One writer described
Hail the Conquering Hero as "a satire on mindless hero-worship, small-town politicians, and something we might call "Mom-ism," the almost idolatrous reverence that Americans have for the institution of Motherhood," and Sturges himself said that of all his films, it was "the one with the least wrong with it." The film has the normal hallmarks of Sturges' best work: an extremely fast pace, overlapping dialogue, and rapid-fire punch lines.
Monty Python's
Terry Jones called it "like a wonderful piece of clockwork." In
The Nation in 1944,
James Agee, critic, wrote, "The film has enough themes for half a dozen first-rate American satires—the crippling myth of the dead heroic father, the gentle tyranny of the widowed mother, the predicament of the only child, the questionable nature of most heroism, the political function of returning soldiers, these are just a few; I suppose in a sense the whole story is a sort of
Coriolanus on all fours. But not one of these themes is honored by more attention than you get from an incontinent barber in a railway terminal, and the main theme, which I take to be a study of honor, is dishonored by every nightingale in Sturges's belfry... Any adequate review of this remarkable movie would devote at least as much space to its unqualified praise as I have to qualifying the praise... it tells a story so touching, so chock-full of human frailties and so rich in homely detail that it achieves a reality transcending the limitations of its familiar slapstick." Critic
Pauline Kael states that Sturges: "... uses verbal slapstick as well as visual slapstick, and his timing is so quirkily effective that the dialogue keeps popping off, like a string of firecrackers."
Leslie Halliwell gave it three of four stars, stating: "Skillfully orchestrated Preston Sturges romp, slightly marred by an overdose of sentiment but featuring his repertory of comic actors at full pitch." The film can be seen as a look at patriotism and hero worship in the United States during World War II, and while adhering to the
Hollywood Production Code – even more restrictive in wartime – it can be seen as somewhat critical of people's willingness to uncritically embrace heroes. In this regard it is a companion piece to ''
The Miracle of Morgan's Creek'', the previous Sturges satirical venture. ==References==