Critical reception Degrassi: The Next Generation has received generally positive reviews.
Entertainment Weekly has called it "a cult hit", and
The New York Times named it "Tha Best Teen TV N da WRLD (The best teen TV in the world)". Of the first season,
The Ottawa Citizen Tony Atherton had mixed feelings of the new incarnation, saying it "has a cleaner, more polished look, has lost its edge [and offers] nothing new to viewers familiar with the groundbreaking
preceding series, nor to anyone else who has watched the deluge of teen dramas since ... there is a sense of déjà vu with regards to the plots and characters". Before its debut in the United States,
The Seattle Times Melanie McFarland wondered whether the series would do well, writing: "soft-pedaling through the issues might work for today's family of viewers, but what's gentle enough for Mom and Dad's peace of mind might not be enough to hook Junior or the original
Degrassi's older fans". The issues that the characters experience have often been commented on in the media. It has been noted that the series never attempts to hide from depicting honest accounts of the trials and tribulations that real teenagers may often experience. Sarah Liss from
CBC News said that despite often being corny and soap opera-y,
Degrassi: The Next Generation tackles issues that other genre series prefer to gloss over, and was part of her essential viewing. She named the series one of "the [ten] most important television shows of the 2000s", and was the only children's series, and the only Canadian television series, to appear on the list, which included
Mad Men,
Lost, the
CSI franchise, and
Sex and the City. Brian Orloff of the
St. Petersburg Times echoed the sentiments, and praised the series for "stay[ing] in touch with teens' lives". In spite of these comments, Noggin/The N held back a controversial episode from the first season, which showed a character losing control after taking an ecstasy pill. According to Stohn, "the people at Noggin felt there weren't enough repercussions to the drug use, so we re-edited it and added some dialogue to satisfy the network." The N also refused to broadcast two episodes from the second season that featured a storyline about date-rape until suitable edits could be made, and withheld other episodes from season three that showed a fourteen-year-old character having an
abortion after having consensual
sexual intercourse with her boyfriend, and feeling no regrets. The decision caused an uproar amongst fans who organized a petition that caught the attention of the
New York Times, as well as CBC, the
National Post and the
London Free Press in Canada. The episodes eventually aired three years later as part of an "every episode ever"
marathon, with very little advertisement from the network. Another storyline was featured in the media after ten children from a
Québécois school were found to have a number of cuts on their bodies. They said they had copied the show when one character began
self harming herself in an episode. Comparisons between
Degrassi: The Next Generation and other genre specific series have also been made throughout the run. Jake Surette, a writer with
AfterElton.com, a website which focuses on the portrayal of homosexual and
bisexual men in the media, reported on the portrayal of two
Degrassi: The Next Generation gay characters. "
Degrassi features ongoing stories of real-life teen dilemmas—including intense gay and lesbian storylines—and does it without the righteous, 'On a Very Special
Blossom endings that many teen dramas and sitcoms thrive on." Kevin Thompson of
The Palm Beach Post said the series "is told from a teenager's point of view since the writers have no interest in appealing to a broad-based demographic like the writers on, say, Fox's
The O.C. ... it connects with teens on their level".
PopMatters's Jodie Janella Horn also compared it with
The O.C., saying that while scenes from
Degrassi could be "actual scenes from my actual teenage life ...
The O.C. will never remind me of anything in my life", adding that it is the most unnervingly accurate series ever of the high school genre. The
San Jose Mercury News has said "If they [
Everwood,
The O.C., and
One Tree Hill] want to be taken seriously, the shows could take a cue from Canadian drama
Degrassi: The Next Generation, which ... addresses the same gritty teen issues without being far-fetched". The
New York Times has also made favourable reviews of the series in comparison to
Everwood,
The O.C., and
One Tree Hill, as well as
Beverly Hills, 90210,
Gilmore Girls, ''
Dawson's Creek, and adult series such as Sex and the City, Maude, and Six Feet Under''.
AOL TV ranked it as the sixth TV's Biggest Guilty Pleasure.
Television ratings With characters from
Degrassi Junior High and
Degrassi High appearing in
Degrassi: The Next Generation, viewers of the earlier series who were in their 20s and 30s made up a dedicated fan base of the current incarnation. Approximately 40% of the series' viewers are outside of
Degrassi: The Next Generations 12- to 17-year-old target audience.
