MarketShort Stirling
Company Profile

Short Stirling

The Short Stirling was a British four-engined heavy bomber of the Second World War. It has the distinction of being the first four-engined bomber to be introduced into service with the Royal Air Force (RAF) during the war.

Development
Origins In the 1930s, the Royal Air Force (RAF) was interested primarily in twin-engined bombers. The aircraft should also be able to be used as a troop transport for 24 soldiers and be able to use catapult assistance for takeoff when heavily laden. Since it could be operating from limited "back country" airfields, it needed to lift off from a runway and be able to clear trees at the end, a specification with which most small aircraft would have a problem today. Aviation author Geoffrey Norris observed that the stringent requirements given in the specification for the prospective aircraft to be able to make use of existing infrastructure, specifically the specified maximum wingspan of 100 feet, adversely affected the Stirling's performance, such as its relatively low ceiling and its inability to carry anything larger than 500 lb bombs. In mid-1936, Specification B.12/36 was sent out to Supermarine, Boulton Paul, Handley Page, and Armstrong Whitworth. In August, the specification was issued to the rest of British industry. Shorts accepted this large amount of redesign work. The project had added importance due to the death of Supermarine's designer, Reginald Mitchell, which had generated doubt within the Air Ministry about the ability of Supermarine to deliver. Two prototypes were ordered from Shorts. The S.29 used the Sunderland's wing and it had to be reduced to less than In June 1937, the S.29 was accepted as the second string for the Supermarine Type 317 and formally ordered in October; Shorts and Supermarine were issued with instructions to proceed. On 19 September 1938, the S.31 conducted its maiden flight, piloted by Shorts' Chief Test Pilot J. Lankester Parker. Impressed with its performance, on 21 October 1938, Parker flew the S.31 to RAF Martlesham Heath, Suffolk, where it was evaluated by the Aeroplane and Armament Experimental Establishment and received mostly favourable reviews. There was one notable criticism amongst the feedback from pilots, being that the length of the takeoff run was considered to be excessive and that improvements would be desirable. Fixing this required that the angle of the wing to be increased for takeoff; however, if the wing itself were modified, the aircraft would fly with a nose-down attitude while cruising (as in the Armstrong Whitworth Whitley); making this change was also complicated by the fact that work on the production line had already reached an advanced stage. Thus, Shorts lengthened the undercarriage struts to tilt the nose up on take-off, leading to its spindly gear, which, in turn, contributed to many takeoff and landing accidents. The S.31 also received the lengthened undercarriage to test this; subsequent trials found no need for further modification in this respect. A resulting redesign of the undercarriage led to substantially stronger and heavier struts being installed upon the second prototype. On 3 December 1939, the second prototype made its maiden flight. In August 1940, series production of the Stirling commenced at the Rochester factory. Production of the Stirling was delayed by the ongoing bombing campaign of the Luftwaffe. The area, which included a number of major aviation firms, was heavily bombed in the opening days of the Battle of Britain, including one famous low-level raid by a group of Dornier Do 17s. A number of completed Stirlings were destroyed on the ground and the factories were heavily damaged, setting back production by almost a year. Some production was moved to Austin's Longbridge factory at Cofton Hackett just south of Birmingham, the Longbridge production line eventually produced nearly 150 Stirlings. From this point on, the Belfast factory became increasingly important, as it was thought to be well beyond the range of German bombers. However, Belfast and the aircraft factory were subjected to bombing by German aircraft during the Easter week of 1941. To meet the increased requirement for its aircraft during the war, satellite factories near Belfast were operated at Aldergrove and Maghaberry, producing 232 Stirlings between them. In 1940, bombing damaged Supermarine's factory