Elected mainly for Yankee service •
Ed Barrow, General Manager, 1921–46 •
Yogi Berra, C-LF, 1946–63; MGR, 1964, 1984–85 •
Jack Chesbro, P, 1903–09 •
Earle Combs, CF, 1924–35 •
Bill Dickey, C, 1928–43, 1946; MGR, 1946 •
Joe DiMaggio, CF, 1936–42, 1946–51 •
Whitey Ford, P, 1950, 1953–67 •
Lou Gehrig, 1B, 1923–39 •
Lefty Gomez, P, 1930–42 •
Joe Gordon, 2B 1938-1943, 1946 •
Rich "Goose" Gossage, P, 1978–1983, 1989 •
Waite Hoyt, P, 1921–30 •
Miller Huggins, MGR, 1918–29 •
Derek Jeter,SS, 1995-2014 •
Willie Keeler, RF, 1903–09 •
Tony Lazzeri, 2B, 1926–37 •
Mickey Mantle, CF, 1951–68 •
Joe McCarthy, MGR, 1931–46 •
Herb Pennock, P, 1923–33 •
Mariano Rivera, P, 1995-2013 •
Phil Rizzuto, SS, 1941–42, 1946–56 •
Red Ruffing, P, 1930–42, 1945–46 •
Babe Ruth, RF, 1920–34 •
CC Sabathia, P, 2009-2019 •
Casey Stengel, MGR, 1949–60 •
George Weiss, General Manager, 1947–60 •
Dave Winfield, LF-RF, 1981–88, 1990 Elected for service with other teams, as well as the Yankees •
Frank Baker, 3B, 1916–19, 1921–22 •
Carlos Beltrán, RF, 2014–16 •
Wade Boggs, 3B, 1993–97 •
Roger Bresnahan, C, 1901–02 •
Frank Chance, 1B-MGR, 1913–14 •
Stan Coveleski, P, 1928 •
Leo Durocher, MGR (2B-SS, 1925, 1928–29) •
Clark Griffith, P-MGR, 1903–07 •
Burleigh Grimes, P, 1934 •
Bucky Harris, MGR, 1947–48 •
Rickey Henderson, LF, 1985–89 •
Catfish Hunter, P, 1975–79 •
Reggie Jackson, RF, 1977–81* •
Andruw Jones, LF, 2011–12 •
Joe Kelley, CF, 1902 (Baltimore) •
Bob Lemon, MGR, 1978–79, 1981–82 •
Joe McGinnity, P 1901–02 (Baltimore) •
John McGraw, MGR (3B-MGR, 1901–02) •
Johnny Mize, 1B, 1949–53 •
Phil Niekro, P, 1984–85 •
Gaylord Perry, P, 1980 •
Tim Raines, LF, 1996–98 •
Iván Rodríguez, C, 2008 •
Wilbert Robinson, C, 1901–02; MGR, 1902 (Baltimore) •
Joe Sewell, 3B, 1931–33 •
Enos Slaughter, LF, 1954–55, 1956–59 •
Ichiro Suzuki, RF, 2012–14 •
Dazzy Vance, P, 1915, 1918 •
Paul Waner, RF, 1944–45 (Affiliation according to National Baseball Hall of Fame; Reggie Jackson is affiliated with the Athletics, but wears a New York Yankees cap ) ==Major League Baseball awards==