"Homecoming" was met with mixed reviews from
music critics. Giving the song four out of five stars in Digital Spy, Nick Levine described it as the "emotional centrepiece" of
Graduation, commenting that West shows his humanity and Martin provides "a pomp-filled piano riff" with undertones of English singer and composer
Elton John. Jackie Im of
Treblezine declared that the song exceeded his expectations, praising Martin's vocals on the hook for their heavy catchiness and his piano as reminiscent of Elton John, summarizing it as a "nice little pop song that leads into Kanye's most earnest moment".
Pitchfork Mark Pytlik wrote that the song seemingly "hits all the right notes", aided by Martin. Vadim Rizov from
Slant Magazine said the song is among West's strongest rapping on the album and quipped that in contrast to Jay-Z's collaboration with Martin on "Beach Chair", West may be able to "make Coldplay acceptable for the cool kids again".
Ann Powers, for the
Los Angeles Times, also held the belief that West bests Jay-Z's utilization of Martin's "reedy pipes".
Paste reviewer Ross Bonaime wrote that West's usage of Martin is the most successful and they are a "undeniably pretty great" duo, although found it weird hearing the singer sing of Chicago as home.
Exclaim! Del Cowie remarked that "Homecoming" lacks the level of emotion that a "hometown ode should elicit", attributing this to Martin's "yodelling soccer yob". Labeling the track as one of the album's transgressions, Noah Love of
Chart Attack stated that it would be better without the singer's crooning and considered West was still finding his lyrical potential.
Chicago Tribune music critic
Greg Kot dismissed Martin's vocals and the "cornball piano riff", feeling that the song fails and results in the album's biggest misstep. Some reviews of the song were not focused on Martin's vocals. While he upheld the belief that
Graduation did not meet its expectations, Kyle Ryan of
The A.V. Club wrote that the song is an example of "its usual share of West gold".
NOW Magazine editor Jason Richards labeled the song as the highlight of the album. At
Stylus Magazine,
Jayson Greene expressed that the usage of "Home" for the song is the album's prime example of West's "narrow lyrical focus" of reiterating his older works and strongly demonstrates he has not left his defining moment, despite "a big, stadium-ready beat". To honor West's 39 birthday in June,
The Jamaica Observer composed a list of his top 10 best songs and placed "Homecoming" 10th. In 2017,
CraveOnline ranked "Homecoming" as West's best song; the staff summarized that the instrumentation is the highlight and combined with the topic of his love for Chicago, makes for a "high point". "Homecoming" was declared the 50th greatest
Chicago rap song by
Complex. For
Chart Attacks list of ''Kanye West's 10 Most Stripped-Down, Minimal Songs'', head writer Jordan Darville ranked it at number four. Discussing the track's lyricism, he mentioned it is among the introspectiveness of
Graduation that is "much more deeply felt". "Homecoming" received a nomination for Best R&B/Hip-Hop Track at the
2008 Teen Choice Awards. ==Music video==