In January 2014,
Miley Cyrus covered the song during the uncensored version of her
MTV Unplugged special. Cyrus' version garnered critical acclaim. According to Stephanie Chase of
Contactmusic.com, she "nailed it". Kimberley Dadds of
BuzzFeed called the version "very, very good" and stated that "It's a nice reminder that she's actually quite good at singing." Merna Jibrail of
AndPOP praised the performance, writing, "Miley brought some British flair to her MTV Unplugged session with her amazing cover of the Arctic Monkeys’ hit." Tom Breihan of
Stereogum praised Cyrus' vocal delivery, writing, "Cyrus’s cover stands tall. She’s got enough swagger and iciness to sell the song, she’s got the technical chops to hit a couple of big notes toward the end, and she sings like she’s knows what she’s singing about." Shannon Carlin provided a positive review, writing, "Cyrus creeps into a deep, southern twang to tell the tale of a rather long night and keeps things a little seedy with her country drawl." Ben Kaye of
Consequence of Sound praised Cyrus' vocals, writing, "Cyrus reached way up high for some powerful ending notes." Amy Sciarretto of
PopCrush provided a positive review, writing, "She hits some power notes in the last few seconds of the song, where she lets it rip." Rae Alexandra from
SF Weekly praised the performance, writing, "She took the laid-back swagger of the original, gave it a sultry, stompy slant, and injected the end of the track with a refreshing kick of passion." Charlie Gowans-Eglinton of
Elle called the cover "brilliant". Writing for
Time, Sam Lansky praised Cyrus' "raspy, tangy vocals and energetic showmanship." During an interview,
Matt Helders, the drummer of Arctic Monkeys, revealed his love for Cyrus' version of the track. Quizzed on his favorite cover version of one of the band's songs, the drummer said: "I think Miley Cyrus' version of 'Why'd You Only Call Me When You're High'... she did some bits in there I wish we'd have done. She gets higher than we can in the voice" Cyrus has also performed the track on selected stops of her
Bangerz Tour. The performance received positive reviews. Andrea Domanick of the
Las Vegas Weekly praised Cyrus' "sleek-and-sexy delivery" of the song. A critic from the
Belfast Telegraph praised Cyrus' vocal performance, writing, "Cyrus has got one hell of a voice, she impressively growled through a cover of Arctic Monkeys' ''Why'd You Only Call Me When You're High''?" ==Track listing==