Keeley was one of the top three racquetball players in the world from 1971 to 1976 and in the top ten until 1979, while winning seven NPA National
Paddleball Titles. Keeley won the National
Paddleball Singles Championship in 1971, 1973, 1974, 1976 and 1977. He captured the National Paddleball Doubles Championship in 1974 with Len Baldori and in 1976 with Andy Homa. Keeley was the second player in history to win a Professional
Racquetball Tournament after Steve Serot, when he defeated
Charlie Brumfield 21-8, 21-17 in the finals of the NRC Long Beach Pro Am in October 1973. Keeley won the Canadian National
Racquetball Singles Championship in November 1974 defeating
Bud Muehleisen in the final. Keeley won his last Professional
Racquetball Title in 1980 defeating
Marty Hogan 21-5, 21-6 in the finals of the Voight Championship in Los Angeles. During his racquetball career, he defeated every US National Singles Champion from 1968–1982, and every professional champion of his era including ex-housemates
Marty Hogan (Racquetball),
Charlie Brumfield and
Bud Muehleisen, as well as, Bill Schultz, Bill Schmidtke, Craig Finger, Davey Bledsoe and Mike Yellen. He became one of the game's foremost instructors and an author during the 1970s golden era with approximately 100 articles published in
Ace, IRA Racquetball,
National Racquetball and other trade magazines. In 2002, he refused induction into the USRA Hall of Fame. where incumbent inductees credited him with instructing their games. He was the 2003 racquetball
historian and
psychologist for the Legends pro tour, and the same year co-invented (with
Scott Hirsch) Hybrid Racquetball using a racquetball with wood paddleball paddles. He wrote what many have called the Bible of the sport,
Complete Book of Racquetball (1976, 200,000 sold), and opened racquetball doors in every state, Central and South America with hundreds of clinics and exhibitions, once beating
Miss World runner-up with a
Converse tennis shoe in a
Sports Illustrated exhibition, and others with a seven-inch mini-racquet. Keeley was a stroke and strategy
trendsetter, and the first apparel-sponsored pro, flaunting multicolored
Converse Chucks tennis shoes. He was featured in
Sports Illustrated and other publications as an unusual combination of athlete, intellectual, and 'flake.' Also a California B-division
handball champion, Keeley is the only player to consistently beat handball legend
Paul Haber in mano a racqueta exhibitions. He started a silent
scholarship fund of personal prize money plus contributions to bring rising East Coast stars to train at the racquetball mecca, Gorham's Sports Center in San Diego, California. In 2007 he was awarded the prestigious NPA Earl Riskey Trophy for contributions to the sport. Inducted into the NPA Hall of Fame in 2014 ==Author and publisher==