On release,
Chris Welch wrote in
Melody Maker: "A Number One hit could easily be in store for the maestro of rock drums. There's a touch of the Marc Bolans in this highly playable rhythmic excursion ... It's hypnotic and effective, ideal for
jukeboxes and liable to send us all mad by the end of the week." Alan Clayson writes of reviewers criticising "Back Off Boogaloo" for being repetitious, leading Starr to respond in a 1973 interview: "Play me a pop song that isn't." Writing in 1981,
NME critic
Bob Woffinden commented on Starr's success in establishing himself in the first two years after the Beatles' break-up, and said that the single "confirmed that he and Harrison, dark horses both, were the ones who had managed their solo careers more purposefully and intelligently" compared with McCartney and Lennon. Woffinden described "Back Off Boogaloo" as "every bit as ebullient" as "It Don't Come Easy", although "slightly inferior", In a 1974 article for the
NME,
Charles Shaar Murray highlighted "Back Off Boogaloo" as a "great radio and juke-box tune". Among Beatle biographers, Simon Leng terms it "a rocking, soccer crowd chant that suited Starr's talents well",
Guitar World editor Damian Fanelli includes the song on his list of Harrison's ten best post-Beatles "Guitar Moments", saying of the recording: "the main event is clearly Harrison's slightly wild, wacky – and very bouncy – slide guitar solo, which includes an alternate melody line that's even catchier than the melody Ringo is singing." Andrew Grant Jackson features "Back Off Boogaloo" in his book
Still the Greatest: The Essential Solo Beatles Songs. He says that Starr's mood on the track, while short of the rage that American rapper
Tupac Shakur vented against his rival
Biggie Smalls in "
Hit 'Em Up", "no doubt helped make the tune a staple of football and soccer matches". He comments that the song has "been appropriated" by several artists, including the
glam-metal band
Warrant, in their hit single "
Cherry Pie", and
Franz Ferdinand, in "
Take Me Out". ==Subsequent recordings==