at Woolston and the incomplete Type 316 prototypes. In November 1940, development of the 316 was formally cancelled, leaving the Stirling as the only B.12/36 design. The first few Stirling Mk.Is were furnished with Bristol Hercules II engines, but most were built with more powerful Hercules XI engines, instead. Total production of the bomber variants was 1759 aircraft, divided among four locations, as follows: • Short Brothers plant, Belfast: 261 Mk.I and 342 Mk.III • Short Brothers plant, Rochester, later relocated to the shadow factory of South Marston: 260 Mk.I and 276 Mk.III • Austin Motors plant, Longbridge: 181 Mk.I and 429 Mk.III Another 610 aircraft were built directly as Mk.IV and Mk.V transports/glider tugs. Proposed developments Even before the Stirling went into production, Short had improved on the initial design with the S.34 in an effort to meet specification B.1/39. It would have been powered by four Bristol Hercules 17 SM engines, optimised for high-altitude flight. The new design featured longer-span wings and a revised fuselage able to carry dorsal and ventral power-operated turrets each fitted with four 20 mm Hispano cannons; despite the obvious gains in performance and capability, the Air Ministry was not interested. In 1941, it was decided that the Stirling would be manufactured in Canada and an initial contract for 140 aircraft was placed. The S.37 was a fully-furnished transport aircraft that was capable of seating 30 passengers and was constructed to conform with civilian standards. A prototype, known as the Silver Stirling, was converted from a Mk.V aircraft; partly due to greater levels of interest being expressed for a more promising civilian version of the Handley-Page Halifax, the proposal met with little official interest. In 1941, Short proposed the development of a new variant of the Stirling, the S.36, which was nicknamed the "Super Stirling" in a company publication. ==Design==
Design
Overview The Short Stirling was a four-engined monoplane heavy bomber designed to provide a previously unmatched level of strategic bombing capability to the Royal Air Force (RAF). It was powered by four Bristol Hercules radial engines which were spaced across its mid-mounted wing. The Stirling has the distinction of being the only British bomber of the period to see service that had been designed from the start with four engines - the Avro Lancaster was a re-engined, stretched-wingspan Avro Manchester while the Halifax was planned to be powered by twin Rolls-Royce Vulture engines but was similarly re-designed to use an arrangement of four Merlin engines in 1937. The flight engineer and wireless operator were housed in a cabin just forward of the leading edge of the wing, and directly forward of them was the navigator's station. The two pilots were contained within a fully glazed flight deck positioned level with the forward end of the bomb cells; the provision of a separate flight engineer's station led to the cockpit having a relatively simple appearance in comparison with the majority of the RAF's bombers. The Stirling was armed with a two-guns FN.5 nose turret and a four-guns FN.20A tail turret (the latter was notable for the wide angles of fire) along with a single retractable two-guns FN.25 ventral ("dustbin") turret located just behind the bomb-bay. This proved almost useless due to cramped conditions, with the added distraction that the turret tended to drop and hit the ground when taxiing over bumps. This turret designated the FN.7A also had problems; it had a metal back fitted with an escape hatch which turned out to be almost impossible to use. The Stirling Mk.III, introduced in 1943, was similar to the Mk.I with the exception of the improved Hercules VI or XVI engines, which improved maximum speed from . The Mk.III used a fully glazed dorsal turret (the same FN.50 as in Lancaster) that had more room and an improved view. Early Mk.III Stirlings were fitted with a 12.7 mm Browning machine gun in the rear escape hatch (behind a perspex shield) to ward off German night fighters using the Schräge Musik system. Later Stirlings were fitted with an improved, low-drag remotely-controlled FN.64 ventral turret or a H2S radar. Mk.III Stirlings also were fitted with electronic countermeasure systems such as ventral antennas for the Mandrel jamming system as well as a ventral "window" chaff chute to jam Freya and Würzburg