Maya received moderately positive reviews from critics. At
Metacritic, which assigns a
normalised rating out of 100 based on reviews from mainstream critics, the album received an
average score of 68 based on 41 reviews, which indicates "generally favorable reviews". Simon Vozick-Levinson of
Entertainment Weekly called the album "surely the year's most divisive major-label release". Matthew Bennett of
Clash gave a similar score, calling it a "towering work".
Mojo writer Roy Wilkinson called it a "startling fusillade of to-the-moon pop music". Writing for the
BBC Online, Matthew Bennett characterised the album as "loud, proud, and taking no prisoners" and also praised the album's lighter tracks, such as "Teqkilla", which he called "enjoyably demented but utterly catchy".
Rolling Stone writer Rob Sheffield said the album was M.I.A.'s "most aggressive, confrontational and passionate yet", praising her "voracious ear for alarms, sirens, explosions, turning every jolt into a breakbeat" and her consequent lyrics as "expansive".
Los Angeles Times writer Ann Powers commended the album as "an attempt by an artist who's defined herself through opposition to engage with the system that she has entered, for better or worse, and to still remain recognizable to herself" characterising
Mayas foregrounded ideas as "a struggle worthy of a revolutionary". In his consumer guide for
MSN Music, critic
Robert Christgau gave the album an A rating and complimented its "beats and the spunky, shape-shifting, stubbornly political, nouveau riche bundle of nerves who holds them together". Other critics were not as complimentary towards the album. Charlotte Heathcote of British newspaper the
Daily Express said that, while M.I.A. could "still lay claim to being one of our most imaginative, uncompromising artists", there were "only glimmers of brilliance" on the album.
Chicago Tribune writer
Greg Kot gave the album two and a half out of four stars and expressed a mixed response towards M.I.A.'s "[embracing] pop more fervently than ever.
Entertainment Weeklys Leah Greenblatt was critical of the album, stating that it sounded "murky and almost punishingly discordant, as if the album has been submerged underwater and then set upon by an arsenal of exceptionally peeved power tools". She went on to state that nothing on the album sounded "truly vital", or as revolutionary as M.I.A. wanted the public to believe. Stephen Troussé, writing in
Uncut, described the album as "anticlimactic" and "self-satisfied" and said that it suffered from "diminished horizons". Mehan Jayasuriya of
PopMatters noted M.I.A.'s "self-aggrandizing" as a weakness, adding that
Maya lacks "the focus and confidence of M.I.A.'s previous albums". Jesse Cataldo of
Slant Magazine noted that the album "has the feel of a vanity project" and wrote "It may be an above-average album, but its aesthetic matches her persona only at its shallowest levels, in the thinness of its ideas and the often-forceful ugliness of its message". Chris Richard of
The Washington Post called it "a disorienting mix of industrial clatter and digital slush" and noted "there isn't much to sing along to".
Accolades In December 2010,
NME named "XXXO" and "Born Free" the number two and number 11 best tracks of the year respectively.
Maya appeared in a number of magazines' lists of the best albums of the year. The album was placed at number five on the "2010
Pitchfork Readers Poll" list of the "Most Underrated Album" of the year.
Spin placed
Maya at number eight in its list of the best releases of 2010, and
Rolling Stone listed it at number 19 in its countdown.
Legacy In 2013, in light of recently
leaked NSA documents that revealed the agency had been surveilling US citizens' internet use through Google and
Facebook, M.I.A. made a
Tumblr post saying she had correctly predicted this sort of spying in her song "The Message". Carrie Battan of
Pitchfork noted that the then-widespread "criticisms of M.I.A.'s politically charged words and alleged paranoia" could now "seem just as silly as her lyrics once might have". On
Maya's tenth anniversary, journalists opined that the album's "internet aversion and overstuffed sound" aged well and could be considered a precursor to the industrial distortion of albums like
Yeezus (2013) by
Kanye West. ==Commercial performance==