Böcklin completed the first version of the painting in May 1880 for his patron
Alexander Günther but kept it for himself. In April 1880, while the painting was in progress, Böcklin's Florence studio had been visited by Marie Berna, née Christ (widow of financier
Georg von Berna (1836–1865) and soon-to-be wife of the German politician
Waldemar, Count of Oriola (1854–1910)). She was struck by the first version of this "dream image" (now in the
Kunstmuseum Basel), which sat half completed on the easel, so Böcklin painted a smaller version on wood for her (now in the
Metropolitan Museum of Art in
New York City). At Berna's request, he added the coffin and female figure, an allusion to her husband's death from
diphtheria years earlier. Subsequently, he added these elements to the earlier painting. He called these works ("Tomb Island"). (Sometimes the Basel version is credited as the first; sometimes the New York version is.) It was acquired by the
Gottfried Keller-Stiftung in 1920. The third version was painted in 1883 for Böcklin's dealer Fritz Gurlitt. Beginning with this version, one of the burial chambers in the rocks on the right bears Böcklin's initials, "A.B." In 1933, this version was put up for sale, and noted Böcklin admirer
Adolf Hitler acquired it. He hung it first at the
Berghof in
Obersalzberg and then, after 1940, in the New
Reich Chancellery in
Berlin. It is now at the
Alte Nationalgalerie, Berlin. Financial imperatives resulted in a fourth version in 1884, which was ultimately acquired by the entrepreneur and art collector Baron
Heinrich Thyssen and hung at his
Berliner Bank subsidiary. It was burned after a bomb attack during
World War II and survives only as a black-and-white photograph. A fifth version was commissioned in 1886 by the
Museum of Fine Arts,
Leipzig, where it still hangs. In 1888, Böcklin created a painting called ("Isle of Life"). Probably intended as an antipole to the
Isle of the Dead, it also shows a small island, but with all signs of joy and life. Together with the first version of the
Isle of the Dead, this painting is part of the collection of the Kunstmuseum Basel. A sixth version, allegedly created in 1901 and acquired in 2022 from a private collection, can be found at the State Hermitage (General Staff building) in Saint Petersburg. It bears the signatures
A. Böcklin invenit ("devised by A. Böcklin") and
Carlo Böcklin fecit 1901 ("executed by Carlo Böcklin 1901"), and can therefore be assumed to be the version mentioned by the
Thieme-Becker biographical dictionary which was started by Arnold Böcklin together with Carlo in autumn 1900.
Versions • May 1880—Oil on canvas; 111 × 155 cm;
Öffentliche Kunstsammlung, Kunstmuseum, Basel. • June 1880—Oil on board; 74 × 122 cm;
The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Reisinger Fund, New York. • 1883—Oil on board; 80 × 150 cm;
Alte Nationalgalerie,
Staatliche Museen zu Berlin. • 1884—Oil on copper; 81 × 151 cm; destroyed in
Berlin during World War II. • 1886—Oil on board; 80 × 150 cm;
Museum der bildenden Künste, Leipzig. • (with Carlo Böcklin) 1901—Oil on canvas; Hermitage (General Staff building), Saint Petersburg. ==Admirers==