radars. Mk.III Stirlings were also fitted with a ventral antenna for the Blind Approach Beacon System which was a blind-landing aid and a Monica rear warning radar in the tail turret. Structure Short Stirling aircraft The construction of the Stirling shares considerable similarity to the earlier Short Empire flying boats. The wing housed three large self-sealing fuel tanks within the spar truss, along with a fourth non-self-sealing fuel tank within the leading edge of the wing root, which provided for a combined tankage of 2,254 gallons. Up to six ferry tanks could also be installed within the wing bomb cells to add another 220 gallons. The four sections were joined using tension bolts through the webs of the end frames. The lower sides of the centre-section spar booms aligned with the main deck of the aircraft, which was supported upon the three longitudinal girders which formed the three parallel bomb cells. Flying characteristics Pilot accounts generally report that, once airborne, the Short Stirling was a delight to fly, surprisingly manoeuvrable for such a large aircraft and without any vices. According to Norris, the Stirling was "more manoeuvreable and responsive than any other aircraft in its class". The Stirling did, however, exhibit some vicious flying characteristics during takeoff and landings. As a class, the large and heavy four-engined tail-wheeled bombers such as the Stirling, Handley Page Halifax, Avro Lancaster and Boeing B-17 Flying Fortress could be a handful on takeoff and landing, more so for relatively young and inexperienced new pilots who formed the vast majority of the expanding Commonwealth and American air forces. Later heavy bomber designs such as the Consolidated B-24 Liberator and Boeing B-29 Superfortress used a nose-wheel (tricycle) configuration as did most successful four engined commercial aircraft in the post-war years. Tricycle geared aircraft are typically easier to control on takeoff, landing and during taxiing, and also make for easier cargo loading and servicing as the cabin, engines and other systems are closer to the ground. The long undercarriage of the Stirling was a result of a request by the RAF who sought to increase the wing incidence. On flare-out for landing, the Short Stirling exhibited a tendency to suddenly stall and "drop like a stone" to the runway. With such a heavy aircraft, a "dropped" landing could cause serious structural damage. During its service life, it was not unknown for "dropped" landings to render Stirlings or other large four-engined bombers write-offs and suitable only for parts. ==Operational history==
Operational history
In July 1940, the first production Stirling departed Rochester; in August 1940, it was delivered to No. 7 Squadron at RAF Leeming, North Yorkshire. From May 1943, raids on Germany were often conducted using over a hundred Stirling bombers at a time. Stirlings were amongst the RAF bombers used during the first 1,000 bomber raid against Cologne. Norris observed that, by 1942, the type had "given plenty of punishment to the Germans and was also proving that it could itself take punishment to an incredible extent". There were several incidents in which damaged aircraft, such as one Stirling which suffered a head-on collision with a Messerschmitt Bf 109 fighter over Hamburg, were able to return to base. Its handling was much better than that of the Halifax and some preferred it to the Lancaster. Based on its flight characteristics, Flt Lt Murray Peden (RCAF) of No. 214 Squadron RAF described the Stirling as "one of the finest aircraft ever built". A consequence of the thick wing was a low ceiling; many missions were flown as low as . This was a disadvantage if crews were attacking Italy and had to fly through (rather than "over") the Alps. When Stirlings were on operations with other RAF bombers which could fly higher, the Luftwaffe concentrated on the Stirlings. Within five months of being introduced, 67 out of 84 aircraft had been lost to enemy action or written off after crashes. The Stirling's maximum bomb load could be carried for only around . On typical missions deep into Germany or Italy, a smaller load was carried, consisting of seven GP bombs; this payload was in the range of that which was already being carried by the RAF's medium bombers, such as the Vickers Wellington and by 1944, the de Havilland Mosquito. Perhaps the biggest weakness present in the