As an
NGO working on a daily basis with the
United Nations human rights protection mechanisms by submitting to these UN bodies detailed information on serious human rights violations committed by States in the region, Alkarama has often been the victim of defamation campaigns, whilst several members of its staff have been targeted – in their own capacity and not necessarily because of their relation with Alkarama – such as executive director,
Mourad Dhina and legal director,
Rachid Mesli, both victims of international arrest warrants issued by the Algerian government; as well as founding member and former chairman of the Foundation's Council,
Abdulrahman Al Naimi, listed by the
U.S. Treasury as an “
Al Qaeda financier” although the charges were never substantiated. Among others, on 2 September 2014, the Lebanese newspaper, As-Safir published an article entitled The Founder of the Cham Al Islam movement, a prominent activist within Alkarama, which openly accuses Alkarama of "supporting terrorism" and "spreading anarchy". In the following couple of days, these allegations were echoed in the Hezbollah-affiliated Lebanese information channel, Al Manar, in Syrian governmental news sites, RTV.gov and Al Tawra, as well as in Saudi-run news site on Syria, Al Akhbar Al Youm . On 3 September,
Commentary, a magazine founded by the
American Jewish Committee in 1945, accused Alkarama of being run by an "
Al Qaeda financier", in reference to Alkarama's Founder, Mr Abdulrahman Al Naimi. On 14 October 2014, the Swiss newspaper,
Le Temps published an article entitled The town of Geneva funded an NGO accused of links with Al Qaeda , which was relayed by other Swiss media outlets. The article relied exclusively on the unproven listing of one of Alkarama's three founding members as an “
Al Qaeda financier” (see below). A month later,
Le Temps published a feature by Alkarama's Legal Director,
Rachid Mesli, speaking of the difficulty to defend human rights in the Arab World, explaining that in the Arab World, those who dare criticise authoritarian regimes or demand more freedom are accused of terrorism to stifle any criticism or demand to take part in the country's political life.
“It is therefore not surprising that Alkarama, which defends victims of this repression, finds itself vilified and attacked by these regimes; that international NGOs such as the Council on American-Islamic Relations and Islamic Relief find themselves on the UAE’s list of terrorist organisations along with ISIL and Al Qaeda; and that the former Chairman of our Foundation, Dr Abdulrahman Al Naimi, a university Professor, a Qatari human rights activist and a former Amnesty prisoner of conscience be banned from several countries – including the UAE and Saudi Arabia,” explained
Me Mesli. The current president of Alkarama's Board of Trustees, Khalifa al-Rabban, is a Founding Member and Member of the Board of Trustees of the Global Anti-Aggression Campaign (GAAC) alongside Abdulrahman Al Naimi. An online portal for articles on human-rights matters in the Arab World, the GAAC's founding statement, written by Alkarama founding member Abdulrahman Al Naimi, claims that Islam is under siege and that the organisation seeks to confront the Western “aggressor.” GAAC has also hosted Hamas leaders. Alkarama unambiguously and irrevocably denies all these accusations.
2012: Arrest and detention of Mourad Dhina in Paris In 2012, Alkarama's executive director, Dr
Mourad Dhina, who had openly called for democratic change in
Algeria for years was detained in
France for six months on a request from the Algerian authorities to have him
extradited to the country. The French court released him when they received documents from the Algerian authorities, which were so incoherent and lacking any evidence that the French prosecutor qualified them as "grotesque". Dr. Dhina returned to Alkarama after having spent almost 6 months at the
Prison de la Santé in
Paris.
2013: Listing of one of Alkarama's three founding members, Pr. Al Naimi, by the United States Department of the Treasury On 18 December 2013, the
United States Department of the Treasury listed one of Alkarama's three founding members, Pr. Abdulrahman Al Naimi as a “Specially Designated Global Terrorist” for having supposedly
“provided money and material support and conveyed communications to Al Qaeda and its affiliates in Syria, Iraq, Somalia and Yemen for more than a decade.”[1] In addition, the U.S. Treasury claimed that Naimi had “reportedly oversaw the transfer of over $2 million per month to al-Qa’ida in Iraq for a period of time” and “served as an interlocutor between al-Qaida in Iraq leaders and Qatar-based donors.” Speaking to the
Financial Times from
Istanbul, Al Naimi denied the charges leveled against him.
[2] Al Naimi is also a secretary general of the Global Anti-Aggression Campaign, an online NGO that has hosted
Hamas leaders and released anti-Semitic and anti-Western writings. Following the listing, Pr. Al Naimi resigned from the Foundation to avoid any misinterpretation. However, the Alkarama Council decided to reject the resignation of Mr. Al Naimi after initially accepting it. In July 2014, Naimi stepped down as president and Member of the Board of Alkarama. It is important to note, however, that the charges brought by the
U.S. Treasury against him were made against his own person, and not the Foundation. Besides, the U.S. Treasury has not submitted any evidence or proof of its allegations against Pr Al Naimi, who denies all charges as a whole, and is willing, as he officially notified the American authorities, to appear in person before a court to establish the falsity of the charges pressed against him. Al Naimi has, however, received widespread media coverage for his support to terrorist groups.
2014: Listing of Alkarama as a terrorist organisation by the United Arab Emirates On 15 November 2014, the
Emirates News Agency released a list of 85 organisations
“designated as terrorist organisations and groups in implementation of Federal Law No. 7 for 2014 on combating terrorist crimes” issued by Sheikh Khalifa bin Zayed Al Nayhan with the aim to
“raise awareness in society about these organisations.” The list, which includes internationally recognised terrorist organisations, such as
Al-Qaeda or Dae’sh (the
Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant - ISIL), also includes several Muslim associations in Europe and international NGOs, such as the
Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) and
Islamic Relief. “Alkarama organisation” also appears in that list, but despite numerous attempts to contact Emirati officials on this matter, the Alkarama Foundation never received an official confirmation and therefore considers itself not concerned by that listing.
2015: Arrest of Rachid Mesli in Italy Me
Rachid Mesli, Legal Director at Alkarama, was arrested at the Swiss-Italian border on 19 August 2015 on the basis of an
international arrest warrant issued by the Algerian authorities in April 2002, which claims that he had
"provided telephone information to terrorist groups movements," and
"attempted to supply terrorist groups with cameras and phones," twisting his work as a human rights lawyer, in constant contact with victims of human rights abuses and their families. On 22 August, the Italian justice decided to put him under house arrest instead of keeping him in Aosta prison, following several calls from various
NGOs, institutions and personalities, as well as an important media coverage of his case. On 15 September 2015, recognizing Me Mesli's important work in the promotion and protection of human rights in the Arab World, as well as the strong risks of
torture that he would incur if he was extradited to
Algeria, the
Turin Court decided to release him without waiting for the end of the 40-day period by which the Algerian authorities can submit their formal request for
extradition. Eventually, on 16 December 2015, the Italian court rejected the extradition request after noting all the inconsistencies in the
international arrest warrant. The court considered the charges against Me Mesli were the result of
"political persecution" and asserted that
"his human rights activities have nothing to do with terrorism." And on 13 May 2016, the
Commission for the Control of Interpol's Files decided, after a long legal battle, to drop the
international arrest warrant issued in 2003 by the Algerian authorities against Me Mesli, for their lack of cooperation as well as their failure to provide any form of clarification on his case. == Advocacy on behalf of terrorism supporters ==