As the cradle of organized baseball, New York City had many clubs in the "amateur" era leading up to 1869–1870, and the "professional" era after that.
Knickerbocker, Mutual and
Gotham were some of the more prominent clubs. The short-lived
Federal League entry in New York was the
Brooklyn Tip-Tops. The Fed teams had some innovative names, and this was probably the only major league team ever named for a loaf of bread.
New York Mets Since the amateur Metropolitan Base Ball Club was founded in New York as far back as 1857, three years before Athletic of Philadelphia, the Mets can claim to have the oldest team name in major-league baseball. The first professional
Metropolitan Baseball Club was a member of the 19th Century
American Association, lasting until 1887, but unable to compete with the Giants. They were normally listed as "Metropolitan" in the standings, and writers would sometimes use the pluralized "Metropolitans" or just "Mets" in the style of the day, to distinguish them from the "New Yorks", their next-door neighbors. The Metropolitans were never referred to as "New York." When major league baseball expanded in 1962, the old name was revived in the form of the Metropolitan Baseball Club of New York, otherwise known as the
New York Mets. "Met" is a common short form of "Metropolitan", as in "The Met" for the
Metropolitan Opera; "MetLife" for the
Metropolitan Life Insurance Company; and so on. The
New York Jets of the
NFL, originally known as the New York Titans, were the first of several New York area teams whose names rhymed with "Mets". Others included the
New York Nets of the
ABA (now the Brooklyn Nets of the
NBA), and the New York Sets of
World Team Tennis.
New York Giants First official use: 1911 The early entry of this team in 1883 was simply the
New Yorks, also sometimes called the
Gothams, "Gotham" being a synonym for New York City. According to legend, manager
Jim Mutrie was bragging to newspaper reporters about the stature of his players, "My big fellows! My giants!" and by about 1885 the name was stuck on the team for good. :"The club was first called the
Giants about 1885. P.J. Donohue,
New York World baseball writer, probably picked up a chance to get into a type argument with Harry Palmer of Chicago and Charles F. Mathison of Detroit. All three scribes followed teams that had big men, were proud of that fact, and stressed the poundage and height of their athletes. The New York Nationals, after playing an exhibition game with Newark in 1886, were called Giants; and when they appeared in St. Louis later the same year, Joe Pritchard, Mound City expert at that time, alluded to them as the
Gotham Giants." (TSNBBG) The problem with that story is that the Giants nickname was already in use in newspapers by 1884. By 1885, it was well-established in the press. Although unofficial for a long time, it remains one of the oldest team names in MLB. "Giants" was one of the only team nicknames used with any frequency at all in 1886 newspaper writeups, and the only team nickname,
period, found in Spalding's Official Guide for 1889. However, the team's official name, as printed on its scorecards, remained simply the New York Base Ball Club. Although the "Giants" nickname was well established, it wasn't endorsed by the franchise until they put it on the home programs for the 1911 World Series; the prosaic "NEW YORK" or simple block letters "NY" were used on uniform shirts until 1918 when "GIANTS" first appeared. (Okkonen) Eventually the alternate nickname "Jints" (rhymes with "pints") was picked up as a colloquial pronunciation of the team name. It followed them, along with their real nickname "Giants", when they moved to the west coast in 1958. The
New York Giants of the
NFL were named for the baseball team which was once their landlord. Even though the baseball Giants moved in 1958, the NFL team to this day displays a sign at
MetLife Stadium proudly indicating that the team's official name remains the "New York Football Giants."
