Allegations of bias Several outlets and politicians over many years have accused
CBC News of bias. Surveys have found the Canadian public perceives a centre-left/Liberal Party bias in CBC News coverage.
Falun Gong and Beyond the Red Wall In November 2007, the CBC replaced its documentary about
persecution of Falun Gong members in China,
Beyond the Red Wall: Persecution of Falun Gong, The documentary aired two weeks later on November 20, 2007, after editing.
CBC President's comparison of Netflix's influence to colonialism In January 2019 CBC President
Catherine Tait came under fire for comparing
Netflix to colonial
imperialism in
India and parts of
Africa. Tait did not offer an apology and
Heather Mallick defended her comparison. Tait's comments made American headlines with J.J. McCullough of
The Washington Post suggesting that "the state-sponsored" corporation shielded her from criticism and that the Canadian industry "was built in part as a bulwark against American influence". Canadian TV critic
John Doyle, who has long criticized what he perceives as the low standards of Canadian programming, claimed that CBC had a problem of complacency rather than imperialism.
Closed captioning CBC Television was an early leader in broadcasting programming with
closed captioning for the
hearing impaired, airing its first captioned programming in 1981. Captioned programming in Canada began with the airing of
Clown White in English-language and French-language versions on CBC Television and Radio-Canada, respectively. Most sources list that event as occurring in 1981, while others list the year as 1982. In 1997, Henry Vlug, a deaf lawyer in Vancouver, filed a complaint with the
Canadian Human Rights Commission (CHRC) alleging that an absence of captioning on some programming on CBC Television and
Newsworld infringed on his rights as a person with a disability. A ruling in 2000 by the
Canadian Human Rights Tribunal, which later heard the case, sided with Vlug and found that an absence of captioning constituted
discrimination on the basis of disability. The Tribunal ordered CBC Television and Newsworld to caption the entirety of their broadcast days, "including television shows, commercials, promos, and unscheduled news flashes, from sign-on until sign off". The ruling recognized that "there will inevitably be glitches with respect to the delivery of captioning", but that "the rule should be full captioning". In a negotiated settlement to avoid appealing the ruling to the
Federal Court of Canada, the CBC agreed to commence 100% captioning on CBC Television and Newsworld beginning November 1, 2002. CBC Television and Newsworld are the only broadcasters in the world required to caption the entire broadcast day. However, published evidence asserts that CBC is not providing the 100% captioning ordered by the Tribunal. In 2004, Canadian retired senator
Jean-Robert Gauthier, a hard-of-hearing person, filed a complaint with the CHRC against Radio-Canada concerning captioning, particularly the absence of real-time captioning on newscasts and other live programming. As part of the settlement process, Radio-Canada agreed to submit a report on the state of captioning, especially real-time captioning, on Radio-Canada and
RDI. The report, which was the subject of some criticism, proposed an arrangement with
Cité Collégiale, a college in Ottawa, to train more French-language real-time captioners. English-language
specialty networks owned or co-owned by CBC, including
documentary, have the lower captioning requirements typical of larger Canadian broadcasters (90% of the broadcast day by the end of both networks' licence terms).
ARTV, the French-language specialty network co-owned by CBC, has a minimum captioning requirement of 53%.
2013 Radio-Canada rebranding On June 5, 2013, the CBC announced that it would be phasing out the Radio-Canada brand from its French-language broadcast properties, and unifying them under names prefixed with "
Ici" ('this is' or literally 'here'). For instance, the CBC planned to re-brand
Télévision de Radio-Canada as "
Ici Télé",
Première Chaîne as "
Ici Première", and move its French-language website from
Radio-Canada.ca to
ici.ca. Radio-Canada vice-president
Louis Lalande stated that the new name complemented its multi-platform operations, while also serving as an homage to the broadcaster's historic
station identification slogan since the 1930s, "
ici Radio-Canada" ('this is Radio-Canada'). , the corporation's French-language radio network The announcement was criticized by politicians (such as
Minister of Canadian Heritage James Moore), who felt that the new "Ici" brand was too confusing, and that the CBC was diminishing the value of the Radio-Canada name through its plans to downplay it. The re-branding was also criticized for being unnecessary spending, reportedly costing $400,000, in the midst of budget cuts at the CBC. On June 10, in response to the criticism,
Hubert Lacroix apologized for the decision and announced that the new brands for its main radio and television networks would be revised to restore the Radio-Canada name alongside Ici, such as "
Ici Radio-Canada Première". In March 2013, the CBC also filed a
trademark lawsuit against Sam Norouzi, founder of
CFHD-DT—a new multicultural station in Montreal—seeking to have Norouzi's registration on the name "ICI" (as an abbreviation of "International Channel/Canal International") cancelled because it was too similar to its own "Ici"-related trademarks. Despite Norouzi's trademark having been registered prior to the registration of CBC's, the corporation argued that Norouzi's application contained incorrect information surrounding his first use of the name in commerce, and also asserted the long-time use of "Ici Radio-Canada" as part of its imaging. Norouzi stated that he planned to fight the CBC in court.
