Hitler was a leader oriented towards practical politics, whereas, for Rosenberg, religion and philosophy were key and he was the most culturally influential within the party. Several accounts of the time before the Nazi ascension to power speak of Hitler as being a mouthpiece for Rosenberg's views, and he clearly exerted a great deal of intellectual influence. The question of Rosenberg's influence in the Nazi Party is controversial. He was perceived as lacking the charisma and political skills of the other Nazi leaders, and was somewhat isolated. In some of his speeches Hitler appeared to be close to Rosenberg's views, rejecting traditional Christianity as a religion based on Jewish culture, preferring an ethnically and culturally pure "Race" whose destiny was supposed to be assigned to the German people by "Providence". But Hitler rejected Rosenberg's spiritual views on race and instead based his views on biology. After Hitler's assumption of power he moved to unify the churches into a national church which could be manipulated and controlled. He placed himself in the position of being the man to save Positive Christianity from utter destruction at the hands of the
atheistic antitheist Communists of the
Soviet Union. Once in power, Hitler and most Nazi leaders sought to unify the Christian denominations in favor of "positive Christianity". Hitler privately condemned mystical and pseudoreligious interests as "nonsense", and maintained that National Socialism was based on science and should avoid mystic and cultic practices. However, he and
Joseph Goebbels agreed that after the () the
Reich Church should be pressed into evolving into a German
social evolutionist organisation proclaiming the cult of race, blood and battle, instead of
Redemption and the
Ten Commandments of
Moses, which they deemed outdated and Jewish.
Heinrich Himmler's views were among the closest to Rosenberg's, and their estrangement was perhaps created by Himmler's abilities to put into action what Rosenberg had only written. Also, while Rosenberg thought Christianity should be allowed to die out, Himmler actively set out to create countering pagan rituals. Lieutenant Colonel
William Harold Dunn (1898–1955) wrote a medical and psychiatric report on him in prison to evaluate him as a suicide risk: He gave the impression of clinging to his own theories in a fanatical and unyielding fashion and to have been little influenced by the unfolding during the trial of the cruelty and crimes of the party. Summarizing the unresolved conflict between the personal views of Rosenberg and the pragmatism of the Nazi elite: The ruthless pursuit of Nazi aims turned out to mean not, as Rosenberg had hoped, the permeation of German life with the new ideology; it meant concentration of the combined resources of party and state on
total war.
Racial theories As the Nazi Party's chief
racial theorist, Rosenberg oversaw the construction of a human racial "ladder" that
justified Hitler's racial and ethnic policies. Rosenberg built on the works of
Arthur de Gobineau,
Houston Stewart Chamberlain,
Madison Grant and the
Klansman Lothrop Stoddard as well as on the beliefs of Hitler. Rosenberg placed
Blacks and
Jews at the very bottom of the ladder, while at the very top stood the "
Aryan" race. Rosenberg promoted the
Nordic theory which considered the
Nordic race the "
master race", superior to all others, including to other Aryans (Indo-Europeans). He was also influenced by the
Judeo-Masonic conspiracy theory promoted by the Catholic
counter-revolutionary tradition, such as the book
Le Juif, le judaïsme et la judaïsation des peuples chrétiens (1869) by
Roger Gougenot des Mousseaux, which he translated into German under the title
The Eternal Jew. Rosenberg got the racial term from the title of Stoddard's 1922 book
The Revolt Against Civilization: The Menace of the Under-men, which had been adopted by the Nazis from that book's German version
Der Kulturumsturz: Die Drohung des Untermenschen (1925). Rosenberg reshaped the
Nazi racial policy over the years, but it always consisted of
Aryan supremacy, extreme
German nationalism and rabid
antisemitism. Rosenberg also outspokenly opposed
homosexuality – notably in his
pamphlet "Der Sumpf" ("The Swamp", 1927). He viewed homosexuality as a hindrance to the expansion of the "racially pure" Nordic population. Rosenberg's attitude towards
Slavs was flexible because it depended on the particular nation which he referred to. As a result of the ideology of "
Drang nach Osten" ("Drive to the East"), Rosenberg saw his mission as the conquest and colonization of the Slavic East. In
The Myth of the Twentieth Century, Rosenberg describes Russian Slavs as being overwhelmed by Bolshevism. Regarding
Ukrainians, he favoured setting up a
buffer state to ease the pressure on the German eastern frontier, while agreeing with the notion that Russia could be exploited for the benefit of Germany. During the war, Rosenberg was in favour of collaboration with the
East Slavs against Bolshevism and offering them national independence unlike other Nazis such as Hitler and Himmler who dismissed such ideas. Rosenberg criticised those who did not subscribe to his racial theories. For example, he attacked
Fascist Italy for what he perceived as its incorrect and improper stance on race and Jewishness.
