Season 1 (1959–1960) The Twilight Zone premiered on October 2, 1959, to rave reviews. "
Twilight Zone is about the only show on the air that I actually look forward to seeing. It's the one series that I will let interfere with other plans", said Terry Turner for the
Chicago Daily News.
Daily Variety ranked it with "the best that has ever been accomplished in half-hour filmed television" and the
New York Herald Tribune found the show to be "certainly the best and most original anthology series of the year". While the show proved popular with television critics, it struggled to find a receptive audience. CBS was banking on a
rating of at least 21 or 22, but its initial numbers were much worse. The series' future was jeopardized when its third episode, "
Mr. Denton on Doomsday" earned a 16.3 rating. Still, the show attracted a large enough audience to survive a brief hiatus in November, after which it finally surpassed its competition on
ABC and
NBC and persuaded its sponsors (
General Foods and
Kimberly-Clark) to stay on until the end of the season. However, by the end of the first season the show "seemed doomed" by some. Both sponsors appeared ready to pull out. Even if the show continued, CBS was said to be planning to replace Serling with a more prestigious host and narrator, even offering it to
Orson Welles. Many of the season's episodes proved to be among the series' most celebrated, including "
Time Enough at Last", "
The Monsters Are Due on Maple Street", "
Walking Distance", and "
The After Hours". The first season won Serling an unprecedented fourth
Emmy Award for dramatic writing, a Producers Guild Award for Serling's creative partner
Buck Houghton, a Directors Guild Award for
John Brahm and the
Hugo Award for best dramatic presentation.
Bernard Herrmann's original opening theme music lasted throughout the first season. For the final five episodes of the season, the show's original surrealist "pit and summit" opening montage and narration was replaced by a piece featuring an eye that closed, revealing the setting sun, and shorter narration, and a truncated version of Herrmann's theme. Some first-season episodes were available for decades only in a version with a pasted-on second-season opening. These "re-themed" episodes were prepared for airing in the summer of 1961 as summer repeats; the producers wanted to have a consistent opening for the show every week. During the original 1959/60 run, Herrmann's theme was used in every first-season episode. The first season openings for these episodes have since been restored to recent DVD and Blu-ray reissues although incorrect openings were restored on two episodes, "
Mr. Denton on Doomsday" and "
A Passage for Trumpet".
Season 2 (1960–1961) , who appeared in "
The Hitch-Hiker" and "
The Lateness of the Hour." in "
The Trouble With Templeton" The second season premiered on September 30, 1960, with "
King Nine Will Not Return," Serling's fresh take on the pilot episode "
Where Is Everybody?" The familiarity of this first story stood in stark contrast to the novelty of the show's new packaging: Bernard Herrmann's stately original theme was replaced by
Marius Constant's more jarring and dissonant (and now more-familiar) guitar-and-bongo theme. The closing eye was replaced by a more surreal introduction inspired by the new images in Serling's narration (such as "That's the signpost up ahead"), and Serling himself stepped in front of the cameras to present his opening narration, rather than being only a voice-over narrator (as in the first season). The openings of the first three episodes of the season retained the eye opening's narration. A new sponsor,
Colgate-Palmolive, replaced the previous year's
Kimberly-Clark (as
Liggett & Myers would succeed
General Foods, in April 1961), and a new network executive,
James Aubrey, took over CBS. "Jim Aubrey was a very, very difficult problem for the show," said associate producer Del Reisman. "He was particularly tough on
The Twilight Zone because for its time it was a particularly costly half-hour show... Aubrey was real tough on [the show's budget] even when it was a small number of dollars." In a push to keep the show's expenses down, Aubrey ordered that seven fewer episodes be produced than last season and that six of those being produced would be shot on
videotape rather than film, a move Serling disliked, calling it "neither fish nor fowl." Two additional episodes filmed in the second season ("
The Grave" and "
Nothing in the Dark") were held over to the third season. Season two saw the production of many of the series' most acclaimed episodes, including "
Eye of the Beholder", "
Nick of Time", "
The Invaders", "
The Trouble With Templeton" and "
Will the Real Martian Please Stand Up?". The trio of Serling, Matheson and Beaumont began to admit new writers, and this season saw the television debut of
George Clayton Johnson. Emmys were won by Serling (his fifth) for dramatic writing and by director of photography
George T. Clemens and, for the second year in a row, the series won the
Hugo Award for best dramatic presentation. It also earned the Unity Award for "Outstanding Contributions to Better Race Relations" and an Emmy nomination for "Outstanding Program Achievement in the Field of Drama."
The Twilight Zone was mentioned in
Newton Minow's landmark 1961 speech "
Television and the Public Interest" as one of the few
quality television series on the air at the time in a "vast wasteland" of mass-produced junk, with Minow praising the series as "dramatic and moving." Five weeks into season two, the show's budget was showing a deficit. The total number of new episodes was projected at twenty-nine, more than half of which, sixteen, had already been filmed by November 1960. As a cost-cutting measure, six episodes ("
The Lateness of The Hour", "
The Night of the Meek", "
The Whole Truth",
"Twenty Two", "
Static" and "
Long Distance Call") were produced in the cheaper videotape format, which also required fewer camera movements. In addition, videotape was a relatively primitive medium in the early 1960s; the editing of tape was next to impossible. Each of the episodes was, therefore "camera-cut" as in live TV—on a studio sound stage, using a total of four cameras. The requisite multi-camera setup of the videotape experiment made location shooting difficult, severely limiting the potential scope of the story-lines. Even with those artistic sacrifices, the eventual savings amounted to only $6,000 per episode, far less than the cost of a single episode. The experiment was not attempted again.
Kinescope versions of the videotaped episodes were rerun in syndication.
