Critical reception Boardwalk Empire has received critical acclaim. For its first and second seasons, the
American Film Institute named
Boardwalk Empire one of the 10 "best television programs of the year". On the
review aggregator website
Metacritic, the first season scored 88 out of 100, The fifth season of the show holds a rating of 88%, with the site's consensus reading: "The final season of
Boardwalk Empire is as visually dazzling and well-acted as ever, but it's the emphasis on Nucky Thompson's history that's particularly rewarding this time out." David Hinkley of the
New York Daily News awarded the series five stars, saying, "Watching HBO's new 'Boardwalk Empire' is like sitting in your favorite tavern and hearing someone say, 'Drinks are on the house.' Friends, it does not get much better." Paige Wiser of the
Chicago Sun-Times called it "... an event not to be missed," and praised Buscemi in particular, calling his performance "fascinating".
Variety's Brian Lowry praised the show for returning network HBO to top form, saying, "This is, quite simply, television at its finest, occupying a sweet spot that—for all the able competition—still remains unique to HBO: An expensive, explicit, character-driven program, tackling material no broadcast network or movie studio would dare touch ... For those wondering when the channel would deliver another franchise to definitively put it on top of the world, Ma, the wait is over: Go directly to
Boardwalk." "One of the unexpected joys of
Boardwalk Empire, though, lies in the way the show revels in the oddities of its time, peeling back the layers of polite society to reveal a giddy shadow world of criminals and politicians collaborating to keep the liquor flowing," says online magazine ''
Salon's Heather Havrilesky, who went on to call the pilot "breathtaking". Roberto Bianco from USA Today said in his review that Boardwalk Empire
was "Extravagantly produced, shockingly violent and as cold and hard as ice, Boardwalk Empire'' brings us back to the world's former playground at the start of Prohibition—and brings HBO back to the forefront of the TV-series race." The second season received widespread acclaim. Verne Gay from
Newsday stated that "
Mad Men, of course, remains the King of the Emmys, while
Empire nailed the equally prestigious Golden Globe for best drama last winter. But Sunday begins to build the case for
Empire, and build it convincingly." Matt Roush of
TV Guide stated, "This is a gorgeous piece of storytelling that requires and rewards patience." Brian Lowry stated in his review for
Variety that: "A few creative flourishes feel a trifle heavy-handed – starting with Shannon's philandering fed. Unlike Nucky, though,
Boardwalk isn't campaigning for anything except the gratitude of a pay-cable audience (and award voters) eager to take refuge in its sordid charms. By that measure, the show doesn't just go down smoothly; it's good to the last illicit, intoxicating drop." Nancy Franklin of
The New Yorker considered Buscemi miscast as the central figure in the drama. "Buscemi can't play that kind of character; even at the age of fifty-two, he looks cagey and restless—not like a guy at the top but like the guy who gets killed when he tries to knock off the guy at the top." The review concludes "
Boardwalk Empire is at great pains to give viewers a sense that they are there, and yet rarely did I feel engrossed in the show. Even if its point is to show you the ugly side of fun,
Boardwalk Empire should be much more fun to watch." Alessandra Stanley of
The New York Times review states that "surprisingly, given the extraordinary talent and money behind it,
Boardwalk Empire falls short. One possible reason is that the star, Steve Buscemi, is hard to accept in the lead role of Enoch Thompson," going on to observe "it takes a lot of squinting to see him as a powerbroker straddling two worlds."
Awards and nominations On July 14, 2011, for the
63rd Primetime Emmy Awards,
Boardwalk Empire was nominated for 18
Primetime Emmy Awards for the first season that included
Outstanding Drama Series,
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series (Steve Buscemi), and
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Drama Series (Kelly Macdonald), with Martin Scorsese winning Outstanding Directing for a Drama Series, along with seven other wins at the
Creative Arts Emmy Awards.
Boardwalk Empire won the
Writers Guild of America Award for Best New Series and was nominated for Best Dramatic Series. In addition, the show won the
Golden Globe Award for Best Television Series – Drama and Steve Buscemi won Best Actor – Television Series Drama, while Kelly Macdonald was nominated for Best Supporting Actress – Series, Miniseries, or Television Film. The cast won the
Screen Actors Guild Award for Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series in 2011 and 2012, while Steve Buscemi won for Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Drama Series as well in 2011 and 2012, for the first and second season. In 2011, Martin Scorsese won the
Directors Guild of America Award for Outstanding Directing – Drama Series for the pilot.
Boardwalk Empire was also listed in the
American Film Institute's Top Ten List for Television in 2010 and 2011 for the first and second season.
Boardwalk Empire also won two awards at the 9th Annual Visual Effects Society Awards. The first for Outstanding Supporting Visual Effects in a Broadcast Program and second for Outstanding Models & Miniatures in a Broadcast Program or Commercial. The former was received by Richard Friedlander (of Brainstorm Digital),
Robert Stromberg, Paul Graff and David Taritero; the latter was received by Brendan Fitzgerald, John Corbett and Matthew Conner of Brainstorm Digital. The show's Season One Soundtrack won the
Grammy Award for
Best Compilation Soundtrack for Visual Media in
2012. For the second season,
Boardwalk Empire won once again for the
Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Directing for a Drama Series for
Tim Van Patten for the season finale "
To the Lost", along with three other wins at the
Creative Arts Emmy Awards. For the third season,
Bobby Cannavale won the show's first acting award at the
65th Primetime Emmy Awards for
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Drama Series for his portrayal of Gyp Rosetti, along with four other wins at the
Creative Arts Emmy Awards.
Ratings On its original airing, the pilot episode gained a 2.0/5 ratings share among adults aged 18–49 and garnered 4.81 million viewers. The episode was re-played twice that night, once at 10:15 p.m. and again at 11:30 p.m. Taking these broadcasts into account, a total of 7.1 million Americans viewed the episode on the night of its original broadcast, and is the highest rated premiere for an HBO series since the pilot of
Deadwood in March 2004. The
season finale was watched by 3.29 million viewers, attaining a 1.3 rating adults aged 18–49. The second-season premiere was watched by 2.91 million viewers, down 39% from the pilot and down 12% from its first-season finale. ==See also==