Nichols registered in 1979 with the
Republican Party. In 2016, he described himself as a
Never Trump conservative. During the 2016 presidential campaign, Nichols argued that
conservatives should vote for
Hillary Clinton, whom he detested, because
Trump was "too mentally unstable" to serve as
commander-in-chief. Nichols continued that type of argument for the
2018 midterm elections and advocated that Republicans could save the party by electing as many Democrats as possible in that election. Following the confirmation of
Brett Kavanaugh to the
Supreme Court of the United States, Nichols announced on October 7, 2018, that he would leave the Republican Party to become an independent. He claimed that Senator
Susan Collins's "yes" vote on the confirmation convinced him that the Republican Party exists solely to exercise raw political power. In an opinion column published in 2019, Nichols cited the
Mueller Report to argue that Trump failed in his role as a citizen and then as commander-in-chief, by not doing more to prevent and punish the
Russian interference in the 2016 United States elections. In April 2022, Nichols was quoted regarding the
Russian invasion of Ukraine, stating: "If Putin's goal was to cement his grip on power by making Russia hated for decades to come, well, congratulations, I guess." In October 2025, Nichols appeared on MSNBC's "Deadline: White House" to discuss President Trump's military strikes on suspected drug boats in Pacific and Caribbean waters. Nichols expressed agreement with Senator
Rand Paul, who had condemned the operations as extrajudicial acts. Nichols stated: "Basically the presidentand I want to kind of foot stomp behind Paul here about a planthe American president has said, 'I can point the U.S. military any place I want and kill anyone I want.' That, eventually, is going to become a principle in the domestic use of the military. He is acclimating people to the notion that the military is his private army, unconstrained by law, unconstrained by norms, unconstrained by American traditions." Nichols expressed skepticism about the administration's stated rationale for the strikes, arguing they might not have "anything to do with drugs" and could primarily serve as precedent for expanded executive powers over the military. == Personal life ==