Upon its release, the album was met with mixed reviews. At
Metacritic, which assigns a
normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream critics, the album received an
average score 59, based on 10 reviews, which indicates "generally mixed or average reviews". It also holds an aggregate score of 5.0 out of 10 at AnyDecentMusic?, based on 11 reviews. Several reviews considered
Born Villain to be a comeback for the band. Matthew Horton of
Virgin Media described it as "a new step forward, bristling with a vitality that Manson has no right to still have in his locker this far down the line."
Loudwire's Graham Hartmann praised the album as a whole, as did Rick Florino of
Artistdirect, who said: "From top to bottom, it's Manson's most vicious and vibrant effort since
Antichrist Superstar. Make no mistake about it: this is Manson at his best."
Bloody Disgusting ranked it among the band's best work. The band received acclaim for the quality of their songwriting. Fred Thomas of
AllMusic complimented them for disposing of the introspective material which appeared on prior albums and choosing to "accentuate all the throbbing rhythms, metallic guitars and bilious disgust that defined the band's best work." He went on to suggest that
Born Villain could pave the way for future releases. A review for
Blabbermouth said that several tracks were likely to be considered classics among the band's discography. Mayer Nissim of
Digital Spy praised the album for being more fun than previous work, while
Gary Graff from
Billboard applauded it for containing a wide variety of moods and styles. British magazine
Rock Sound complained that the record contained too many long
introductions, which they said disrupted its fluidity. Writing for
NME, Hamish MacBain defined the album as being better than average, saying there was "just a lack of magic, a lack of something special going on. It's not bad. It's not good."
Accolades "No Reflection" earned the band their fourth
Grammy Award nomination, for
Best Hard Rock/Metal Performance. The song's music video won the award for 'Rock Video of the Year' at the
2012 Loudwire Music Awards, while the song itself placed third in their poll for 'Rock Song'.
Born Villain also won the award for 'Rock Album of the Year', and was nominated for 'Album of the Year' at the 2013
Revolver Golden Gods Awards. It also appeared on multiple 'best albums of 2012' lists, including ones for
Kerrang! and Loudwire. ==Commercial performance==