The album has received varied critical responses both at the time of its release and since. British journalist
Geoff Barton stated in his 1981 five-star review of
Welcome to Hell that the album had "the
hi-fi dynamics of a 50-year-old pizza", and that it "brought a new meaning to the word 'cataclysmic. In the 2013 book
Louder Than Hell,
Scott Ian of
Anthrax is quoted as follows regarding his memories of hearing the album for the first time: "For me and all my friends,
Welcome to Hell was our first exposure to Venom, and it was a huge eye-opener. It was one of those 'holy shit' records. Like, 'Jesus Christ, listen to this, these guys are fucking insane. There were songs like 'Sons of Satan' and the title track. It was so, so evil. This was a new kind of insanity." In 2017,
Rolling Stone ranked
Welcome to Hell as 74th on their list of 'The 100 Greatest Metal Albums of All Time.' The black metal band
Mayhem borrowed their name from the instrumental track "Mayhem with Mercy" and covered the song "Witching Hour" on their
EP Deathcrush. The German
thrash metal band
Sodom also reportedly named themselves in reference to the song "One Thousand Days in Sodom". In addition to covering the song, Canadian parody metal band
Zimmers Hole references "In League with Satan" in the title of their album
When You Were Shouting at the Devil... We Were in League with Satan. American punk rock band
The Meatmen covered "In League With Satan" as the title track on their enhanced CD EP
Evil In A League With Satan. In 1995,
Slayer and
Machine Head did a cover of the song "Witching Hour" in a live concert. ==Track listing==