Reviews The season was met with mixed-to-positive reviews. Jeffry Kauffman of Blu-ray.com gave the season 4/5. He said the season was "arguably an incremental step downward" but he still thought "There are still delights galore to be sampled throughout the season," Shadowlocked gave the season 4/5 stars. Luke Connolly said that the season did a great job at tying things together and praised "Girls Just Want to have Sums" and "We're on the Road to D'ohwhere" as highlights. He concluded by saying "While season 17 shows its age in certain places, its continual pursuit of originality and familiar comedy more than makes up for this, and one cannot help but be impressed." Fanboy Nation's Sean Mukvihill was positive on the season saying "Even though it isn't as a great as it once was, the show still boast some very clever writing and the best voice cast of any animated program in history." Capsule Computers was more critical of the season giving the season 5.5/10 and commented "As a long time fan of the early Simpsons that involved great episodes with hilarious, tightly developed plots, it is hard to stomach what the show has become." Spotlight Report gave the season 3.0/5 criticizing that it wasn't as funny as previous seasons. Colin Jacobson of
DVD Movie Guide said that the season "overcomes the weaker seasons and becomes a fairly entertaining collection of episodes" and concluded that "The Blu-ray offers very good picture quality, good audio, and bonus features. Fans will enjoy season 17." Ron Cerabona of
The Sydney Morning Herald found the season enjoyable and offered plenty of laughs, saying, "It may be past its peak and occasionally show signs of repetition and despair, but this long-running animated series remains one of the funniest and most entertaining programs on television." John Schwarz of
Bubbleblabber gave it an eight out of ten praising the DVD's content and the episode commentary, saying "In any case, hearing
Matt Groening rave about The Simpsons, even after all this time, is a gem in itself, and should not be missed by die-hard Simpsons fans."
Awards "
The Seemingly Never-Ending Story" won an
Emmy for
Outstanding Animated Program, the first
Simpsons episode to win since
season 14's "
Three Gays of the Condo" and the ninth time in the history of the show.
Kelsey Grammer received the Emmy for
Outstanding Voice-Over Performance for "
The Italian Bob". At the
59th Writers Guild of America Awards,
John Frink won the
Writers Guild of America Award for Television: Animation for his script for "The Italian Bob". The writers for "
Simpsons Christmas Stories", "
Kiss Kiss, Bang Bangalore", and "
Girls Just Want to Have Sums" were nominated for the same award. The writers for "
The Girl Who Slept Too Little" and "
See Homer Run" were nominated for the same award at the
58th Writers Guild of America Awards. At the
34th Annie Awards,
Ian Maxtone-Graham won the
Annie Award for Outstanding Achievement for Writing in an Animated Television/Broadcast Production for his script for "The Seemingly Never-Ending Story". At the 16th
Environmental Media Awards, "
The Bonfire of the Manatees" won the award for Television Episodic Comedy.
Nielsen ratings The show ranked 56th in the seasonal ratings tied with
Invasion, ''
America's Funniest Home Videos, and The Amazing Race'' with a viewership 9.2 million viewers and an 18–49
Nielsen Rating of 4.4/11. ==Home media==