Degrassi: The Next Generation averaged 365,000 viewers aged 12–20 years old in season one, and became the most watched domestic drama in Canada. By the end of season two, it had become the most popular Canadian show for the three youngest age groups (children aged 2–11, teenagers aged 12–17 and young adults aged 18–34). In the third season,
Degrassi: The Next Generation was again the most-watched all-Canadian drama series, and the most watched Canadian drama among adults 18–49. A season four episode that featured a school shooting received 930,000 viewers; at that time it was the programme's highest-ever rating. A second episode in the same season that featured a storyline about
oral sex also earned just under 1,000,000 viewers. It averaged 250,000 viewers in the US in 2004 and was the highest rated digital cable series in the US in 2006. While that figure was still far lower than successful shows on the "big four" networks (
ABC,
CBS,
Fox and
NBC), the premiere episodes of earlier seasons had achieved higher audience numbers with females aged 12–34. The fifth season drew in an average of 767,000 viewers, with episode two of the season was seen by 1,000,000 viewers. Ratings began to decline halfway through the series' run. In Canada, season six was watched by fewer viewers than had watched season five; The season finale was watched by 520,000 viewers, and the season overall averaged 522,000 viewers. This progressively dropped over the coming weeks, from 446,000 total viewers for the third episode, to 407,000 total viewers for the fifth episode, and continued to fall to a low of 314,000 viewers by the tenth episode. Overall, the first twelve episodes of the season averaged 455,000 viewers, 45,000 less than the same number of episodes from the season six. almost 200,000 viewers fewer than what the premiere of season seven achieved. Viewing figures continued to drop when episodes two and six were both watched by an average of 220,000 viewers. At the time they were the lowest figures
Degrassi: The Next Generation has ever received; The overall number of viewers rose slightly for the thirteenth episode, the first of a two-parter, when it was watched by 157,000 people, but the viewing figures for the key 18–34 demographics was at a low of 81,000. The following week, the episode that concluded the two-parter picked up viewers, reaching an estimated total of 206,000. Brioux commented again about
Degrassi: The Next Generation still being on the schedules, wondering when CTV was going to announce its cancellation and noting that
The Amazing Race, which follows it in the scheduling, was watched by ten times the number of
Degrassis viewers. CTV aired two episodes back-to-back in the first half of season nine, and the scheduling had improved ratings. The first two episodes earned a combined figure of 471,000 viewers, and the third and fourth episodes retained them; they were watched by a combined 475,000 viewers. The following week, the total viewing figures for episodes five and six had increased to 608,000, and remained high as the season went into
hiatus in November with 572,000 total viewers.
Awards Degrassi: The Next Generation has received numerous awards and nominations. The
Writers Guild of Canada awarded its
Canadian Screenwriting Awards to the writers of two episodes. In 2004, Aaron Martin, James Hurst and Shelley Scarrow won the "Best Youth Script Award" for "
Pride". The following year, the Scarrow-penned episode "
Secret" vied with "
Mercy Street", written by James Hurst and Miklos Perlus for the "Best Youth Script Award". "Mercy Street" won. The series has been nominated for fourteen
Directors Guild of Canada Awards. In the "Outstanding Achievement in a Television Series – Children's" group category, the Bruce McDonald helmed "
Mother and Child Reunion" (nominated 2002) and "
When Doves Cry" (nominated 2003) were winners. "
White Wedding", also directed by McDonald, won the award in 2003 for "Outstanding Achievement in Direction – Television Series". "
Can't Hardly Wait" and "
Pass the Dutchie" were also nominated in that category in 2007 and 2008, respectively, but failed to win the awards. Stephen Withrow picked up two awards in the "Outstanding Achievement in Picture Editing" category, for "Mother and Child Reunion" in 2002 and "When Doves Cry" in 2003. In 2010, producer
Linda Schuyler received the
Academy Achievement Award.
Degrassi: The Next Generation had also seen awards success internationally. It was nominated for a "Best Children's Television Programme" Prix Jeunesse in Germany in 2004, and has been nominated at the
GLAAD Media Awards four times. In 2004, the show received a nomination in the Outstanding Drama Series category, but lost to the sports drama
Playmakers. It was nominated in the same category again in 2008, but lost to
Brothers & Sisters. In 2005,
Degrassi: The Next Generation won the
Television Critics Association Award for "Outstanding Achievement in Children's Programming." It was only the second time that a non-United States series has won an award in this category (the first time was
Degrassi Junior High in 1988). The
Young Artist Awards had been recognising actors in the
Degrassi franchise since 1987.
Degrassi: The Next Generation was nominated for four awards in its first year. Ryan Cooley and Jake Goldsbie were nominated in the "Best Leading Young Actor Performance in a TV Comedy Series" category, but lost to
Frankie Muniz from
Malcolm in the Middle. The series won the award for "Best Ensemble in a Comedy or Drama TV Series" category. A year later, Jake Epstein won the Young Artist Award in the category for "Best Leading Young Actor Performance in a TV Comedy Series". In 2005, Christina Schmidt tied with
Alia Shawkat of
Arrested Development to win the award for "Best Supporting Young Actress Performance in a TV Comedy Series", and Jamie Johnston won the 2008 category for "Best Leading Young Actor Performance in a TV Series". Young Artist Awards were awarded again in 2012, with both
Cristine Prosperi and
A.J. Saudin winning awards in the Lead Young Actress and Recurring Young Actor categories respectively. However, they both tied with another in their category. At the
Teen Choice Awards, children aged between twelve and nineteen vote for each category's winner. The series was nominated three times in the "Choice Summer TV Show" category, and won twice, in 2005 and 2007. The episode "
My Body Is a Cage", where Adam was
outed as
transgender, earned a
Peabody Award, and a
Creative Arts Emmy Award nomination in 2011. ==References==