New York Yankees Modern writers tend to refer to the New York AL club as the "
Highlanders" for its 1903–1912 era and as the "
Yankees" from 1913 onward. The two nicknames actually developed in parallel starting around 1904, with "Highlanders" initially more often used, and "Yankees" becoming the predominant nickname before "Highlanders" was fully dropped in 1913. Initially the team was simply the "Greater New York Baseball Club", a designation imposed on them as part of the "deal" allowing the Baltimore club to transfer to New York. Giants fans considered them to be "Invaders", and publisher
William Randolph Hearst's
New York Evening Journal initially referred to the new club by that name in 1903. Both "Highlanders" and "Yankees" were also initially inventions of the press. The first president of the new New York American League entry was Joseph Gordon, who served from 1903 to 1906. There was a noted British military unit called
The Gordon Highlanders. The new team built its new ballpark on a high point of Manhattan called "The Hilltop" (hence the informal nickname "
Hilltop Park" for the American League Park), which contrasted especially with the altitude of the Giants, whose
Polo Grounds was in the bottomland in the shadow of Coogan's Bluff. Creative members of the press, who liked to make artificial connections between disparate elements of popular culture, dubbed the team "Gordon's Highlanders" (e.g. New York
World, April 15, 1903), soon shortened to just "Highlanders", and the name stuck with them for the better part of a decade. There is no evidence that "Highlanders" was ever officially adopted by the team itself. The uniforms only sported a large block "N Y", which eventually evolved into the well-known curving NY logo of the Yankees. (Okkonen) A prophetic letter to the editor of the New York
Sun, May 7, 1903, p. 8, raised this question: "
Name for the American New Yorks. If the new baseball team is to have a name that is in keeping with the 'Giants,' does it not seem reasonable that if they are the 'New York Americans' they might be called the 'Yankees' or 'Yanks'?" The alternate nickname "Yankees" first appeared regularly in the press in 1904. The term "
Yankee" or "Yank" is a synonym for "American". The new team was in the American League, and the papers for cities with two teams (such as Boston) would often call their teams "Nationals" or "Americans" to distinguish them. The term "Yankee" was also in the news frequently at that time, especially with the success of
George M. Cohan's Broadway musical,
Little Johnny Jones, and its centerpiece number, "Yankee Doodle Dandy". To the creative writers of the New York press, the connection was easy to make. On April 7, , a spring training story from
Richmond, Virginia carried the headline "Yankees Will Start Home From South To-Day." The
New York Evening Journal screamed: "YANKEES BEAT BOSTON".
The Sporting Life for a game of April 4, 1905, discussing the acquisition of
Hal Chase, referred to the team as the "Americans" and the "Highlanders" in the same writeup. As the decade progressed, the nickname "Yankees" began to be used more and more often.
The New York Times writeup about
Cy Young's no-hitter of June 30, 1908, referred to the club exclusively as "Yankees" or "Yanks" throughout the article, with no mention at all of "Highlanders". The
Times also consistently referred to the Hilltop by its formal name, "the American League Park". (
The Complete Book of Baseball: A New York Times Scrapbook History, Arno Press, Bobbs-Merrill, 1980, p. 8)
The Philadelphia Inquirer for a game of April 21, 1912, an exhibition between the two New York clubs, was headlined "Giants wallop Yanks", while in the article the teams were referred to as the "Nationals" and the "Giants"; and "the American League team", "Americans", and "Highlanders"; respectively.
The New York Times for opening day 1912 reported that "The Yankees presented a natty appearance in their new uniforms of white with black pin stripes." In 1913, the American Leaguers left the Hilltop after ten years, and began what would become a ten-year sub-lease with the Giants at the Polo Grounds. At that point the term "Highlanders" made no logical sense, and was dropped by the press. The club was exclusively the "Yankees" from then onward. It is uncertain exactly when the Yankees began referring to themselves by their popular nickname. By the time of
Babe Ruth's arrival in 1920, the "Yankees" nickname was well established, but the name still did not appear on the uniforms. In fact, the Yankees have seldom carried their nickname on their uniforms. The only time was during 1927–1930, when the word "YANKEES" first appeared, in lieu of "NEW YORK" – on the
road shirts. This was continued through the 1930 season, and then "NEW YORK" was restored to the road uniforms. (Okkonen) The name must have been considered 'official' at least by 1923, when the team named its new ballpark Yankee Stadium. The popular and successful Yankees have acquired many other unofficial nicknames through the years, such as the "
Pinstripers" for obvious reasons, and jokingly as the "
Evil Empire", a term originally applied to the Soviet Union by President
Ronald Reagan. Probably the longest-lasting unofficial nickname has been the "
Bronx Bombers", which was applied many decades ago in reference to the Yankees' power hitting, dating back to the Ruth era. One early newspaper usage came in July 1928. ==Oakland==