Factions, 1920 split and aftermath Poale Zion was torn between left-wing and right-wing factions in 1919–1920; the organization formally split at the Poale Zion fifth world congress in Vienna in 1920, following a similar division that occurred in the
Second International. The right wing was less Marxist and more nationalist, and favoured a more moderate socialist program and supported the
International Working Union of Socialist Parties to continue the work of the Second International, essentially becoming a
social democratic party. The left-wing faction did not consider the Second International radical enough, and some accused its members of betraying Borochov's revolutionary principles (although Borochov had begun to modify his ideology as early as 1914, and publicly identified as a social democrat the year before his death). Poale Zion Left, which supported the
Bolshevik revolution, continued to be sympathetic to
Marxism and
Communism, and attended the second and third congresses of the
Communist International in a consultative capacity. They lobbied for membership, but their attempts were unsuccessful, as the internationalist communist movement under
Lenin and
Trotsky was opposed to Zionist nationalism. The
Comintern advised individual members of Left Poale Zion to join their national Communist parties as individuals; at their 1922
Danzig conference, these terms were rejected by the party. The Comintern declared it an enemy of the workers' movement. Poale Zion Left opposed the decision by Poale Zion to rejoin the World
Zionist Organization, viewing it as essentially
bourgeois in character, and viewed the
Histadrut as
reformist and non-socialist. Aside from differing attitudes towards
Zionism and
Stalinism, the two wings of Poale Zion parted ways over
Yiddish and Yiddish culture. The Left was more supportive of the latter, similar to the members of the
Jewish Bund, while the Right bloc identified strongly with the emerging
modern Hebrew movement in the early 20th century.
Palestine In
Palestine, the major leaders of Poale Zion since their immigration in 1906 and 1907 had been
David Ben-Gurion, who joined a local Poalei Tziyon group in 1904 whilst living in
Warsaw, and
Yitzhak Ben-Zvi, a close friend of Borochov and an early member of the
Poltava group. After the split the two
Benim ("the Bens") continued to control and direct Poale Zion Right in Palestine. The party in Palestine split into right and left wings at its February 1919 conference. In October 1919, a faction of the Left Poale Zion founded
Mifleget Poalim Sozialistiim (Socialist Workers Party) which became the
Jewish Communist Party in 1921, split in 1922 over the Zionist issues, with one faction taking the name
Palestine Communist Party and the more anti-Zionist faction becoming the
Communist Party of Palestine. The former retained its links to Poale Zion Left. These two factions reunited as the
Palestine Communist Party in 1923 and become an official section of the
Communist International. Another faction of Poale Zion Left, aligned with the
kibbutz movement
Hashomer Hatzair, founded in Europe in 1919, became the
Mapam party. Poale Zion Right, under Ben Gurion's leadership, formed
Ahdut HaAvoda in March 1919. In January 1930 it merged with another party to become
Mapai, predecessor of the modern
Democrats. The Poale Zion Left continued as a separate party and ran in the
1931 Assembly of Representatives election, led by
1931 Assembly of Representatives election and electing one member to the assembly. In the
1944 Assembly of Representatives election it ran as part of the
Left Bloc with the
Hashomer Hatzair Workers Party on a joint slate that elected 21 representatives. In 1946 the Poale Zion Left merged with the
Ahdut HaAvoda Movement to form the
Ahdut HaAvoda Poale Zion Movement (, ''HaTnu'a LeAhdut HaAvoda Poale Zion''). Two years later the party merged with the
Hashomer Hatzair Workers Party to form
Mapam. Most senior Haganah commanders were Mapam members, including the head of the National Command
Israel Galili who was one of Mapam's leaders. The Palmach was also dominated by Mapam with its commanding officer,
Yigal Allon, and five brigade commanders being members. With the creation of Israel's national army this led to conflict with Ben Gurion. In 1953, after a series of confrontations, two of the four Area Command commanders and six of the twelve brigade commanders resigned. Those members of Mapam who remained,
Yitzhak Rabin,
Haim Bar-Lev and
David Elazar, had to endure several years in staff or training post before resuming their careers.
Bolshevik Revolution and USSR In Russia, the Poale Zion Left participated in the
Bolshevik Revolution and organized a brigade of Poale Zion activists nicknamed the "Borochov Brigade" to fight in the
Red Army. The party remained legal until 1928 when it was liquidated by the
NKVD. Most other Zionist organizations had been closed down in 1919, but Poale Zion Left remained untouched because it was recognized as a Communist party. In 1919, the Communists of Poale Zion Left split to form the
Jewish Communist Party which ultimately joined the
Communist Party of the Soviet Union, leading to a sharp loss of membership in Russia. While the Bund was forcibly disbanded in 1921, Poale Zion and
Hechalutz were allowed to operate freely in the Soviet Union until 1928.
Poland In Poland, for a brief period following World War I, both factions of Poale Zion were reported as legal and functioning political parties. The Polish Left party was the largest Left Poale Zion party in the world. It worked closely with the Bund in developing Yiddish schools in Poland and supporting secular Yiddish culture, although they had political differences (e.g., the Bund was more supportive of the Polish Socialist Party than LPZ). As part of the large-scale ban on Jewish political parties in post-
World War II Poland by the
Communist leadership, both Poale Zion groups were disbanded in February 1950.
Austria In
Austria, the left faction was led by
Michael Kohn-Eber, who joined the
Austrian Communist Party in 1938. The right faction also remained active until 1938.
United States The first Poale Zion group in America was established in 1903. In 1915 it was estimated they had fewer than 3,000 members. After the First World War, the American party was led by veteran socialist Zionist thinker
Nachman Syrkin. In America, the right faction was dominant, and initiated the
National Labor Committee for Palestine, raising money for the Histadrut.
Manya Shochat, one of the Poale Zion leaders in Palestine, toured the United States in 1920. Writing to
Rachel Ben Zvi she estimated there were “maybe” 2,000 members of Poale Zion in the whole country, with 180 of them in New York. She comments “The entire movement here is worthless.”
United Kingdom Poale Zion in Britain formally affiliated to the
British Labour Party in 1920. Its original affiliate status with the Labour Party in 1920 was as The Jewish Socialist Labour Party (Poale Zion).
Worldwide Globally, Poale Zion, under the leadership of
Shlomo Kaplansky, was involved in the 1921 formation of the centrist
International Working Union of Socialist Parties, then between 1923 and 1930 the World Union of Poalei Zion (i.e., the PZ right) joined the
Labour and Socialist International (as its Palestine section). As of 1928, it claimed to have 22,500 members in branches around the world; 5,000 in Poland and the United States, 4,000 in Palestine, 3,000 in Russia, 1,000 in Lithuania, Romania, Argentina and the United Kingdom, 500 in Latvia and another 1,000 scattered across countries such as Germany, Austria, Czechoslovakia, Belgium, France and Brazil. The general secretary of the World Union of Poalei Zion at the time was
Berl Locker. The World Union had a women's wing, the Women's Organization for the Pioneer Women in Palestine.
World Union of Zionists–Socialists (1932) In 1932, Poale Zion's world federation merged with
Hitahdut Olamit, the World Union of
Hapoel Hatzair and
Zeirei Zion, to create
Ihud Olami, the World Union of Zionists–Socialists. During this period several well-known Zionist leaders and politicians were active in Poale Zion, including Ben-Gurion, Ben-Zvi, kibbutz movement leader
Yitzhak Tabenkin,
Jewish Agency Executive member Shlomo Kaplansky, and future Israeli politicians
Moshe Sharett and
Dov Hoz. == The Holocaust ==