Religious theories Rosenberg was raised as a
Lutheran, but he rejected what he called "negative"
Christianity later in life. Instead, Rosenberg argued for a new "religion of the blood", which was based on the supposed innate promptings of the Nordic soul to defend its noble character against racial and cultural degeneration. In his 1920 book
Immorality in the Talmud, Rosenberg identified Jews with the
antichrist. He rejected negative Christianity because of its universality, for its doctrine of
original sin (as he believed that all ethnic Germans were born noble), and for its teachings on the
immortality of the soul, saying, "indeed, absorbing Christianity enfeebled our people." Publicly, Rosenberg affected to deplore Christianity's degeneration owing to its Jewish influence. He took inspiration from
Houston Stewart Chamberlain's ideas and condemned what he called "Negative Christianity" (which was conventional Christianity preached by
Protestantism and
Catholicism), instead Rosenberg was arguing for a so-called
"Positive" Christianity which was based on the argument that Jesus was not a Jew but a member of an Indo-European enclave which was resident in ancient
Galilee who fought against
Judaism. Significantly, in his work explicating the Nazi intellectual belief system,
The Myth of the Twentieth Century, Rosenberg cryptically applauds the early Christian heretic
Marcion (who rejected the
Old Testament as well as the notion of Christ as the Jewish Messiah) and the
Manichaean-inspired, "Aryo-Iranian"
Cathari, as being the more authentic interpreters of Christianity versus historically dominant
Judaeo-Christianity; moreover these ancient, externally Christian metaphysical forms were more "organically compatible with the Nordic sense of the spiritual and the Nordic 'blood-soul'." For Rosenberg, the anti-intellectual, religious
doctrine was inseparable from serving the interests of the Nordic race, connecting the individual to his racial nature. Rosenberg stated that "The general ideas of the
Roman and of the Protestant churches are negative Christianity and do not, therefore, accord with our (German) soul." His support for
Martin Luther as a great German figure was always ambivalent. In January 1934, Hitler appointed Rosenberg cultural and educational leader of the Reich. The
Sanctum Officium in Rome recommended that Rosenberg's
Myth of the Twentieth Century be put on the
Index Librorum Prohibitorum (list of books forbidden by the Catholic Church) for scorning and rejecting "all dogmas of the Catholic Church, and the very fundamentals of the Christian religion". Rosenberg has been described as an
atheist by some people, including
Henry F. Gerecke, the Lutheran chaplain who communed with some of the Nuremberg prisoners with Lutheran backgrounds, like
Joachim von Ribbentrop and
Wilhelm Keitel.
Gustave Mark Gilbert, Rosenberg's prison psychologist during his trial, reports that Rosenberg described himself having "always been anti-Catholic" and criticised the Church's power. Due to his criticism of traditional Christianity, some polemical texts have called him a
neo-pagan. After its use in evidence during the Nuremberg trials, the diary went missing, along with other material which had been given to the prosecutor
Robert Kempner (1899–1993). Kempner had taken the diary, along with several other documents pertaining to the Nazi prosecutions back to his home. This was considered to be against standard government procedure, and illegal. Written on 425 loose-leaf pages, with entries dating from 1936 through 1944, it is now the property of the
United States Holocaust Memorial Museum (USHMM) in Washington.
The New York Times said of the search for the missing manuscript that "the tangled journey of the diary could itself be the subject of a television mini-series." Since the end of 2013, the USHMM has shown the 425-page document (photos and transcripts) on its homepage. ==Personal life==