Suspension of local newscasts during the COVID-19 pandemic On March 18, 2020, in the wake of the
COVID-19 pandemic, CBC News suspended all of its English-language
local newscasts (excluding those carried by
CBC North, which include an English-language newscast and a second in
Inuktitut), replacing them in their time slots with
simulcasts of
CBC News Network. The CBC stated that this was done in order to pool its local resources to CBC News Network as a "core news offering". An employee memo suggested that a lack of staff at the
Canadian Broadcasting Centre and "much stricter newsgathering protocols" were another factor in the decision. The
Canadian Media Guild stated that the decision "flies in the face of past experience which has proven time and again that in times of significant events, Canadians trust and rely on CBC news coverage, particularly for its widespread coverage of regional and local impact, something no other Canadian network can match". The
Toronto Star similarly wrote that the CBC had "decided to bail on local communities across the country". On March 24, the CBC announced that it would introduce "an expanded 30-minute local news segment on CBC News Network" beginning March 25, and would "make every effort to have all of the dedicated local shows back up on the main network". In May 2021, Radio-Canada commissioned a documentary to better understand the dissident movement led by
Dave Leduc and three other Quebec personalities that rejected the health measures imposed by the government surrounding
COVID-19 pandemic in Quebec. The documentary was a finalist for the
Prix Gémeaux.
CBC Tandem and branded content Since 2016, the CBC has utilized
branded content, publishing advertisements that are designed to look, read or sound similarly to news produced by the CBC itself. In 2020 the CBC formally launched a division called Tandem that focused its branded content marketing efforts, promising corporate clients they can "leverage" the CBC's reputation by aligning their message with the "trust Canadians have in our brand". Over 500 current and former employees called on CBC management to end Tandem, saying "in an era of 'fake news', where misinformation is already rife, it undermines trust ... what's worse, it uses [Canadians'] tax dollars to do it." In November 2020 former employees requested that the
Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission investigate Tandem as part of the public broadcaster's upcoming licence renewal, concerned the content blurs the lines between advertising and news, adding that "Canadians have a right to a national public broadcaster that puts their news and information needs ahead of the desires of corporate clients." Private sector media criticized the CBC's ability to dominate the Canadian advertising market, using tax-funded subsidies to unfairly compete with local newspapers and broadcasters, driving them out of business. The CRTC decision has been criticized as allowing the CBC to disregard its mandate as a public broadcaster, transforming into a "publicly funded commercial broadcaster".
Kenneth Muzik verdict On December 15, 2021, Manitoba Bench Justice Herbert Rempel ordered the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation to pay investment advisor Kenneth Wayne Muzik nearly $1.7 million in damages for a story it had aired in June 2012 featuring a former client, William Worthington, who complained about the performance of his investment portfolio. Muzik was represented by William Gange of Gange Collins Holloway. In March 2022, Rempel ordered CBC to pay nearly $300 thousand to cover Muzik's legal fees. In 2023, the Manitoba court of appeal overturned Rempel's decision, stating that the CBC acted in the public interest when reporting on the investment adviser. "Given the public interest aspect of the story, the CBC performed a satisfactory investigation into the status and reliability of its main source, the Worthingtons," the appeal court decision says. "For the trial judge to dismiss the plaintiff's conduct and his regulatory problems in his assessment of the reputation the plaintiff held at the time of the publication is a failure to give proper effect to relevant evidence," the appeal court's decision said regarding Justice Rempel's assessment of Muzik's history as an advisor. While the appeal court agreed that the stories were defamatory, it found that the trial judge erred by failing to appreciate that there was a public interest element to the stories, given that they dealt with risks to investors and the regulation of financial planners.
WE Charity v. CBC On February 8, 2022,
WE Charity's
New York-based affiliate filed a lawsuit against the CBC for defamation. The 230-page complaint was filed in the
United States District Court for the District of Columbia, where the case was assigned to
district judge Randolph D. Moss.
Dominion Voting Systems, originally a Canadian company, choose to sue
Fox News Network in the United States, ultimately settling for $787.5 million. Similarly, WE Charity, whose American operations are incorporated in
Williamsville, New York, sued the CBC in the United States, in both instances despite the hurdle of the "actual malice" standard established in
New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, which is unique to American law and requires that the defendant either knew that or did not care if its representations were false. According to the CBC annual revenue report, 70.6% of revenue came from parliamentary spending in 2019–2020, while 65.6% of revenue came in 2021–2022, and 66.7% came in 2023. On May 9, 2023, the CBC announced that it would resume partial activity on some of its Twitter accounts.
Travis Dhanraj resignation Travis Dhanraj, the former host of CBC News program
Canada Tonight, alleged in 2025 that he was forced to resign by CBC after he raised issues such as a lack of diversity of opinion and editorial imbalance in its political coverage. CBC spokesperson Kerry Kelly said the corporation "categorically rejects" Dhanraj's allegations. Dhanraj's lawyer, Kathryn Marshall, said that the CBC did not want him booking "Conservative voices" on his show. == See also ==