Season 3 (1961–1962) In his third year as executive producer, host, narrator and primary writer for
The Twilight Zone, Serling was beginning to feel exhausted: "I've never felt quite so drained of ideas as I do at this moment". In the first two seasons he contributed 48 scripts, or 73% of the show's total output; he contributed 56% of this season's output. "The show now seems to be feeding off itself", said a
Variety reviewer of the season's episode two. Sponsors for this season included Chesterfield, Bufferin tablets, and Pepsi-Cola. Despite his avowed weariness, Serling again managed to produce several teleplays that are widely regarded as classics, including
"It's a Good Life",
"To Serve Man",
"Little Girl Lost" and "
Five Characters in Search of an Exit". Scripts by
Montgomery Pittman and
Earl Hamner, Jr. supplemented Matheson and Beaumont's output, and George Clayton Johnson submitted three teleplays that examined complex themes. The episode "
I Sing the Body Electric" was written by
Ray Bradbury. By the end of the season, the series had reached over 100 episodes.
The Twilight Zone received two Emmy nominations (for cinematography and art design), but was awarded neither. It again received the
Hugo Award for "Best Dramatic Presentation", making it the only three-time recipient until it was tied by
Doctor Who in 2008. In spring 1962,
The Twilight Zone was late in finding a sponsor for its fourth season and was replaced on CBS's fall schedule with a new hour-long situation comedy called
Fair Exchange. In the confusion that followed this apparent cancellation, producer Buck Houghton left the series for a position at
Four Star Productions. Serling meanwhile accepted a teaching post at
Antioch College, his alma mater. Though the series was eventually renewed, Serling's contribution as executive producer decreased in its final seasons.
Season 4 (1963) and
Albert Salmi in "
Of Late I Think of Cliffordville." In November 1962, CBS contracted
Twilight Zone (now sans
The) as a
mid-season January replacement for
Fair Exchange, the very show that replaced it in the September 1962 schedule. In order to fill the
Fair Exchange time slot, each episode had to be expanded to an hour, an idea which did not sit well with Serling, nor the production crew. "Ours is the perfect half-hour show... If we went to an hour, we'd have to fleshen our stories, soap opera style. Viewers could watch fifteen minutes without knowing whether they were in a
Twilight Zone or
Desilu Playhouse," Serling responded.
Herbert Hirschman was hired to replace long-time producer Buck Houghton. One of Hirschman's first decisions was to direct a new opening sequence, this one illustrating a door, eye, window and other objects suspended in space. His second task was to find and produce quality scripts. Sponsors included
Johnson & Johnson. This season of
Twilight Zone once again turned to the reliable trio of Serling, Matheson and Beaumont. However, Serling's input was limited this season; he still provided the majority of the teleplays, but as executive producer, he was virtually absent and as host, his artful narrations had to be shot back-to-back against a gray background during his infrequent trips to Los Angeles. Due to complications from a developing brain disease, Beaumont's input also began to diminish significantly. Additional scripts were commissioned from
Earl Hamner, Jr. and
Reginald Rose to fill in the gap. With five episodes left in the season, Hirschman received an offer to work on a new
NBC series called
Espionage and was replaced by
Bert Granet, who had previously produced "The Time Element". Among Granet's first assignments was "
On Thursday We Leave for Home", which Serling considered the season's most effective episode. There was an Emmy nomination for cinematography and a nomination for the
Hugo Award.
Season 5 (1963–1964) Serling later claimed, "I was writing so much, I felt I had begun to lose my perspective on what was good and what was bad". By the end of this final season, he had contributed 92 scripts in five years. This season, the new alternate sponsors were
American Tobacco and
Procter & Gamble. The show returned to its half-hour format. Beaumont was now out of the picture almost entirely, contributing scripts only through the ghostwriters
Jerry Sohl and John Tomerlin, and after producing only 13 episodes, Bert Granet left and was replaced by
William Froug—with whom Serling had worked on
Playhouse 90. in "
Nightmare at 20,000 Feet." Froug made a number of unpopular decisions; first by shelving several scripts purchased under Granet's term (including Matheson's "The Doll," which was nominated for a Writer's Guild Award when finally produced in 1986 on
Amazing Stories); secondly, Froug alienated George Clayton Johnson when he hired Richard deRoy to completely rewrite Johnson's teleplay
Tick of Time, eventually produced as "
Ninety Years Without Slumbering." "It makes the plot trivial," complained Johnson of the resulting script, insisting he be given screen credit for the final version of the episode as "Johnson Smith."
Tick of Time became Johnson's final submission to
The Twilight Zone. Even under these conditions, several episodes were produced that are well remembered, including "
Nightmare at 20,000 Feet", "
A Kind of a Stopwatch", "
The Masks" and "
Living Doll." Although this season received no
Emmy recognition,
An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge—a 1962 French short film which was modified slightly for broadcast—received the
Academy Award for
best short film in 1963. It was based on the
short story of the same name by
Ambrose Bierce; Serling introduces it as "a haunting study of the incredible from the past master of the incredible." In late January 1964, CBS announced the show's cancellation. "For one reason or other, Jim Aubrey decided he was sick of the show… [H]e claimed that it was too far over budget and that the ratings weren't good enough", explained Froug. But Serling countered by telling the
Daily Variety that he had "decided to cancel the network".
ABC showed interest in bringing Serling over to their network to write a more explicitly horror-themed series,
Witches, Warlocks and Werewolves, but Serling was not impressed. "The network executives seem to prefer weekly ghouls, and we have what appears to be a considerable difference in opinion. I don't mind my show being supernatural, but I don't want to be booked into a graveyard every week." Shortly afterwards, Serling sold his 40% share in
The Twilight Zone to CBS, leaving the show and all projects involving the supernatural behind him until 1969, when
Night Gallery debuted. ==Casting==