While dynamic cone speakers remain the most popular choice, many other speaker technologies exist. Balanced armature drivers (a type of moving iron driver) use an armature that moves like a see-saw or diving board. Since they are not damped, they are highly efficient, but they also produce strong resonances. They are still used today for high-end
earphones and hearing aids, where small size and high efficiency are important.
Piezoelectric speakers Piezoelectric speakers are frequently used as beepers in
watches and other electronic devices, and are sometimes used as tweeters in less-expensive speaker systems, such as computer speakers and portable radios. Piezoelectric speakers have several advantages over conventional loudspeakers: They are resistant to overloads that can destroy other high-frequency drivers, and, due to their electrical properties, they can be used without a crossover. Piezoelectric speakers can have extended high-frequency output, and this is useful in some specialized circumstances; for instance,
sonar applications in which piezoelectric variants are used as both output devices (generating underwater sound) and as input devices (acting as the sensing components of
underwater microphones). They have other advantages in these applications, not the least of which is simple and solid-state construction that resists seawater better than a ribbon or cone-based device would. There are also disadvantages: some amplifiers may oscillate when driving capacitive loads like piezoelectrics, which results in distortion or damage to the amplifier. Additionally, their frequency response is typically inferior to that of other technologies. In 2013,
Kyocera introduced piezoelectric ultra-thin medium-size film speakers with only one millimeter of thickness and seven grams of weight for their 55"
OLED televisions.
Magnetostatic loudspeakers Instead of a voice coil driving a speaker cone, a magnetostatic speaker uses an array of metal strips bonded to a large film membrane. The magnetic field produced by signal current flowing through the strips interacts with the field of permanent bar magnets mounted behind them. The force produced moves the membrane and so the air in front of it. Typically, these designs are less efficient than conventional moving-coil speakers.
Magnetostrictive speakers Transducers based on
magnetostriction have been predominantly used as ultrasonic sound wave radiators for
sonar, but their use has also spread to audio speaker systems, including subwoofers. Magnetostrictive speaker drivers have some special advantages: they can provide greater force (with smaller excursions) than other technologies and low excursion can avoid distortions from large excursion as in other designs; the magnetizing coil is stationary and therefore more easily cooled; they are robust because delicate suspensions and voice coils are not required. Magnetostrictive speaker modules have been produced by Fostex and
FeONIC.
Electrostatic loudspeakers Electrostatic loudspeakers use a high-voltage electric field (rather than a magnetic field) between two conductive planes to drive a thin statically charged membrane between them. Because the driving force is applied over the entire membrane surface rather than from a small voice coil, they potentially provide a more linear and lower-distortion motion than dynamic drivers. They also have a relatively narrow dispersion pattern that can make for precise sound-field positioning comparable to
studio monitors. However, their optimum listening area is small and they are not very efficient speakers. Diaphragm excursion is severely limited due to practical construction limitations—the further apart the planes are positioned, the higher the voltage must be to achieve acceptable output. This increases the tendency for electrical arcs, as well as increasing the speaker's tendency to attract dust particles. Arcing remains a potential problem with current technologies, especially when the panels are allowed to collect dust or dirt and are driven with high signal levels. Electrostatics are inherently dipole radiators and, due to the thin flexible membrane, are less suited for use in enclosures, which can reduce low-frequency front-to-back cancellations. Due to this and the low excursion capability, full-range electrostatic loudspeakers are large by nature, and the bass
rolls off at a frequency corresponding to a quarter wavelength of the narrowest panel dimension. To reduce the size of commercial products, they are sometimes used as a high-frequency driver in combination with a conventional dynamic driver that handles the bass frequencies effectively. Electrostatics are usually driven through a
step-up transformer that multiplies the voltage swings produced by the power amplifier. This transformer also multiplies the capacitive load that is inherent in electrostatic transducers, which means the effective impedance presented to the power amplifiers varies widely by frequency. A speaker that is nominally 8 ohms may actually present a load of 1 ohm at higher frequencies, which is challenging for some amplifier designs.
Ribbon and planar magnetic loudspeakers A
ribbon speaker consists of a thin metal-film ribbon suspended in a magnetic field. The electrical signal is applied to the ribbon, which
moves in the magnetic field to create the sound. The advantage of a ribbon driver is that the ribbon has very little
mass; thus, it can accelerate very quickly, yielding a very good high-frequency response. Ribbon loudspeakers are often very fragile. Most ribbon tweeters emit sound in a
dipole pattern. A few have backings that limit the dipole radiation pattern. Above and below the ends of the more or less rectangular ribbon, there is less audible output due to phase cancellation, but the precise amount of directivity depends on the ribbon length. Ribbon designs generally require exceptionally powerful magnets, which makes them costly to manufacture. Ribbons have a very low impedance that most amplifiers cannot drive directly. As a result, a
step-down transformer is typically used to increase the current through the ribbon. The amplifier
sees a load that is the ribbon's resistance times the transformer turns ratio squared. The transformer must be carefully designed so that its frequency response and parasitic losses do not degrade the sound, further increasing cost and complication relative to conventional designs.
Planar magnetic speakers consist of a flexible membrane with a voice coil printed or mounted on it. The
current flowing through the coil interacts with the magnetic field of carefully placed magnets on either side of the diaphragm, causing the membrane to vibrate more or less uniformly and without much bending or wrinkling. The driving force covers a large percentage of the membrane surface and reduces resonance problems inherent in coil-driven flat diaphragms.
