1977–1979: Defamation suit from Lee Kuan Yew After the
1976 general election,
Lee Kuan Yew demanded an unconditional apology from Jeyaretnam for making the following remarks in a speech during the lead-up to the election: Lee filed a defamation suit against Jeyaretnam in court when the latter refused to apologise. Lee and Jeyaretnam were represented in court by
Queen's Counsels
Robert Alexander and
John Mortimer respectively, with the latter defending Jeyaretnam
pro bono.
1983–1986: Convictions for making false statements In December 1983, Jeyaretnam and
Workers' Party chairman
Wong Hong Toy were charged with falsely declaring the party's accounts. They were also accused of defrauding
Tay Boon Too, a PAP Member of Parliament whom the Workers' Party had unsuccessfully sued for defamation in 1972. The suit had been dismissed by
High Court judge
Frederick Arthur Chua, who had also ordered the Workers' Party to pay Tay's legal costs amounting to S$14,000. In early 1984, senior district judge Michael Khoo found Jeyaretnam and Wong guilty of one of the four charges they faced but acquitted them of the other three. After both the defendants and the prosecution appealed against the judgement, the case was heard in May 1984 by Chief Justice
Wee Chong Jin. In April 1985, Wee found Jeyaretnam and Wong guilty of two of the three charges they had been acquitted of earlier, and fined them S$2,000 each. He also ordered a retrial for the offence of making a false declaration. noting in their judgement: After the JCPC's judgement, Jeyaretnam requested President
Wee Kim Wee to remove his convictions. However, the President, constitutionally bound to act in accordance with the
Cabinet's advice, denied the request, so Jeyaretnam remained disqualified from participating in parliamentary elections until 1991. After the election, Lee sued Jeyaretnam for
slander, alleging that Jeyaretnam implied that he had abetted Teh's suicide and covered up corruption. In August 1990,
High Court judge
Lai Kew Chai ruled against Jeyaretnam and ordered him to pay Lee
damages of S$260,000 with interest on the amount and costs.
1995–2001: Defamation suits from Tamil PAP MPs and others In November 1995, Jeyaretnam and the Workers' Party's central executive committee faced two defamation suits. The first was from five
PAP Members of Parliament of
Tamil origin, including Foreign Affairs Minister
S. Jayakumar. The plaintiffs included Senior Minister
Lee Kuan Yew, Prime Minister
Goh Chok Tong, and Deputy Prime Ministers
Lee Hsien Loong and
Tony Tan. The lawsuits came after Tang had accused the plaintiffs of lying when they labelled him as "anti-Christian" and "Chinese chauvinist" during the campaigning period. Jeyaretnam had also said during a rally speech, During the trial, which started on 18 August 1997, Jeyaretnam and Goh were represented by
Queen's Counsels
George Carman and Thomas Shields respectively. On 20 August 1997, Carman accused Goh of lying and challenged his assertions that Singapore was a democracy. During
cross-examination by Carman, Goh likened Jeyaretnam's statement to throwing a
Molotov cocktail. However, on further questioning, Goh also stated that "it has been a good year" for him and his standing as a leader had not been injured. The trial generated much public interest, with representatives from the
International Commission of Jurists and
Amnesty International in attendance as observers. The
Amnesty International representatives who observed the trials said that the lawsuits were politically motivated. Goh commenced
bankruptcy proceedings against Jeyaretnam after he failed to pay an instalment, but discontinued them later with S$31,000 still outstanding. The following day,
Kenneth Jeyaretnam called Henson's confession "brave" and said that it "provided
prima facie evidence of corruption" in the 1997 lawsuits against his father. He also said that the unauthorised leaks had allowed the plaintiffs to claim aggravated damages, and that his father's lawyer
George Carman could have used the unauthorised leaks in his defence.
2001–2007: Bankruptcy On 23 and 25 July 2001, the
Court of Appeal dismissed two
bankruptcy appeals from Jeyaretnam after he failed to pay instalments on time for the damages arising from the earlier defamation lawsuits. As undischarged bankrupts are barred from serving in Parliament, Jeyaretnam lost his seat as a
Non-constituency Member of Parliament on 25 July 2001. He was also
disbarred. To pay off his debts, Jeyaretnam went onto the streets to sell copies of two books he wrote:
Make It Right for Singapore and
The Hatchet Man of Singapore. The first book contains the texts of some of his parliamentary speeches from 1997 to 1999, while the second describes his trials. In 2003, he told the
Associated Press that he had managed to sell as many as 10 copies of
The Hatchet Man of Singapore each time he went out, and that the first 2,000 copies had been almost sold out. In May 2007, Jeyaretnam was discharged from bankruptcy after he paid the remaining sum of S$233,255.78 owed to his creditors. == J B Jeyaretnam Foundation ==