Bay Shore is one of the older hamlets on Long Island.
Sagtikos Manor, located in
West Bay Shore, was built around 1697. It was used as a British armed forces headquarters, at the time of the
Battle of Long Island during the
Revolutionary War.
President Washington stayed at the
Sagtikos Manor during his tour of Long Island in 1790. The land that would become Bay Shore proper was purchased from the Secatogue Native Americans in 1708 by local school teacher John Mowbray for "several eel spears". In 1840, Bay Shore had one of two churches in the entirety of Islip Town. This was a methodist church built in 1828. In 1850, Bay Shore was one of only two proper hamlets in the entire Town of Islip, along with
Sayville. The hamlet's name has changed over time: Early European settlers referred to the area first as Penataquit and later as Awixa; both were names used by the indigenous
Secatogue. For reasons never documented, the name was changed in the early 19th century to Sodom. In 1842 there was a further name change to Mechanicsville, then a return in 1849 to Penataquit. The change to Penataquit coinciding with a change in the name of the post office to Penataquit. The name Penataquit proved unpopular because it was difficult to spell, and the name of the hamlet and post office was changed to Bay Shore in 1868.
19th and early 20th centuries Bay Shore became renowned in the late 19th century for its shopping district and resorts. The rural hamlet became popular with affluent New Yorkers looking to escape the city to white sand beaches of the
Great South Bay and the fishing villages of
Fire Island. It was a tourist spot on weekends and during the summer, in large part because the newly built
Long Island Rail Road enabled easy access from
New York City. During
World War I it became the headquarters of the
First Yale Unit, a
United States Naval Air Reserve unit.
Post-World War II development The population of Bay Shore increased significantly after
World War II: from the mid-1950s through mid-1960s, a variety of
housing developments were constructed on farms and unused woodlands. Those developments were settled largely by working and middle class first-time home buyers from New York City. Despite strains on the community brought on by sudden, substantial growth, the hamlet remained sound. Main Street continued to be one of the region's most popular shopping destinations.
1970s and 1980s Bay Shore suffered a decline beginning in the late 1970s. Without a local government, residents were unable to make decisions that were instead left to the
Town of Islip and
Suffolk County. The population density and demographics shifted when
rezoning permitted businesses, rental properties and multi-family dwellings where previously only single-family houses had been allowed. Many Main Street storefronts became vacant. Construction of the
South Shore Mall two miles north of Main Street took business away from the small businesses on Main Street.
Deinstitutionalization caused psychiatric patients of the nearby
Pilgrim State Hospital to be hastily relocated to rental housing downtown, often without sufficient professional support.
Restoration and the hamlet today Work to restore Bay Shore has been ongoing since the 1980s. Upscale townhouses and condominiums were built in
gated communities on the grounds of old estates. The former Bay Shore Theater and one-time opera house was renovated and expanded into a
YMCA. The redevelopment of Main Street is ongoing; efforts include new sidewalks, antique-style streetlights, new landscaping and restored parks. Main Street has regained much of its popularity. There are many attractive new restaurants, clothing boutiques and other stores and offices. The Bay Shore Beautification Society transformed an empty lot on Main Street into a
meditation garden in 2007, that has since been recognized for its excellent design. A US
battleship was to have been placed at the Bay Shore Marina. However, the water was deemed too shallow, and instead a decommissioned WWII
torpedo was converted into a monument. The aging
bulkhead and other dock structures at the marina were rebuilt. Over the summer of 2010, a new
water park was built at Benjamin Beach, which sits adjacent to the marina, with a renovated bath house and new landscaping. Abandoned department stores at the Gardiner Manor Mall were razed to make new use of the property. Most of the old mall and adjacent buildings were replaced by new commercial and retail spaces, including a Lowe's home improvement center, a
Target and a
BMW dealership. In 2008 and 2009, new
condominiums replaced
dilapidated housing next to the train station. Additionally, a pedestrian bridge was built over the tracks, and the old tunnel between platforms was closed. ==Geography==