Pugmire's writings have been described as a "love letter to Lovecraft" around which he constructed his own universe. Pugmire's fiction has also been described as embracing the gothic with a modern sensibility, not as a look or a style but as "an idea that cut against the naive American faith that the past was absolutely past." Writing for
Weird Fiction Review, Bobby Derie stated that Pugmire "wrote Lovecraftian fiction without the formulaic trappings of the mythos, wrapped in a sensuous prose and characters with easy, fluid sexuality". Issue 28 of
The Lovecraft eZine was devoted to Pugmire—"one of our greatest Lovecraftian writers"—with tributes from
S. T. Joshi,
Joseph S. Pulver Sr., and others; in it, Lovecraftian author and editor
Robert M. Price described Pugmire as "the Oscar Wilde of our time ... the most revered and beloved figure in the Lovecraftian movement today." and a writer who "puts forth a new baroque masterpiece every other year".
Nick Mamatas, in a 2009 interview, stated that Pugmire and
Thomas Ligotti were "the best Lovecraftians today".
Silvia Moreno-Garcia, in a
Washington Post review article, spoke of Pugmire's "decadent, lush prose". S. T. Joshi described Pugmire's writing style as "richly evocative", writing in his scholarly analysis of
Cthulhu Mythos fiction,
The Rise and Fall of the Cthulhu Mythos, that Pugmire's work contains "some of the richest veins of neo-Lovecraftian horror seen in recent years." However, Joshi has been more critical of Pugmire's nonfiction writing, proclaiming "no one takes him seriously as a critic." ''
Asimov's Science Fiction magazine, in their review of Sesqua Valley and Other Haunts'', stated that "Pugmire's devotion to his sources transcends mere pastiche, and his style is neither overwrought nor too sparse."
Publishers Weekly, reviewing
Uncommon Places: A Collection of Exquisites, said that readers "with an appetite for the weird and the decadent will find Pugmire's work a rich confection." The site's review of
Monstrous Aftermath: Stories in the Lovecraft Tradition, stated that "horror fans fond of baroque prose" should enjoy the collection, noting "a knack for injecting gallows humor", but adding that those "looking for memorable plots and vivid characterizations ... will have to look elsewhere."
Fantasy Magazine's review of
The Weird Inhabitants of Sesqua Valley, while observing "the love-it-or-hate-it nature of even the best Lovecraftian style", noted that there were "many pleasures to be had" in the collection of "surprisingly humanistic" tales.
The New York Review of Science Fiction's review of
The Tangled Muse stated that Pugmire's writing revealed "a mastery of language and vocabulary that brings to mind the work of
Clark Ashton Smith", noting a "distinct homoerotic theme or undercurrent that is neither gratuitous nor inconsistent but rather genuine and often central to characterization and storytelling." ==Bibliography==