Survivor: Pearl Islands was met with critical acclaim and is generally considered to be one of the show's best seasons. It was ranked by host
Jeff Probst as his 5th favorite season. Dalton Ross of
Entertainment Weekly ranked it eighth, citing
Rupert Boneham and
Jonny Fairplay as memorable players. Both Andrea Deiher of
Zap2it and Joe Reid of
The Wire ranked it as the 9th-greatest season; Deiher called Fairplay's lie about his grandmother "some next-level shenanigans never before seen on reality TV," and Reid described Rupert and Fairplay as "two of the series' signature players" who "pretty much made the season." Since 2012, "
Survivor Oz" has consistently ranked
Pearl Islands in the top 5 greatest seasons, in its annual polls ranking every season of the series; it was 4th in 2012, 3rd in 2013 and 2015, and 5th in 2014. "The Purple Rock Podcast," ranked it as the 6th best season out of 40. In the official issue of
CBS Watch commemorating
Survivor's 15th anniversary,
Pearl Islands was voted by viewers as the #2 greatest season of the series, only behind
Heroes vs. Villains, and thus was the highest-ranking season with an entirely new cast. Also,
Sandra Diaz-Twine was ranked in another poll, in the same magazine, as the 6th greatest contestant in the series, and was the highest-ranking contestant on the list to win her first time playing. Additionally, Fairplay's infamous lie about his grandmother's death was voted as the #10 most memorable moment in the series. In 2015, a poll by
Rob Has a Podcast ranked
Pearl Islands 2nd out of 30, behind
Heroes vs. Villains, with
Rob Cesternino ranking this season 3rd. This was updated in 2021 during Cesternino's podcast,
Survivor All-Time Top 40 Rankings, ranking 3rd out of 40th. In 2020,
Inside Survivor ranked this season as the show's best out of the first 40 calling it "the quintessential
Survivor season, containing everything that makes the show so great: an incredible cast, exciting gameplay, a well-worked theme, fun challenges, jawdropping moments, humor, drama, emotion, etc." In 2024, Nick Caruso of
TVLine ranked this season 8th out of 47. ==References==