates the Beatles' ability to "rock really, really hard". MacDonald describes the track as "the most extreme sound the Beatles had manufactured to date". Writing that it is the first Beatles song to feature a high profile bass line, he opines that it foreshadows McCartney's later "striving to get his instrument 'up' in volume, tone, and octave". He further characterises the recording as outré, and groups it with "
What You're Doing" and "
Eight Days a Week" as one of McCartney's late-1964 recording experiments. Everett writes that his piano playing on the song "[took] his keyboard work to a new level", while describing Harrison's guitar solo as
rockabilly in style, heavily influenced by guitarist
Carl Perkins.
Rolling Stone critic
Rob Sheffield opines that the song's "
power-chord thud" anticipates the sound of the
heavy metal band
Black Sabbath. Spencer calls the song McCartney's "stoned out-take on his
Little Richard legacy", and musicologist
Alan W. Pollack describes the song as McCartney's "most outrageous vocal performance" since "
Long Tall Sally", anticipating that of the 1969 songs "
Get Back" and "
Oh! Darling". He further writes that as the song progresses, the vocal gets "steadily freer, louder, and more extroverted". Calling the song a "throaty McCartney rocker", Hertsgaard describes the line, "My love don't give me presents / I know that she's no peasant" as "one of the most awkward rhymes in the Beatles' catalogue". MacDonald also dismisses the lyrics, calling them "[k]nowingly functional" and only notable for the marijuana reference. Riley writes that, were it not for Starr's cymbal smashing in the four-bar break, the song would be "almost too tightly strung". == Other versions ==