design was that, although the bomb bay was large at long, it had a pair of structural dividers that ran down the middle, limiting the bay to nothing larger than the bomb. As the RAF started using the "cookies" and even larger "specials", the Stirling became less useful. The Handley-Page Halifax and especially the Avro Lancaster offered better performance and when these aircraft became available in greater numbers from 1943, the Stirlings were relegated to secondary tasks. In May 1944, No. 138 (Special Duties) Squadron acquired 22 Stirlings to support resistance groups organised by the Special Operations Executive in Europe. Standard "C" Type containers for weapons and other stores could be loaded into the bomb bay and dropped like a payload of bombs. The Stirling could carry 18 of these; a particularly large load. Smaller panniers or packages could be carried in the Stirling's roomy rear fuselage and manually dropped through a hole in the floor by a dispatcher. Experiments with a roller-based conveyor to drop these packages faster than a dispatcher were delayed until the end of the war by concerns that this would involve too rapid a change in the aircraft's centre of gravity. From late 1944, 160 of the special transport variant Stirling Mk V were built, which had the tail turret removed and a new nose opening added; most of these were completed after the war. By 1946, the Stirlings of Transport Command were being phased out and replaced by the Avro York, which was a transport derivative of the Lancaster that had previously replaced the Stirling in the bomber role. While many aircraft were scrapped, 12 Stirlings were modified to conform with S.37 standards and sold to Belgian charter operator Trans-Air in May 1947. Acting Flt Sgt Arthur Louis Aaron, was awarded his VC as the captain of a No. 218 Squadron Stirling in a raid on Turin in August 1943. Aaron was badly wounded while piloting the aircraft and refused to rest, directing the flight engineer, who was acting as co-pilot, to fly to Rabah Bitat Airport (Bone Airfield), Algeria; he died following the aircraft's safe landing. Six Stirlings were purchased by the Egyptian Air Force for use in the 1948 Arab Israeli War, forming the 8th Bomber Squadron. These flew a number of air raids on Israeli targets in the 1948 war, one of their number being lost either as a result of an accident or sabotage. The remaining five appear to have been scrapped or retired by 1951. ==Operators==
Operators
; • Trans-Air, later known as Air Transport (Post-war civilian use, a total of 10 planes, 9 of which went on to the Egyptian Air Force. The 10th (OO-XAC, ex-PK172) crashed during operations in Kunming, China) ; • Egyptian Air Force ; • Luftwaffe :* KG 200 ; • Royal Air Force :* Operational Units :** No. 7 Squadron RAF: bomber unit, Mk.I August 1940 to July 1943, Mk.III March 1943 to July 1943. Operational from February 1941. Based at Leeming, then Oakington (October 1940). :** No.11 Ferry Unit: September 1944 to August 1945. Based at Talbenny. :** No.12 Ferry Unit: September 1944 to November 1945. Based at Melton Mowbray. :** No. 15 Squadron RAF: bomber unit, Mk.I April 1941 to January 1943, Mk.III January 1943 to December 1943. Based at Wyton, then Bourn (August 1942), then Mildenhall (April 1943). :** No. 46 Squadron RAF: air transport unit, January 1945 to February 1946. Based at Storney Cross. :** No. 51 Squadron RAF: air transport unit, June 1945 to February 1946. Based at Leconfield, then Stradishall (August 1945). :** No. 75 (New Zealand) Squadron: bomber unit, October 1942 to March 1944. based at Mildenhall, then Mepal (June 1943). :** No. 90 Squadron RAF: bomber unit, November 1942 to June 1944. Operational from January 1943. Based at Bottesford, then Ridgewell (December 1942), then Wrattling Common (May 1943), then Tuddenham (October 1943). :** No. 138 Squadron RAF: special duty service unit (air supply for resistance forces), Mk.IV June 1944 to March 1945. :** No. 148 Squadron RAF: special duty service unit (air supply for resistance forces), Mk.IV November 1944 to December 1944. Based at Brindisi (Italy). :** No. 149 Squadron RAF: bomber unit, Mk.I November 1941 to June 1943, Mk.III June 1943 to September 1944. Based at Mildehall, then Lakenheath (April 1942), then Methwold (May 1944). :** No. 158 Squadron RAF: air transport unit, June 1945 to December 1945. Based at Lissett, then Stradsihall (August 