Bending wave loudspeakers Bending wave transducers use a diaphragm that is intentionally flexible. The rigidity of the material increases from the center to the outside. Short wavelengths radiate primarily from the inner area, while longer waves reach the edge of the speaker. To prevent reflections from the outside back into the center, long waves are absorbed by a surrounding damper. Such transducers can cover a wide frequency range and have been promoted as being close to an ideal point sound source. This uncommon approach is being taken by only a very few manufacturers, in very different arrangements. The Ohm Walsh loudspeakers use a unique driver designed by
Lincoln Walsh, who had been a radar development engineer in WWII. He became interested in audio equipment design and his last project was a unique, one-way speaker using a single driver. The cone faced down into a sealed, airtight enclosure. Rather than move back and forth as conventional speakers do, the cone rippled and created sound in a manner known in RF electronics as a
transmission line. The new speaker created a cylindrical sound field. Lincoln Walsh died before his speaker was released to the public. The Ohm Acoustics firm has produced several loudspeaker models using the Walsh driver design since then. German Physiks, an audio equipment firm in Germany, also produces speakers using this approach. The German firm Manger has designed and produced a bending wave driver that at first glance appears conventional. In fact, the round panel attached to the voice coil bends in a carefully controlled way to produce full-range sound. Josef W. Manger was awarded with the
Rudolf-Diesel-Medaille for extraordinary developments and inventions by the German institute of inventions.
Flat panel loudspeakers There have been many attempts to reduce the size of speaker systems, or alternatively to make them less obvious. One such attempt was the development of
exciter transducer coils mounted to flat panels to act as sound sources, most accurately called exciter/panel drivers. These can then be made in a neutral color and hung on walls where they are less noticeable than many speakers, or can be deliberately painted with patterns, in which case they can function decoratively. There are two related problems with flat panel techniques: first, a flat panel is necessarily more flexible than a cone shape in the same material, and therefore moves as a single unit even less, and second, resonances in the panel are difficult to control, leading to considerable distortions. There have been several flat panel systems commercially produced in recent years.
Heil air motion transducers Oskar Heil invented the air motion transducer in the 1960s. In this approach, a pleated diaphragm is mounted in a magnetic field and forced to close and open under control of a music signal. Air is forced from between the pleats in accordance with the imposed signal, generating sound. The drivers are less fragile than ribbons and considerably more efficient (and able to produce higher absolute output levels) than ribbon, electrostatic, or planar magnetic tweeter designs. ESS, a California manufacturer, licensed the design, employed Heil, and produced a range of speaker systems using his tweeters during the 1970s and 1980s.
Lafayette Radio, a large US retail store chain, also sold speaker systems using such tweeters for a time. There are several manufacturers of these drivers (at least two in Germany—one of which produces a range of high-end professional speakers using tweeters and mid-range drivers based on the technology) and the drivers are increasingly used in professional audio. Martin Logan produces several AMT speakers in the US and GoldenEar Technologies incorporates them in its entire speaker line.
Transparent ionic conduction speaker In 2013, a research team introduced a transparent ionic conduction speaker which has two sheets of transparent conductive gel and a layer of transparent rubber in between to make high voltage and high actuation work to reproduce good sound quality. The speaker is suitable for robotics, mobile computing and adaptive optics fields.
Digital speakers Digital speakers have been the subject of experiments performed by
Bell Labs as far back as the 1920s. The design is simple; each
bit controls a driver, which is either fully 'on' or 'off'. Problems with this design have led manufacturers to abandon it as impractical for the present. First, for a reasonable number of bits (required for adequate
sound reproduction quality), the physical size of a speaker system becomes very large. Secondly, due to inherent
analog-to-digital conversion problems, the effect of
aliasing is unavoidable, so that the audio output is
reflected at equal amplitude in the frequency domain, on the other side of the
Nyquist limit (half the sampling frequency), causing an unacceptably high level of
ultrasonics to accompany the desired output. No workable scheme has been found to adequately deal with this.
Without a diaphragm Plasma arc speakers Plasma arc loudspeakers use electrical
plasma as a radiating element. Since plasma has minimal mass, but is charged and therefore can be manipulated by an
electric field, the result is a very linear output at frequencies far higher than the audible range. Problems of maintenance and reliability for this approach tend to make it unsuitable for mass market use. In 1978 Alan E. Hill of the Air Force Weapons Laboratory in Albuquerque, NM, designed the
Plasmatronics Hill Type I, a tweeter whose plasma was generated from
helium gas. This avoided the
ozone and
NOx produced by
RF decomposition of air in an earlier generation of plasma tweeters made by the pioneering DuKane Corporation, who produced the Ionovac (marketed as the Ionofane in the UK) during the 1950s. A less expensive variation on this theme is the use of a flame for the driver, as flames contain ionized (electrically charged) gases.
Thermoacoustic speakers In 2008, researchers of Tsinghua University demonstrated a
thermoacoustic loudspeaker (or
thermophone) of
carbon nanotube thin film, whose working mechanism is a thermoacoustic effect. Sound frequency electric currents are used to periodically heat the CNT and thus result in sound generation in the surrounding air. The CNT thin film loudspeaker is transparent, stretchable and flexible. In 2013, researchers of Tsinghua University further present a thermoacoustic earphone of carbon nanotube thin yarn and a thermoacoustic surface-mounted device. They are both fully integrated devices and compatible with Si-based semiconducting technology.
Rotary woofers A
rotary woofer is essentially a fan with blades that constantly change their pitch, allowing them to easily push the air back and forth. Rotary woofers are able to efficiently reproduce
subsonic frequencies, which are difficult to impossible to achieve on a traditional speaker with a diaphragm. They are often employed in movie theaters to recreate rumbling bass effects, such as explosions. ==See also==