Critical On
review aggregator website
Metacritic,
Toxicity holds a score of 73 out of 100, based on reviews from nine critics, which indicates "generally favorable reviews". Ben Myers of
Kerrang! stated that the band had "gone and bettered" their
debut album and hailed
Toxicity as "metal album of the year, hands down".
Spins Joe Gross wrote that the band "have an undeniable nerd-prog charm".
Uncut, on the other hand, panned
Toxicity as "virtually unlistenable".
Commercial Toxicity peaked at number one on the
Billboard 200, selling 220,000 copies in its first week of release. The album also topped the
Canadian Albums Chart.
Toxicity sold at least 2,700,000 copies in the United States, On July 19, 2022, the album was certified sextuple platinum by the
Recording Industry Association of America. "Aerials" peaked at number one on the
Mainstream Rock Songs chart and number one on the
Alternative Songs chart. "Chop Suey!" and "Toxicity" were both top ten hits. Added to the
2001 Clear Channel memorandum, "Chop Suey!" was temporarily pulled from playlists of most radio stations after the
September 11 attacks in 2001, as it featured some lyrics that
Clear Channel deemed inappropriate following the attacks. The song returned to the airwaves when things settled down.
Accolades The album is listed on
Blender 500 CDs You Must Own.
MusicRadar held a public poll and
Toxicity was ranked as the 28th greatest heavy metal album on its list of The 50 Greatest Heavy Metal Albums of All Time. The album is ranked number 44 on
Rolling Stone 100 Best Albums of the Decade for 2000s and 27th on the magazine's "100 Greatest Metal Albums of All Time".
Toxicity was voted the 27th best album of the year in
The Village Voices annual
Pazz & Jop critics poll for 2001.
Spin named the album one of The 300 Best Albums Of The Past 30 Years, with
Toxicity being one of the highest-listed heavy metal albums on the list.
Spin also named
Toxicity the Album of the Year in 2001, and finally ranked it number 38 on its list of The 40 Greatest Metal Albums Of All Time.
Kludge ranked it number five on their list of best albums of 2001.
Alternative Press ranked it number nine on its 25 Best Albums of 2001. The album won a 2001
Metal Edge Readers' Choice Award for Album of the Year.
Loudwire listed the album at number one on its list of Top 11 Metal Albums of the 2000s, number two on the Top 100 Hard Rock + Metal Albums Of The 21st Century, and number 11 on its list of Top 50 Metal Albums of All Time.
NME listed the album at number six on its list of 20 Greatest Metal Albums Ever.
Metal Hammer declared
Toxicity the best album of 2001.
The Observer ranked
Toxicity as one of the Top 50 Albums Of The Decade, at number 34. In 2007,
The Guardian placed the album on its list of the 1000 Albums To Hear Before You Die.
Entertainment Weekly also put
Toxicity on its list of the 100 Best Albums of the 1983–2008 Period, at number 90.
Revolver named
Toxicity the eighth greatest metal album of all time on its list of the 69 Greatest Metal Albums Of All Time. The album was included on
The A.V. Clubs list of the best metal records of the 2000s.
PopMatters ranked
Toxicity at 62 on its Best Albums of the 2000s list. "Chop Suey!" was nominated for
Best Metal Performance at the
44th Grammy Awards in 2002 and "Aerials" was nominated for
Best Hard Rock Performance at the
45th Grammy Awards the following year. In 2020, the album was included at the 100 Best Albums of the 21st Century list of
Stacker, being ranked at 85. ==Track listing==