1945). :** No. 161 Squadron RAF. special duty service unit (air supply for resistance forces), Mk.IV and Mk.V April 1942 to June 1945. Based at Tempsford. :** No. 171 Squadron RAF: bomber support unit (electronic countermeasures), Mk.III September 1944 to January 1945. Based at North Creake. :** No. 190 Squadron RAF: glider-towing unit, Mk. IV January 1944 to May 1945. Based at Leicester East, then Fairford (March 1944), then Great Dunnow (October 1944). :** No. 196 Squadron RAF: bomber support unit (electronic countermeasures), Mk.III July 1943 to February 1944, Mk.IV February 1944 to March 1946. Based at Witchford, then Leicester East (November 43), Tarrant Rushton (January 1944), Keevil (March 1944,) Wethersfield (October 1944), Shepherds Grove (January 1945). :** No. 199 Squadron RAF: bomber unit, July 1943 to May 1944, then bomber support unit (electronic countermeasures), May 1944 to May 1945. Based at Lakenheath, then North Creake (May 1944). :** No. 214 Squadron RAF: bomber unit, April 1942 to January 1944. Based at Stradishall, then Chedburgh (October 1942), Downham Market (December 1943), Sculthorpe (January 1944), :** No. 218 Squadron RAF: bomber unit, January 1942 to August 1944. Based at Maraham, then Downham Market (July 1942), Woolfox Lodge (march 1944), Methwold (August 1944). :** No. 242 Squadron RAF: air transport unit, February 1945 to December 1945. Based at Stoeney Cross. :** No. 295 Squadron RAF: air transport unit, Mk.IV July 1944 to January 1946. Based at Harwell, then Rivenhall (October 1944). :** No. 299 Squadron RAF: air transport unit, Mk.IV January 1944 to February 1946, based at Stoney Cross, then Keevil (March 1941), Wethersfield (October 1944), Shepherds Grove (January 1945). :** No. 513 Squadron RAF: bomber unit, Mk.I September 1943 to October 1943, Mk.III October 1943 to November 1943. Based at Witchford. :** No. 525 Squadron RAF: air transport unit, one single Stirling attached for trials June 1944 to August 1944. Based at Lyneham. :** No. 570 Squadron RAF: air transport unit, Mk.IV July 1944 to January 1946. based at Harwell, then Rivenhall (October 1944). :** No. 620 Squadron RAF: bomber unit, Mk.I June 1943 to August 1943, Mk.III August 1943 to February 1944, Mk.IV February 1944 to July 1945. Airborne support unit (transport) from November 1943. Based at Chedburgh, then Leicester East (November 1943), Fairford (March 1944), Great Dunmow (October 1944). :** No. 622 Squadron RAF: bomber unit, Mk.III August 1943 to December 1943. Based at Mildenhall. :** No. 623 Squadron RAF. bomber unit, Mk.III August 1943 to December 1943. Based at Downham Market. :** No. 624 Squadron RAF: special operations support unit, Ml.IV June 1944 to September 1944. Based at Blida (Algeria). :** No.1375 Heavy Transport Unit: October 1945 to April 1946. Based at Wethersfield. :** No.1588 (Heavy Freighter) Flight: October 1945 to May 1946. Based at Bombay (India). :** No.1589 (Heavy Freighter) Flight: October 1945 to May 1946. Based at Cairo (Egypt) :* Training Units :** No.7 Conversion Flight: October 1941 to October 1942. Based at Oakington. :** No.15 Conversion Flight: January 1942 to May 1942. Based at Alconbury, then Waterbeach (May 1942). :** No.21 Heavy Glider Conversion Unit: Julu 1945 to August 1945. Based at Brize Norton. :** No.26 Conversion Flight: November 1941 to January 1942. Based at Waterbeach. :** No.101 Conversion Flight: ??? 1941 to October 1942. Based at Oakington. :** No.149 Conversion Flight: November 1941 to October 1942. Based at Mildenhall. :** No.214 Conversion Flight: April 1942 to October 1942. Based at Waterbeach (Stradishall from May 1942 to August 1942). :** No.218 Conversion Flight: January 1942 to October 1942. Based at Barton Bendish. :** No.303 Ferry Training Unit: September 1942 to September 1944. Based at Talbenny. :** No.304 Ferry Training Unit: December 1942 to October 1944. Based at Melton Mowbray. :** No.1332 Heavy Conversion Unit: air transport training, August 1942 to May 1945. Based at Longtown, then Nutt's Corner (October 1942), Riccall (April 1945). :** No.1427 (Training) Flight: December 1941 to April 1943. Based at Thruxton, then Hullavington (May 1942), Marham (August 1942), Stradishall (October 1942). :** No.1651 Heavy Conversion Unit: January 1942 to December 1944. Based at Waterbeach, then Wratting Common (November 1943), then Woolfox Lodge(November 1944). :** No.1653 Heavy Conversion