The season has generally been negatively received, with the primary criticism being the repetition of the "battle of the sexes" theme, and how the theme arguably did not work as well in this season as it did in
Survivor: The Amazon. Host
Jeff Probst, ranking it as the 5th-worst season in 2010, admittedly felt that he "liked this season more than the audience did, and that has probably influenced why it has dropped since my last ranking." Tom Santilli of
Examiner.com ranked it among the bottom 10 at #21, while Dalton Ross of
Entertainment Weekly ranked it the seventh-worst season of the series, only better than
San Juan del Sur,
One World,
Thailand,
Fiji,
Nicaragua and
Island of the Idols, saying that although "the battle of the sexes worked well the first time around," he felt it wasn't as strong in this season. In 2020, it was ranked 31st out of 40 by
Survivor fan site "The Purple Rock Podcast", saying that "the casting was below average on this season," and since "the gimmick/twist for this season was one the show had used before…the issue here is whether you like that narrative." Andrea Deiher of
Zap2it ranked it as the 3rd-worst season, saying that "we can barely remember anyone from this season…this was just kind of a dud season." In 2015, a poll by
Rob Has a Podcast ranked
Vanuatu 17th out of 30 with
Rob Cesternino ranking this season 19th. This was updated in 2021 during Cesternino's podcast,
Survivor All-Time Top 40 Rankings, ranking 23rd out of 40. In 2020,
Inside Survivor ranked this season 22nd out of 40 saying that while "there are a few casting duds on
Vanuatu, and the early merge suffers from a predictable Pagonging against the men, there's still a lot to love in this season thanks to its characters, unexpected moments, and a fantastic endgame." In 2024, Nick Caruso of
TVLine ranked this season 31st out of 47. Part of the show's mixed-to-negative legacy has been defined by how different observers feel about the season's winner, Chris Daugherty. Jeff Probst has stated that Chris was a liar and a bad winner, a sentiment that many fans speculate stemmed from his post game relationship with Julie Berry, who Chris voted off. While many fans liked Chris and were happy when he won, his status as a one time contestant, paired with Probst's blatant dislike for him, has made his legacy more faded than other winners, many of whom have returned for at least one season. ==References==