Casting While the studio and the public agreed that the part of Rhett Butler should go to
Clark Gable (except for Clark Gable himself), casting for the role of Scarlett was harder. The search for an actress to play Scarlett in the film version of the novel famously drew the biggest names in the history of cinema, such as
Bette Davis (who had been cast as a Southern belle in
Jezebel in 1938), and
Katharine Hepburn, who went so far as demanding an appointment with producer
David O. Selznick and saying, "I am Scarlett O'Hara! The role is practically written for me." Selznick replied rather bluntly, "I can't imagine Rhett Butler chasing you for twelve years."
Jean Arthur and
Lucille Ball were also considered, as well as relatively unknown actress
Doris Davenport.
Susan Hayward was "discovered" when she
tested for the part, and the career of
Lana Turner developed quickly after her screen test.
Tallulah Bankhead and
Joan Bennett were widely considered to be the most likely choices until they were supplanted by
Paulette Goddard.The young
English actress
Vivien Leigh, virtually unknown in America, saw that several English actors, including
Ronald Colman and
Leslie Howard, were in consideration for the male leads in
Gone with the Wind. Her agent happened to be the London representative of the
Myron Selznick talent agency, headed by David Selznick's brother, Myron. Leigh asked Myron to put her name into consideration as Scarlett on the eve of the American release of her picture
Fire Over England in February 1938. David Selznick watched both
Fire Over England and her most recent picture,
A Yank at Oxford, that month, and thought she was excellent but in no way a possible Scarlett, for she was "too British". But Myron Selznick arranged for David to first meet Leigh on the night in December 1938 when the burning of the Atlanta Depot was being filmed on the
Forty Acres backlot that Selznick International and
RKO shared. Leigh and her then lover
Laurence Olivier (later to be her husband) were visiting as guests of Myron Selznick, who was also Olivier's agent, while Leigh was in Hollywood hoping for a part in Olivier's current movie,
Wuthering Heights. In a letter to his wife two days later, David Selznick admitted that Leigh was "the Scarlett dark horse", and after a series of screen tests, her casting was announced on January 13, 1939. Just before the shooting of the film, Selznick informed
Ed Sullivan: "Scarlett O'Hara's parents were French and Irish. Identically, Miss Leigh's parents are French and Irish." In any case, Leigh was cast—despite public protest that the role was too "American" for an English actress—but Leigh was able to pull off the role so well that she eventually won an
Academy Award for her performance as Scarlett O'Hara.
Other actresses considered The search for Scarlett began shortly after the announcement of the film adaptation and lasted for over two years. Between late 1937 and mid-1938, approximately 128 actresses were nominated for the role of Scarlett through letters of suggestion sent to
Selznick International Pictures from the public. The following actresses were among those considered or auditioned for the role, which required playing Scarlett from 16 years of age until she was 28 (actress age in 1939, the year of
Gone with the Winds release, when Leigh was 26). •
Lucille Ball (28) •
Constance Bennett (35) •
Clara Bow (34) •
Mary Brian (33) •
Ruth Chatterton (47) •
Claudette Colbert (36) •
Joan Crawford (31–35) •
Bette Davis (31) •
Irene Dunne (41) •
Madge Evans (30) •
Glenda Farrell (35) •
Alice Faye (24) •
Joan Fontaine (22), sister of
Olivia de Havilland, who played
Melanie (23) •
Kay Francis (34) •
Janet Gaynor (33) •
Katharine Hepburn (32) •
Miriam Hopkins (37) •
Rochelle Hudson (23) •
Dorothy Lamour (25) •
Carole Lombard (31) •
Myrna Loy (34) •
Pola Negri (42) •
Maureen O'Sullivan (28) •
Merle Oberon (28) •
Ginger Rogers (28) •
Norma Shearer (37) •
Ann Sheridan (24) •
Gale Sondergaard, who also was considered for but ultimately lost the role of the
Wicked Witch of the West the same year •
Louise Platt (September 1936, 21) •
Tallulah Bankhead (December 1936, 34) •
Liz Whitney Tippett (April 1937, 32) •
Linda Watkins (June 1937, 29) •
Adele Longmire (August 1937, 19) •
Haila Stoddard (November 1937, 23) •
Susan Hayward (December 1937, 20; tested under her birth name Edith Marrener) •
Brenda Marshall (February 1938, 22; tested under her birth name Ardis Ankerson) •
Paulette Goddard (February 1938, 27) •
Ellen Drew (February 1938, 23; tested under the name Terry Ray) •
Anita Louise (February 1938, 23) •
Margaret Tallichet (March 1938, 24) •
Frances Dee (March 1938, 28) •
Nancy Coleman (September 1938, 25) •
Doris Davenport (October 1938, 21; tested under her birth name Doris Jordan) •
Marcella Martin (October 1938, 22; eventually won the role of Cathleen Calvert) •
Margaret Hayes (October 1938, 21; tested under the name Fleurette DeBussy) •
Lana Turner (November 1938, 17) •
Diana Barrymore (November 1938, 17) •
Jean Arthur (December 1938, 38) •
Joan Bennett (December 1938, 28) •
Vivien Leigh (December 1938, 25) Turner was eliminated after her screen test, with Cukor feeling she was too young to have the depth the role required. ==Comparisons to other characters==