Unit: November 1943 to November 1944. Based at Chedburgh. :** No.1654 Heavy Conversion Unit: December 1942 to January 1943. Based at Wigsley. :** No.1657 Heavy Conversion Unit: October 1942 to December 1944. Based at Stradishall (Shepherd's Grove from May to October 1944). :** No.1660 Heavy Conversion Unit: November 1943 to January 1945. Based at Swinderby. :** No.1661 Heavy Conversion Unit: November 1943 to December 1944. Based at Winthorpe. :** No.1655 Heavy Conversion Unit: May 1943 to July 1946. Based at Waterbeach, then Woolfox Lodge (June 1943), Tilstock (January 1944), Saltby (March 1945), Marston Moor (August 1945), Linton-on-Ouse (November 1945). :** Navigation Training Unit, Pathfinder Force: April 1943 to March 1944. Based at Gransden Lodge, then at Warboys (June 1943). :** Operational and Refresher Training Unit: February 1945 to October 1945. Based at Matching. ==Variants==
Variants
;Short S.31: Half-scale flying test-bed, powered by 4x Pobjoy Niagara 7-cylinder radial engines ;Stirling I:Powered by Bristol Hercules XI engines. ;Stirling II:Powered by Wright R-2600 Twin Cyclone engines. Four prototypes built. ;Stirling III: Heavy bomber, powered by Bristol Hercules XVI engines. ;Stirling IV: Para-dropping and glider towing assault transport, powered by Bristol Hercules XVI engines. ;Stirling V: Cargo aircraft, powered by Bristol Hercules XVI engines. == Surviving aircraft ==
Surviving aircraft
Stirling BK716 was recovered using a grapple between 31 August and 9 October 2020 from Markermeer, Netherlands, and parts of it are to be put on display. Two sections of Stirlings have been displayed in museums. At the ''Musée du terrain d'aviation militaire in Vraux, France there are sections of the rear fuselage of Stirling LK142'', a No. 196 Squadron RAF aircraft that crashed near Spincourt on 24 September 1944. The second section is at the Museum Vliegbasis in Deelen, Netherlands, and comes from No. 299 Squadron RAF Stirling LK545 which crashed near Nijmegen on 23 September 1944. A piece of the fuselage was cut off and used as a pig sty on a farm in Beuningen until transferred to a museum in 2003. In September 2019, 75 years after the liberation of the southern Netherlands, excavation started on Stirling W7630 in Lilbosch Abbey near Pey, Echt, Netherlands, which crashed on 10 September 1942. The crew did not survive the crash and the excavation team expects remains to be found and anticipate the wreckage being buried into the ground. The excavation was delayed for many years as the aircraft was severely damaged on impact and it is unknown if unexploded bombs are present. In 1986, the RAF Sub-Aqua Association investigated raising No. 196 Squadron RAF Stirling EF311 which ditched offshore from Selsey Bill on 26 August 1943. After assessing the wreck, which lay at a depth of , the group decided against proceeding. In 1994 the same group looked at the possibility of raising No.196 Squadron Stirling LJ925, which crashed on 25 February 1945 in Hølen Lake, near Arendal, Norway and which had been discovered at a depth of buried in mud and tree bark shavings. This plan was also abandoned, although the group recovered a propeller blade. During preparations for the laying of the North Sea Link electrical cable in 2017, remains suspected to be of a Stirling were found in the North Sea between England and Norway. In September 1977, wreckage of Stirling LK488, which crashed on Mickle Fell in the Pennines on 19 October 1944, was recovered by the RAF. In 2023, the tail section from LK488 went on display at the Royal Air Force Museum London, while a fuselage section was placed on display at the Museum's Cosford site. In the absence of any complete surviving aircraft the "Stirling Aircraft Project" was setup in the late 1990s to make a recreation of the forward fuselage section of a Stirling, largely from new fabrication. In August 2025 archeologists recovered the wreck of a Short Stirling near Kerpen-Manheim in the Hambach surface mine, where the aircraft EF427 had crashed on 31 July 1943 after it had been hit by anti-aircraft fire during a raid on Remscheid. The digging team transported 17 boxes of aircraft parts to the Rheinisches Landesmuseum Bonn. The human remains found at the site, potentially the four missing crew members, are due to be identified by DNA testing. ==Specifications (Short Stirling I)==
tickerdossier.comtickerdossier.substack.com