Critical response On
Rotten Tomatoes, the fourth season holds an approval rating of 92%, based on 142 critic reviews, with an average rating of 7.65/10. The website's critical consensus reads, "Boxing in the political arena with a bloodied smile,
The Boys fourth season is grim and even a little glum while holding up a cracked mirror towards modern society." On
Metacritic, the season holds a weighted average score of 76 out of 100, based on 22 critics, indicating "generally favorable" reviews. Contributing to
The Illuminerdi, Kevin Fenix was exceedingly impressed and ecstatic in his review, awarding it 10/10, writing: "Season 4 is a triumph in every sense, blending sharp social commentary with compelling character arcs and breathtaking production value. It is a brilliant exploration of power, corruption, and humanity, told through the lens of a world where superheroes are anything but heroic. With its perfectly packed and balanced stories, characters, themes, and issues,
The Boys continues to be one of the most relevant and entertaining series on television ... A must-watch." Alison Foreman of
Empire rated the season 4 out of 5 stars, calling season four the "best yet" and the series "at the top of its game", while also praising its "meaningful" character drama.
Pastes Trent Moore gave the season a 9.0 rating, writing: "It's a wild ride, arguably the show's wildest yet, which is saying something ... Season 4 is simply phenomenal ...
The Boys has been one of the best shows on television for years now and continues to cement its place in the pantheon with its deft blend of drama, gore, political commentary, and surrealism. The series is a pressure cooker that only gets hotter and tighter as it goes on." Megan Vick of
GameSpot commended its "emotional center", though criticized the "slow start". Grading the season a B+,
IndieWires Ben Travers wrote: "It's mostly impressive how deftly
The Boys dramatic side balances its many arcs, while the black comedy's demented inventiveness helps distract from any lingering deficiencies ... My notes on Season 4 are littered with 'oh god's' and 'hoo boy's', all of which denote a particularly gnarly set piece or horrific marvel of creature design." In a mixed review, Matt Donato of
IGN graded the season with a 7/10, writing: "Season 4 can't capitalize on all its competing plotlines, but still delivers the show's signature shock and awe entertainment." Also giving the season a 7/10 and mixed review, Garrett Blaney of
Collider wrote: "Season 4 goes wilder than ever before, but even that isn't enough to distract from the formulaic approach the show is taking", adding "No amount of gore or meta-commentary can hide the fact that the story is getting thin."
GamesRadar+s Emily Murray, awarding the season 3 out of 5 stars, was also mixed, writing: "
The Boys may be back in town, but the cracks are beginning to show ... at least there's plenty here to enjoy from this wildly entertaining latest chapter." Though praising the season finale, calling it "excellent" and "strong", Erik Kain of
Forbes found the rest of the season "mediocre" and considered the season to be "filler, with unsatisfying character development ... and weird side stories that didn't need to take up so much time". Conversely,
Startefacts Zoe Wallace gave the overall season an extremely negative review, deeming it the "worst" and "weakest" season so far. She criticized about the low stakes, shock value, and new characters' lack of charisma, summarizing: "The confrontation with Homelander is clearly dragging on and the writers are running out of ideas. Season 4 could have been great if the writers weren't afraid to kill off characters and weren't distracted by secondary storylines – and that's what made Season 4 the worst of all." Reviewing the season finale and season four as a whole,
Comic Book Resources Joshua M. Patton deemed the finale as "the series' most important episode yet" and the overall season as "powerful" television. He concluded by stating: "After faithfully adapting the comic's most important basics and beats during its earliest episodes,
The Boys grew into its own beast. Even better, the series' original story was a much better political commentary and character study of superheroes than its source material ever was. Despite its aggression and edginess,
The Boys is arguably one of the strongest appeals to humanity and demolitions of toxic masculinity on air today. While the series is best known for its pitch-black humor and send-up of superhero culture, Season 4 proves that
The Boys fits into the mold of superhero storytelling more than it doesn't. Using fantastical characters and classic genre conventions, the storytellers held up a mirror to the real-world with a warning about how embracing ugliness, violence, revenge and hatred will only lead to the proliferation of more sadness and suffering. There hasn't been a superhero story as daring and relevant as
The Boys Season 4 in quite some time, and it will be an even longer while before any other superhero story can surpass it."
Audience response The season was generally divisive for audiences, though the season finale received acclaim. Following its three-episode premiere, the season received a mixed response among audiences on
Rotten Tomatoes. Users have mainly criticized the season leaning towards more
left-wing political commentary, compared to what was perceived as both left- and
right-wing commentary from prior seasons. Due to this, critics have attributed the audience response as
review bombing. a theory which has been confirmed by Kripke. Days before the premiere of season four, Kripke described the series to
The Hollywood Reporter as a "story about the intersection of
celebrity and
authoritarianism and how
social media and
entertainment are used to sell
fascism". He also said that viewers who think the show is too "
woke" should "go watch something else" and expressed surprise to some viewers perceiving Homelander as the series' hero, saying: "What do you say to that? The show's many things. Subtle isn't one of them." Additionally, many social media users mocked others who lamented the
anti-Trump undertones of season four. A scene in the sixth episode, "Dirty Business", attracted significant criticism. The scene, which depicts main character
Hughie Campbell getting sexually tortured by the character Tek Knight, attracted backlash for its handling of
rape and
male sexual abuse. The backlash became more severe when Kripke said that, when coming up with the scene, he found the idea "hilarious".
Garth Ennis, co-creator of the comic book series, addressed his thoughts about the right-wing fans and their reaction to the series' satire, claiming that this is a world where "both ends of the
political spectrum can claim they are the
Jedi and the other guys are the
Sith" and that "we're through the looking glass". He also pointed out that the contrast from certain fans comes from the fact that "people are choosing what to believe" in regards to the series. Conversely, one element of the season fans have praised is Starr's performance, particularly in the fourth episode ("Wisdom of the Ages"). Following the aforementioned episode's release, many users on social media campaigned for Starr to win a
Primetime Emmy Award, expressing how deserving he is of such an honor, a sentiment that critics have previously concurred with on various occasions; Kripke himself also agreed. For his performance, Starr was named an honorable mention for
TVLine "Performer of the Week" for the week of June 17, 2024.
TVLines Vlada Gelman highly praised Starr's performance, writing: "We thought we'd already seen the scariest and most sadistic side of Homelander on
The Boys, but Antony Starr's performance in this week's episode took the character to impressively terrifying new extremes ... which only goes to prove that Starr's instincts as Homelander are not only spot-on, but make the character even more fascinating and frightening."
Audience viewership According to
Amazon, the first three episodes of the season received a 21% increase in total viewers compared to season three in the first four days since launch. The fourth season became among the top 5 most-viewed TV seasons on Amazon Prime Video through its first four days, according to the streamer. It was also reported that the fourth season tallied the second most viewers of any returning season on Prime Video through its first four days, behind only the second season of
Reacher. Furthermore, Amazon reported that
The Boys has grown in global viewership per season. Amidst the launch of the season's first three episodes,
The Boys scored 1.19 billion viewing minutes during the week of June 10–16, 2024, according to
Nielsen streaming data. On July 25, Amazon reported that season four overall garnered more than 55 million viewers globally since the season premiere. That figure counts 39 days of viewership after the premiere, ending on July 21, just after the July 18 season finale released. This marked the third-consecutive season of global viewership growth for the satirical superhero series, becoming Prime Video's fourth most-viewed television season of all time and behind only
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 1,
Fallout season 1, and
Reacher season 1.
Awards and nominations ==Notes==